Set the mood. Dim the lights or use candles. Have everyone sit in a circle on the floor with blankets. The atmosphere can make the story seem scarier. For example, if you're telling a story about a haunted house, the dim lighting can make it feel like you're all in that spooky place. You can also add sound effects like creaking doors or howling wind. There are apps that can play these sounds. It'll make the slumber party scary stories more immersive and thus scarier.
Use a spooky voice. When you tell the story in a low, raspy or trembling voice, it adds to the fear factor.
You can use a really quiet and suspenseful voice when telling the story. For example, when you get to the scariest part, slow down your speech and lower your voice to a whisper. This can make the listeners feel more on edge.
You can also use props. If you're telling a story about a monster in the woods, have some fake branches or leaves around. Maybe even a fake claw or something. And as you tell the story, use the props to enhance the description. For instance, if the monster is approaching, move the branches like it's pushing through them. This will engage the listeners' senses more and make the story seem scarier.
Well, to make a scary story scarier, start by creating a sense of isolation for the characters. Add elements of the unknown and build suspense by hinting at something awful without revealing it right away. And don't forget to play with the lighting and sounds in your descriptions to enhance the creepy atmosphere.
You can use sound effects. For example, play some creaking door sounds or howling wind noises in the background while telling the story. It'll add to the spooky atmosphere.
Pause at the right moments. Build up suspense by pausing just before the big scare. For instance, if you're about to reveal the monster in the closet, stop for a few seconds. Let the listeners' imaginations run wild with anticipation. And when you finally reveal it, it'll be much scarier. Also, describe the details vividly, like the smell of decay in a haunted house or the cold touch of a ghostly hand on someone's shoulder.
Use different voices for different characters in the story. For example, if there's a scary old man in the ghost story, use a deep, raspy voice when you're telling that part. It adds to the atmosphere.
One scary slumber party story is about a haunted doll. A group of girls were having a slumber party and found an old doll in the attic. That night, they heard the doll giggling and moving on its own. They were so scared that they locked the doll in a closet, but the giggling continued until morning.
The 'The Babysitter and the Man Upstairs' is also a well - known slumber party scary story. A babysitter is taking care of kids at night. She keeps getting strange phone calls from someone asking if she's checked on the children. When she finally calls the police, they tell her to get out of the house immediately because the calls are coming from inside the house.
Add more details about the spooky setting. Like if it's set in a cemetery, describe the broken tombstones, the mist hovering over the graves, and the cold wind that seems to whisper. This will enhance the scariness.
Build suspense. Don't give away the scariest parts too soon. Describe the setting and the characters in detail first. For instance, if it's a haunted house story, talk about how the old floorboards creak, how the walls seem to be closing in, and how the air is cold and musty. Then gradually introduce the spooky elements one by one.