One reason could be that the themes explored by James Tynion are not very compelling or relevant to a wide audience. Also, the way they handle cliffhangers and resolutions might disappoint some readers.
James Tynion IV is a significant figure in Comic Vine for his notable contributions to various comic book series and his unique storytelling style.
It could be that the art style has evolved or the themes explored are more contemporary. But to know for sure, you'd have to check it out yourself.
Fan fiction can sometimes limit a writer's creativity as they might rely on existing characters and worlds instead of creating their own from scratch.
James Tynion has made notable contributions to the Batman universe within Detective Comics. His work often explores complex character dynamics and adds depth to the storylines.
The 'bad meat comic' might be considered bad because of a number of reasons. Maybe the plot is confusing and hard to follow. Or the drawing style doesn't appeal to the audience. Also, the themes it presents could be uninteresting or inappropriate.
It could be that the bad Spiderman comic has bad dialogue, doesn't have enough action, or fails to connect with the audience. Any of these could make it get a bad reputation.
Comic Sans is often seen as bad because it's too informal and childish for many serious or professional settings.
It might be due to poor storylines or unappealing art styles.
It might be seen as bad due to weak plotlines or inconsistent character development.
A bad Superman comic could be the result of poor pacing, unconvincing villains, or a failure to capture the hero's charm and moral code. Maybe it just didn't resonate with the current audience's expectations and tastes.