Perhaps some writers feel that Edward was too perfect in the original story. By writing bashing fanfiction, they can humanize him more, or rather, de - idealize him. They can show his flaws in a more extreme way, which gives a different perspective on the character and the story as a whole. It's a way for fans to engage with the material on their own terms and express their dissatisfaction or alternative ideas about Edward Cullen.
Another reason could be to explore alternative storylines. By bashing Edward, they can create new plotlines where other characters get more development. For example, if Edward is out of the picture, Bella could have a different kind of relationship or adventure. Also, it can be a form of creative expression for those who have a different view of the Twilight world and its characters. They want to put their own spin on things, even if it means being critical of a popular character like Edward.
One example could be a fanfiction where Edward's overprotective nature is exaggerated to the point of annoyance for the other characters, and they constantly call him out on it. For instance, Bella might get fed up with his controlling behavior and start to rebel more strongly than in the original story.
Some people write 'twilight edward bashing fanfiction' because they might not like his character. Maybe they think he's too perfect in the original story and want to show a different side of him. For example, his 'too - good - to - be - true' image can be off - putting to some.
I would recommend 'A New Beginning for Bella and Edward'. This fanfic takes their story in a different direction after the events in the original series. It shows how they handle new challenges together and the growth of their love in the face of those difficulties. There are some really beautiful and heart - warming moments in it.
They are popular because their relationship is so unique. Edward is Renesmee's father in a very unconventional vampire - half - vampire family dynamic. Writers like to explore this complex bond.
People write these fanfictions because they like to explore different relationship dynamics. Jacob and Edward have such strong and distinct personalities in the Twilight series. Writers are intrigued by the idea of putting them together in a romantic or at least a very close relationship to see how they interact, how their differences and similarities play out.
People like it because it combines two very popular fictional universes. The magical world of Harry Potter with Hermione and the supernatural world of Twilight with Edward. It's a chance to see how characters from different stories would interact.
When writing an 'Edward Cullen Yes Daddy' fanfiction, think about the relationships. If it's about Edward and Bella, you could rewrite their relationship in a way that Edward is more of a paternal figure. For example, he could be teaching her about the history of vampires in a very nurturing way. You also need to pay attention to the pacing of the story. Slow down for important moments and speed up during action scenes. And always keep in mind the 'yes daddy' concept should be integrated in a way that feels natural within the Twilight world you're creating.
Some people write avengers bashing fanfiction just for fun or to be contrarian. They like to see what happens when they turn the well - known heroes into something else. It could be a way to start discussions among fans as well. For instance, if a writer creates a fanfic where Hulk is out of control all the time and causing chaos instead of helping, it can spark debates about the true nature of the character and how he should be written.
One popular storyline could be Renesmee's coming - of - age in the vampire world with Edward as her protective father. She might face challenges in school among humans while hiding her true nature, and Edward would be there to guide her through it. Another could be a time - travel scenario where they go back to a significant moment in vampire history and have to deal with the consequences of changing something. There could also be a story where Renesmee discovers a new power and Edward helps her master it while facing opposition from other vampire clans who fear her power.
The popularity of Bella Cullen and Edward Cullen fanfiction comes from the fact that fans were so in love with their relationship in the original books. People wanted to explore more of what could have been, or different scenarios for them.