The appeal lies in the fact that there is so much room for creativity. Their relationship is full of potential for different storylines. Fans can take their vampire nature and create stories about how they deal with the challenges of being vampires together. Also, their moral compasses, which are somewhat different yet intertwined, can be a great source for interesting fanfiction, as it allows for exploring ethical dilemmas and how they face them as a 'family'.
One reason is the complex relationship between them. Carlisle is like a father and mentor to Edward. Fans like to explore this relationship further in fanfiction. They can create different scenarios that show more of their emotional bond.
Edward and Carlisle have a very unique connection in the Twilight series. In fanfiction, it allows fans to expand on their shared history. For example, how Carlisle turned Edward and what led to their current relationship. It also gives a chance to explore their different personalities and how they interact in various situations that were not fully explored in the original books or movies.
Many fans would likely be divided. There would be those who are open to new interpretations and might find it an interesting take on the characters. However, a large portion would probably be against it as it goes against the established love story between Bella and Edward. They might feel that it changes the essence of the characters as they were presented in the original books.
It's appealing because fans love the relationship between Bella and Edward. When Bella misses Edward, it intensifies the emotional connection they have. Fans are drawn to the raw emotions and the idea of a love so strong that it persists even when they're apart.
It's appealing because it allows fans to explore more of Edward's character. In the original 'Breaking Dawn', there are still parts of his personality and experiences that are left somewhat unexplored. Fanfiction fills those gaps.
There's also 'A Father's Love: Carlisle and Edward'. This fanfic focuses on the deep, father - son bond between them. It shows how Carlisle's unwavering support helps Edward through various challenges in their vampire existence. It has some really heart - warming scenes that show their connection on a different level than just being maker and made.
One common theme is the family dynamic. Carlisle being the patriarch, his influence on Edward and Bella's relationship within the family framework is often explored. For example, in many fanfictions, he helps them navigate the difficulties of being part of a vampire family.
Carlisle, on the other hand, is usually depicted as a very composed and wise figure. But in the context of lemon fanfiction, he also has a passionate side. His relationship with Edward is complex, with a mix of deep respect and a more intimate connection. The lemon elements usually highlight the physical and emotional closeness between them, showing a side of their relationship that might not be explored as much in non - lemon fanfictions. They are often portrayed as having a relationship that is both secretive and intense, with their interactions being filled with unspoken emotions.
I really like 'A New Beginning in Forks'. In this fanfiction, Carlisle's wisdom has a great impact on how Edward and Bella handle the challenges in their relationship. It has a very engaging writing style that makes you feel like you're right there in Forks with them.
The theme of sacrifice also appears frequently. Edward might sacrifice his own desires or safety for Carlisle, and vice versa. In some fanfictions, this is shown through them protecting each other from other powerful vampires or from the human world's threats. It's really interesting to see how these themes play out in different fan - created stories.
Maybe Carlisle is angry at Edward because Edward put the family in danger in the fanfiction. For example, if Edward exposed their vampire nature to humans carelessly, Carlisle, who values the safety and secrecy of their family, would likely be furious.
Typically, Edward Carlisle slash fanfiction often focuses on the relationship between Edward and Carlisle. It may explore themes like loyalty, family - like bonds in a different context, and the power dynamics between them.