They might feel surprised. It's a new and unexpected situation for them, different from what they are used to in their regular interactions with the opposite sex.
Some may feel a bit of confusion. Since their sexual orientation is straight, this encounter blurs the lines of what they thought was their normal attraction, and they may not know how to react immediately.
I don't have any personal stories to share as this is a rather personal and often not commonly discussed topic in a general sense. However, in general, such experiences can be very complex for straight guys as it challenges their traditional sexual orientation perception.
A straight guy might approach his first gay encounter with a lot of caution. He may start by just having conversations with gay friends to understand the community better. For instance, he could ask them about the unwritten rules or norms. Then, if it progresses to something more, he might be very hesitant about physical contact at first, like just a simple hug might feel different to him. He needs to give himself time to adjust to new feelings and sensations.
A common first encounter story could be at a sports event. They might meet on a basketball court, both being passionate about the game. They start with a friendly competition, and then realize they share common interests in other areas like music or movies.
Well, a straight guy's first time at a big sports event is a memorable story for some. He might have saved up for weeks to buy the tickets. When he got there, the atmosphere was electric. He was cheering so loudly that he lost his voice. Another instance could be his first job interview. He practiced all the possible questions in front of the mirror, but when he walked into the room, his mind went blank for a second. However, he managed to pull himself together and answer the questions quite well. There are also those whose first time camping was an adventure. He went with some friends, they had trouble setting up the tent at first, but once it was done, they had a great time sitting around the campfire and telling stories.
One straight guy's first time story could be his first time driving a car. He was nervous at first, but as he got behind the wheel and started the engine, the excitement kicked in. He slowly pulled out of the driveway, being extra cautious with the pedals. It was a moment of newfound freedom and responsibility for him.
Well, a straight guy could have a story where he went to the bathhouse for the first time because his friends dragged him there. He was surprised by the different facilities like the hot tubs and steam rooms. At first, he felt a bit out of place, but he ended up enjoying the experience. He might have made new friends and learned about different self - care routines from the other guys there.
I'm not sure there are a lot of common 'first anal experiences' among straight guys as it's not a typical sexual experience in the context of heterosexuality. However, some might have had medical procedures like colonoscopies which could be their first encounter with anal related situations. But that's a very different context from a sexual one.
For many straight guys, their first time winning a sports competition can be a really positive experience. It gives them a sense of achievement and pride.
A straight guy once went on a trip with a group of friends, and one of them was gay. They shared a room due to some accommodation issues. That night, they had a long conversation about their lives and relationships. The straight guy learned a lot about his gay friend's experiences of coming out and facing discrimination. It was the first time he really delved into the personal side of a gay person's life, and it changed his perspective on the gay community.
A shemale's first time getting involved in a community project is also great. They can contribute to the community, meet like - minded people, and feel a sense of belonging. It gives them the opportunity to show their value and make a positive impact.