Percy would likely feel a great sense of hurt and confusion. He might question his own judgment in trusting Annabeth. He could become more withdrawn and less trusting of others in general.
For Annabeth herself, she might soon realize the error of her ways. She could face a lot of guilt and regret. Depending on how the story unfolds, she may try to make amends, but it might be very difficult to repair the damage done to her relationship with Percy and the trust of their friends.
Another reason could be jealousy. Suppose Percy was getting a lot of attention and praise for his recent achievements, and Annabeth felt overshadowed. Her jealousy could fester and turn into a desire to undermine Percy, leading to her betrayal. However, this would be a more complex and less noble reason compared to the others.
In some fanfictions, Annabeth might betray Percy for power. Maybe she gets lured by some dark force offering her great power and in order to get it, she has to turn on Percy. It could also be due to a misunderstanding. For example, she might be tricked into believing Percy has done something really bad and as a result, she betrays him without realizing the truth.
One consequence could be that she misses out on some creative interpretations of their relationship. Some fanfiction might actually have really interesting takes on their bond that could enhance her understanding in a different way. But on the other hand, by avoiding it, she maintains her own view of their relationship without outside interference.
One possible consequence is that Annabeth will be heartbroken. She's deeply in love with Percy, so his rejection would be a huge blow to her emotionally.
At first, Percy would likely be angry. He's a fighter, and being betrayed by someone he loves would fuel his rage. He might go after Annabeth to demand an explanation. But as the reality sinks in, he could become very sad and withdrawn. He might isolate himself from his other friends as well, feeling like he can't trust anyone anymore. He would constantly be thinking about what he did wrong to make Annabeth turn on him.
Well, perhaps in the fanfiction, Annabeth betrays Percy's trust in a relationship way. She could start seeing someone else and use Percy's secrets against him to make herself look better in front of the new person. Or she might side with a group that Percy is against, believing their lies and false promises over Percy's warnings. This could lead to Percy feeling completely alone and having to find new allies.
One reason could be that she's scared. The idea of becoming a mother at that point in her life might be overwhelming, and she might think she can't handle it with Percy. Maybe she wants to protect Percy from the difficulties that come with the pregnancy as well.
One common theme is the shattering of trust. When Percy gets betrayed, it's all about how that trust he had in someone is completely broken. This often leads to him feeling isolated and alone.
One possible reason for Annabeth to betray Percy in fanfiction could be a misunderstanding. Maybe she was misled by false information about Percy's actions or intentions. For example, if someone spread rumors that Percy was secretly working against the demigods, Annabeth might believe it without getting the full story.
Another consequence might be that it starts a comical chain of events. Maybe the apple misses Annabeth and hits someone else instead, like Grover, and then there's a whole lot of chaos and laughter that follows. The fanfiction could then take on a light - hearted, humorous tone from there.