The unique personalities of the characters in 'Black Butler' are a great source of humor in fanfiction. Take Mey - Rin for instance. Her clumsiness and her attempts to be a proper maid while constantly messing things up can be made into really hilarious storylines in fanfiction.
The contrast within the story elements. There's a contrast between the dark and serious undertones of the original 'Black Butler' series and the humorous elements in the fanfiction. This contrast is like a breath of fresh air. For example, the normally menacing Sebastian being forced to do something silly like wearing a ridiculous costume. Also, the way the fanfiction can play with the power dynamics. Ciel, who is usually in control, getting into situations where he's completely flustered and at the mercy of the comical events. It's these elements that draw readers to the funny 'Black Butler' fanfiction.
The unexpectedness. When an edit changes the whole meaning or look of something in a way we don't anticipate, it's funny. For example, if a character's voice is suddenly changed to a really high - pitched or low - pitched one that doesn't match their appearance, it's hilarious.
The physical comedy. Mimes use only their bodies to create a story. They can do things like pretending to climb a ladder that isn't there, and the way they make it look real is hilarious.
The unexpected combinations in funny mash stories are what make them entertaining. For example, when you put two completely different characters or situations together, like a serious businessman in a room full of clowns. It creates a contrast that is instantly humorous.
The mystery around Snake in the original 'Black Butler' makes fanfiction about him appealing. His snake familiars add an element of the unknown. Fanfictions can explore what's really going on in his mind and his past.
The unexpectedness. When someone ad - libs, they are creating something on the fly. It's not rehearsed, so it's full of surprises. For example, in a movie scene, if an actor ad - libs a line that's completely different from what was written, it can add a whole new dimension to the story or the character.
The unexpectedness. Cats often do things that are out of the blue. For example, suddenly leaping at nothing or getting startled by their own reflection.
The element of surprise. In these stories, things seem spooky at first but turn out to be something silly. For example, when you think it's a ghost but it's just a stray animal.
The popularity of 'Black Butler Ciel Sebastian Fanfiction' lies in the complex relationship between the two characters. Their master - servant dynamic with a demonic twist is very appealing.
The popularity of 'Black Butler Prince Soma Fanfiction' lies in the character of Prince Soma himself. He's a complex character with a rich backstory. Fans are intrigued by his journey from India to England and his experiences in a foreign land.