There was a small town where every Christmas, people would hear a haunting carol. It seemed to come from the old, abandoned church on the hill. One year, a curious boy named Tom decided to investigate. As he entered the church, it was freezing cold. He saw a figure in a tattered Christmas robe by the altar. The figure turned and its face was a blur. It sang a song that made Tom's blood run cold. He ran out as fast as he could, and from that day on, he never went near the church on Christmas again.
In a snowy village, there was a Christmas tradition of leaving out cookies for Santa. But one year, a family noticed that every morning, the cookies were not eaten in the normal way. Instead, they were smeared all over the plate, and there were strange footprints leading to the attic. The children were curious and went to the attic. There, they found a small, hunched - over creature with long fingers. It hissed at them and they ran away. That Christmas was filled with unease, and they never left cookies out again.
In a small village, there was an old legend about a Christmas spirit that haunted the local churchyard. Every Christmas, if you were out too late, you might see a pale figure dressed in white robes, carrying a broken Christmas wreath. One year, a young couple didn't believe the legend. They were walking home from a Christmas party late at night. As they passed the churchyard, they saw the figure. It started to move towards them, leaving a trail of frost on the ground. The couple tried to run, but they felt a cold hand on their shoulders. When they finally managed to break free and get home, they both fell ill with a mysterious fever that lasted until the new year.
In a small village, there was a legend about a cursed Christmas present. Every year, it would reappear in a different house. One Christmas, it showed up at the home of a family. The present was beautifully wrapped but gave off an eerie feeling. When the youngest child opened it, a cloud of black smoke emerged and formed into a menacing face. It hissed at the family before disappearing, leaving them all shaken for the rest of the Christmas.
I'm sorry, I haven't actually read the 'Creepy Santa: A Christmas Story' specifically. But generally, it might be a story that gives a different and perhaps a bit spooky take on the traditional Santa Claus. Maybe it shows Santa in a less jolly light, with some elements that are not what we usually expect from a normal Christmas story about Santa.
There was a cemetery on the outskirts of town. Late one night, a man was walking past it. As he did, he heard a faint scratching sound coming from one of the graves. He stopped, his heart pounding. He told himself it was just an animal, but then he saw the dirt on one of the graves start to move. A pale hand emerged from the ground. The man was frozen in fear. He wanted to run, but his legs wouldn't move. Then, a figure started to pull itself out of the grave, moaning in a way that sent shivers down his spine.
One Christmas creepy story is about a haunted Christmas tree. A family brought home a beautiful, large tree one year. At night, they would hear strange rustling noises coming from it. When they woke up in the morning, all the presents under the tree were mysteriously moved around. Another one is the story of a ghostly Santa Claus. A child woke up in the middle of the night on Christmas Eve and saw a figure in a Santa suit outside his window. But this Santa had a menacing look and disappeared into thin air when the child blinked.
There's the story of the Christmas Eve apparition. In an old, dilapidated house on a snowy Christmas Eve, a lone traveler sought shelter. As he sat by the fireplace, he noticed a figure slowly materialize in the corner. It was a woman in an old - fashioned Christmas dress, but her face was pale and sad. She seemed to be repeating the same actions over and over, like she was reliving a Christmas long past. The traveler was so terrified that he ran out into the cold night.
Once upon a time, a girl was home alone at night. She heard strange scratching noises from the attic. Ignoring it at first, but it grew louder. She slowly climbed the stairs, her heart pounding. When she opened the attic door, a cold wind blew out, and she saw a pair of glowing eyes in the darkness. She quickly slammed the door and ran downstairs, never to go back up there again.
Once there was a girl named Lily. She had an imaginary friend named Red. Red always showed up at night. He would whisper strange things in Lily's ear like 'The dark is coming to get you.' One night, Lily woke up to find Red standing over her bed, his eyes glowing red. She screamed but her parents didn't hear. Since then, she was too scared to go to sleep at night, fearing Red's return.
One element is a spooky setting like an old, abandoned house or a dark forest during Christmas. For example, if the story is set in a dilapidated mansion where the wind howls through the broken windows on Christmas Eve. Another is having strange characters such as a menacing Santa Claus or a shadowy figure that doesn't belong. Also, the use of unusual sounds like eerie Christmas carols that sound distorted or the sound of bells when there's no bell in sight can make a Christmas short story creepy.
One common theme is the subversion of the traditional Christmas cheer. Instead of joy and celebration, there's fear and dread. Another theme is the appearance of supernatural entities like ghosts, demons or malevolent spirits during the Christmas season, which is supposed to be a time of peace. For example, in many stories, the ghosts of the past come back to haunt people on Christmas. Also, a sense of isolation is often present. Whether it's a family trapped in a snow - covered house or someone alone in an old building on Christmas, this isolation adds to the creepiness.