Well, if it has a really creepy atmosphere, that would be a big factor. For example, if it's set in a dark, abandoned place.
The fear factor in Audrey Holcomb's scary story could come from a variety of elements. It might be the use of suspense. The author could be slowly building up tension, making the reader wait for something bad to happen. And when it finally does, it's all the more terrifying. There could also be psychological horror elements, like messing with the characters' (and the readers') minds. Maybe there are illusions or false memories that make the characters question their own sanity, which is a very effective way to frighten the audience.
Perhaps it's the characters in Audrey Holcomb's story. If there are villains or monsters that are really menacing and unpredictable, that can make the story very frightening. Also, if the main character, like Audrey Holcomb herself if she's a character in the story, is in constant danger and there's a sense of helplessness, that can add to the scariness.
I haven't read the 'Audrey Holcomb scary story' directly. But in general, a scary story by someone might involve elements like a spooky setting, strange characters, and unexpected twists. Maybe it has a haunted house or a malevolent spirit related to Audrey Holcomb. Without more information, it's hard to say more.
The unknown. In a scary story, not knowing what's going to happen next or what the strange thing really is makes it scary. For instance, if there's a noise in the attic, but you don't know if it's a ghost or just a rat, the mystery creates fear.
The unknown elements in 'the wreck scary story' can be really scary. For example, if it's a shipwreck, not knowing what lurks in the dark, flooded cabins can send shivers down your spine.
The mystery behind what's on the other side of the keyhole can be very frightening. You can't see the whole picture, just a limited view, which makes your imagination run wild.
His mystery. We don't know much about him. He just appears out of the mist, rowing his boat.
The unknown elements in a Darcy scary story are often what make it frightening. For example, if Darcy is in a spooky situation and there are unexplained noises or shadows, our imagination runs wild. We don't know what is causing those things, and that fear of the unknown is very powerful.
The creak itself can be very frightening. It's an unexpected sound in the silence, which can startle people.
The unknown. In a scary demon story, we don't really know what the demon is capable of. It could have any power, like the ability to possess people or cause instant death. Just the thought of an otherworldly and malevolent being lurking in the shadows is scary.
The idea of a grandfather being scary can be terrifying because they are family. We usually associate family with safety and love. But in a scary story, when the grandfather is the source of fear, it shakes that foundation. It could be something as simple as his appearance changing in a menacing way, or him having a connection to the supernatural. Maybe he has a past that is full of dark deeds that are slowly being revealed, which makes the reader or listener constantly on edge.
The unknown. In a personal scary story, often it's the things we can't see or understand that are the scariest. Like in my attic story, not knowing what was making that noise.