For a yaoi manga to be good with a supernatural plot, it needs a unique and engaging supernatural concept, strong character chemistry, and a plot that keeps you hooked. The supernatural aspect should enhance the story rather than overshadow the relationship between the characters.
The combination of supernatural elements adds an extra layer of mystery and excitement. It gives unique plot twists and unexpected scenarios that make the manga more engaging.
I'd recommend 'Given'. It has a touching and engaging plot that really draws you in.
The ability to evoke emotions is another factor. A good yaoi manga story should make you feel something, whether it's joy, sadness, or excitement. In 'Love Stage!!', the cute and clumsy moments of the main character make you laugh, while the moments of self - discovery and the development of his relationship with the idol create a sense of warmth and anticipation. If a story can make you invested in the characters' emotions, it's likely to be a good story.
The plot and character development. Maybe it has an engaging story and well-rounded characters that draw you in.
A good yaoi manga story often has well-developed characters with depth and complexity. It also typically features an engaging plot that keeps you hooked and maybe some unexpected twists.
I'd recommend 'Given'. It has a touching and complex plot that keeps you hooked.
You could try 'Koisuru Boukun.' It has a unique and interesting plot that explores various themes and has well-written characters that draw you in.
'Junjou Romantica' is a good choice. The plot is well-developed and full of sweet and heartwarming moments.
I'd recommend 'Love Tension'. It has a compelling plot with interesting character developments and unexpected twists.
Supernatural yaoi manga often features elements like magic, paranormal creatures, and intense romantic relationships between male characters.