Good writing style is a must. The author should be able to create vivid descriptions of the Star Trek universe, from the starships to the alien planets. The dialogue should sound like something the characters would actually say. Also, a great Kirk Admiral fanfic might introduce some interesting twists. It could be a time - travel element that takes Kirk back to his old adventures but with his new perspective as an Admiral, or a situation where he has to make a difficult choice that challenges his beliefs in a whole new way.
One possible annoying aspect could be when fanfics deviate too much from the established character traits of Kirk. For example, if they make him overly whiny or completely change his leadership style into something unrecognizable. It can be really off - putting for fans who love the original Kirk from the series.
The plot needs to be engaging. It can't just be a rehash of the basic court martial idea. Maybe there are new witnesses or evidence that changes the whole dynamic. Also, the fanfic should explore the relationships within the crew. How do they support Kirk? What sacrifices are they willing to make? In a good fanfic, these aspects are well - developed.
The appeal lies in seeing Kirk in a different light. He's usually known for his action - heroics, but in diplomat fanfics, we see his intelligence and charm at work. It's like exploring a new aspect of a beloved character.
You can start by looking on fanfic websites like Archive of Our Own (AO3). It has a large collection of Star Trek fanfics, including those centered around Kirk as an Admiral. Another option is FanFiction.net, which has been around for a long time and has a wide variety of Star Trek stories.
One great Kirk diplomat fanfic is 'Diplomatic Missions of Kirk'. It really delves into Kirk's skills as a diplomat. The story shows how he uses his charm and quick thinking to resolve intergalactic disputes. It's a must - read for fans who love seeing Kirk in a diplomatic role.
Stick to fanfics written by more experienced or well - known Star Trek fanfic authors. These authors are more likely to have a better understanding of Kirk's character and are less likely to create something that is annoying in their portrayal. You can find lists of recommended authors on Star Trek fan forums.
The appeal lies in the character of Kirk. He's a complex and beloved character. Fanfictions about his ceremony allow us to see him in a different light, perhaps more formal or being recognized for his great deeds. It gives fans a chance to explore his character further.
There's a fanfic called 'Court Martial Crisis'. In this one, the charges against Kirk are more complex and intertwined with an alien conspiracy. It makes for a very exciting read as Kirk and his crew have to not only fight the legal battle but also deal with the alien threat at the same time.
One great Kirk ceremony fanfiction is 'The Kirk Ascension'. It focuses on a ceremony where Kirk is honored for his leadership. The story does a wonderful job of bringing in characters from the original series and showing their reactions to Kirk's achievements. It also has some great dialogue that really captures the essence of the Star Trek universe.
The popularity of 'Star Trek TOS Fanfic' comes from the love fans have for the original series. People want more stories with Kirk, Spock and McCoy. It allows fans to explore different scenarios that the original show might not have covered.