Another plot could involve Sii being a civilian who accidentally gets caught in the middle of a fight between Saitama and a villain. Sii then discovers they have a latent psychic ability that they use to help Saitama in the fight, and this leads to Sii becoming an apprentice of sorts to Saitama, learning about being a hero.
Sii might interact with Genos in a mentor - like way. Since Genos is always looking to improve his powers, Sii could offer some unique insights based on their own abilities. For instance, Sii might tell Genos that sometimes the simplest solution is the best, which could change Genos' perspective on combat.
One plot could be Tornado having to team up with a new, unexpected hero to face a powerful villain that even she has trouble with. This would show a different side of her as she has to work with someone she might not initially get along with.
One idea could be that Saitama from One Punch Man somehow ends up in the world of Overlord. He might be mistaken for a powerful player at first. Since he's so strong, he could easily defeat many of the powerful monsters in the Overlord world, which would cause a stir among the various guilds and NPCs. Another plot could involve the characters from Overlord trying to understand Saitama's power, which is beyond their comprehension as it's not based on magic or typical RPG stats.
A plot could involve a villain who has the power to control hair and targets Saitama because his hair is so unique. This leads to a battle where Saitama has to figure out how to fight without using his hair as a weapon, which is quite difficult since his every move usually involves his head (and thus his hair) in some way.
One idea could be Issei getting transported to the One Punch Man universe and trying to prove his worth among the powerful heroes there. He might start by challenging some of the lower - ranked heroes and learning the ropes of this new world.
In a One Punch Man fanfiction, a great plot could be the origin story of some of the minor heroes. For example, how Mumen Rider got his bike and started his hero journey. Another plot could be a tournament among the heroes to see who is the most skilled (not the strongest since that's Saitama). And a story where Saitama has to deal with a PR disaster for the Hero Association because of his non - traditional hero behavior.
In a One Punch Man Blizzard fanfiction, a great plot could be that Blizzard is challenged by a rival group who claim to be stronger. Saitama, in his boredom, decides to help Blizzard prove them wrong. He does this in the most nonchalant way possible, like just one - punching all the opponents while eating an ice - cream. This makes Blizzard both frustrated and in awe of him. Another idea is that Blizzard discovers a hidden power within herself after being inspired by Saitama's confidence in his own strength.
Well, you could write a fanfiction about a new hero who joins the Hero Association and has a unique power that somehow challenges Saitama's world view. For example, a hero who can control time in a very limited way but uses it in the most strategic manner. Or perhaps a story where all the villains team up against the heroes and Saitama has to face an army of powerful foes all at once. It would be interesting to see how he handles that without just one - punching everyone immediately.
One interesting plot idea could be a backstory exploration of Mosquito Girl. Maybe she wasn't always a villain. For example, she could have been a normal girl who was experimented on by a mad scientist, which turned her into the Mosquito Girl we know. This could add depth to her character and make the fanfiction more engaging.
A great plot idea could be that Child Emperor discovers a way to time - travel. He decides to go back in time to learn from the greatest minds in history to further his inventions. But when he gets back to his own time, he realizes that his actions in the past have caused some unforeseen consequences, like a new villain emerging who has knowledge of ancient and powerful technology. He then has to enlist the help of other heroes to fix the mess.