Maybe he got into too many fights. Natsu has a short temper and if there were other students in the academy who provoked him or if he was standing up for someone, he might have engaged in brawls that the academy doesn't tolerate. In a place like Fairy Tail Academy, they might have strict rules about student behavior regarding fighting.
One possible reason could be a misunderstanding. Maybe someone framed Natsu for a crime he didn't commit, like stealing a powerful magical item from the guild. And the guild, without proper investigation, decided to kick him out. Another reason might be his recklessness. If his actions put the guild in great danger too many times, the guild masters could decide that he's a liability and kick him out.
One possible reason could be that he's framed for a crime he didn't commit. Maybe someone planted false evidence to make it seem like he was endangering the guild. Another reason might be that his power got out of control and the guild, fearing for the safety of its members, made the tough decision to kick him out.
It could be because of a conflict with the academy's rules. Natsu is a bit of a rebel. If the academy has strict rules that go against his sense of justice or freedom, he might decide to drop out. For example, if they forbid him from using his dragon - slayer magic in a certain way. Another reason could be that he feels he can learn more on his own or from other non - academy sources. He might think that the real - world experiences and challenges are better for his growth as a wizard than staying in the academy.
One possible reason could be a misunderstanding. Maybe someone framed Lucy for something she didn't do, like stealing a powerful magic item from the guild. Another reason might be that she accidentally broke a very important and unbreakable guild rule without realizing it. For example, if there was a rule about not using a certain type of dark magic, and she unknowingly used it to save a friend.
One reason could be that some writers might want to create a more complex or darker storyline. By having Natsu be hated, it adds conflict. Maybe they portray him as having made a big mistake that the other characters in the fanfic can't forgive.
One possible reason could be a conflict with other guild members. Maybe there's a misunderstanding or a fight that makes Natsu feel he no longer belongs. Another reason might be that he has a personal mission that goes against the guild's rules or values in the fanfiction. He could also be framed for something he didn't do and, feeling betrayed, decides to drop out.
One possible reason could be a misunderstanding. Maybe there was a miscommunication during a mission, and the other members of Team Natsu thought Lucy made a big mistake. For example, if she accidentally led the enemy to their hiding place. Another reason might be jealousy. If Lucy's celestial spirit magic started to gain too much attention and overshadowed the others in some way, they could have decided to kick her out. However, this is all just speculation based on the idea of this fanfiction scenario.
Natsu would probably be very angry at first. He loves Fairy Tail like a family, so being kicked out would feel like a huge betrayal. He might go on a rampage, shouting and arguing with the guild members who made the decision.
Perhaps she was kicked out due to personal conflicts within the pack. If there were other members who didn't like her or were jealous of her for some reason, they might have spread false rumors or convinced the pack leaders to expel her. It could also be that she was in a relationship that the pack disapproved of, and as a result, they decided to kick her out.
Perhaps Percy was kicked out because of a prophecy that the camp elders misinterpreted. They thought that Percy's presence would bring great danger to the camp, so they made the hasty decision to expel him. It could also be that there was some sort of political intrigue within the camp. Some powerful figures at the camp might have seen Percy as a threat to their power and influence, and so they fabricated reasons to get him kicked out.