The idea might come from the fact that both have a sense of a world with its own rules and a long - standing history. The wizarding world in Harry Potter has a detailed history of magic, houses, and conflicts. Atlantean legends also speak of a civilization with its own complex history and social structure. But this is more of a coincidence of story - building elements rather than evidence that Harry Potter is Atlantean fanfiction. J.K. Rowling's creation is a unique and original work with no real connection to Atlantean fanfiction.
People may think this due to the fact that both deal with a form of power that is not fully understood by the outside world. In Harry Potter, magic is a powerful force that only wizards and witches can truly master. In Atlantean lore, there was often some sort of super - advanced knowledge or power that was associated with the lost city. But really, these are just broad similarities and not enough to label Harry Potter as Atlantean fanfiction.
Some people might think this because of the common theme of a young hero on a journey. In both, there is a central character who has to face great challenges and grow throughout the story. Also, the use of magic or some form of special powers is present in both. In Pendragon, there are powers related to the different worlds and in Harry Potter, there are spells and magical abilities. This similarity in the basic structure of the story could lead to such a thought.
Some might think so because of the theme of a 'chosen one'. In the Noah story, Noah was chosen by God to save the animals and his family from the flood. Similarly, in Harry Potter, Harry was the chosen one to defeat Voldemort. But this is a very basic similarity and doesn't really make it a fanfiction.
Some might think so because of the out - of - this - world and often zany elements in Harry Potter. Just like in a flounder fanfiction where the author might come up with really strange and unique ideas, in Harry Potter we have things like talking portraits, flying broomsticks, and magical spells. These elements are so different from the normal world that it could give the impression of being part of a more off - the - wall fanfiction.
The unique combination of the Harry Potter world and Atlantean mythology. It gives Harry a whole new set of powers and a different backstory that's not in the original books.
Probably misinformation. Some might misunderstand or misinterpret certain elements in the Harry Potter series and wrongly assume it has something to do with red dragon fanfiction, but in fact, there's no real connection.
Well, it could be the overarching themes. The idea of a magical realm with different powers and a struggle for balance. In Istari stories, there is a constant battle between light and dark, and in 'Harry Potter', the fight between the Order of the Phoenix and Voldemort's Death Eaters has some similarities. Also, the concept of a 'chosen one' in 'Harry Potter' is not unlike some ideas in Istari - related works, which might give the impression that it's an Istari fanfiction.
Some people might think so because of the use of common fantasy tropes. For instance, the idea of a young hero in a magical world facing great challenges. These tropes are also present in some Warren fanfictions, so they may draw the comparison.
The popularity of Harry Potter and the fact that it has inspired so much derivative work could lead some to think it's a fanfiction. It has such a large and passionate fan base that has created countless stories, art, and interpretations based on it. This makes it seem as if it might be part of the fanfiction realm, when in fact it is the original work that inspired all these fan - made things.
One reason could be the way Harry Potter observes and gathers information. Rangers are good at observing their surroundings, and Harry is often in situations where he needs to do the same. In his search for Horcruxes, for example, he has to be very observant of the places he visits and the people he meets. This aspect of his character might remind some people of the skills that a Ranger would possess, thus leading them to think that Harry Potter has elements of a Ranger fanfiction.
Yes, in a sense. Some might argue that it has elements that could be seen as similar to fanfiction concepts related to Atlantean lore. For example, the complex magical world in Harry Potter with its own rules, history, and hidden secrets could be compared to the often - mysterious and rich Atlantean legends. However, it's important to note that J.K. Rowling created an original and unique world, but these comparisons can be drawn in terms of the depth of the fictional universe and the sense of mystery.