Another sign is the lack of connection to the themes of the original. The Harry Potter series is about so much more than just magic. It's about friendship, family, and fighting for what's right. If a fanfic completely ignores these themes and just focuses on some random action or adventure that has no real depth, it's likely a soulless fanfic.
If the fanfic doesn't respect the lore of the Harry Potter world. For instance, if it changes the rules of magic in a way that doesn't make sense or contradicts what was established in the books. A good Harry Potter fanfic builds on the existing world, while a soulless one might just create chaos in the magic system for no good reason.
One way is if the characters seem flat. In the original Harry Potter, the characters are multi - dimensional. But in a soulless fanfic, they may just be there to move the plot along, with no real personality. For example, Hermione might be just a walking encyclopedia without her usual determination and compassion.
Look for fanfics that change the well - established lore of the Harry Potter world without any real explanation or in a way that seems to be just for the sake of being different in a negative way. Also, if the story seems to be more about tearing down the original characters and themes rather than building on them in a positive or creative way, it's likely bad faith. For example, if a fanfic is constantly making fun of the Hogwarts houses or the magic system in a mean - spirited way.
If the plot is overly simplistic and predictable, it could be a sign of a soulless novel. There's no element of surprise or real conflict. For example, if it's always clear who will win or what will happen next without any twists, it may lack soul. Also, the writing style can be an indicator. If it's very bland and doesn't create any mood or atmosphere, that's a red flag.
Soulless fanfics in the Harry Potter universe may often be those that are written just for the sake of writing, without a true passion for the world and its characters. They might not capture the unique atmosphere of Hogwarts, the sense of wonder, or the struggle between good and evil. The descriptions may be bland, the dialogue uninteresting, and overall it fails to transport the reader into the magical world that we all love from the original books.
One way to identify it could be if the fanfiction drastically changes the personalities of the beloved Harry Potter characters in a negative way. For instance, if Harry is suddenly portrayed as a cruel and heartless person, it might be 'poisoned' fanfiction.
Some platforms where you post your Harry Potter fanfic might have a version history. Look for that and you can select an earlier version to revert to. Another option is if you have a backup copy saved on your device. You can simply replace the current version with the backup.
One way to identify a Mary Sue is by looking at their abilities. If they seem to be able to do everything without any real struggle or training, they might be a Mary Sue. For instance, if in a superhero fanfic, a new character can fly, has super strength, is invulnerable, and can also read minds from the start without any explanation, that's a red flag. Also, if all the other characters are in love with this character for no good reason, it's likely a Mary Sue.
Look at the reviews. If there are a lot of negative reviews complaining about the writing, the plot, or the characterization, it's likely a bad fanfic.
First, do a lot of research on the Harry Potter lore. Then, create your own unique plot twists. Maybe Harry discovers he has a long - lost sister who has a special power. Use detailed descriptions of the wizarding world, from the food in the Great Hall to the spells used in duels. And don't forget to give your characters distinct voices. Each character should have their own way of speaking and thinking. This will make your fanfic stand out and be cooler.
Begin by immersing yourself in the Harry Potter universe. Re - read the series to soak up all the details. For the story, think about events that could have happened within the framework of the original series. Maybe something that was hinted at but not fully explored. As for the characters, they should act in ways that are true to their original selves. For instance, Ginny Weasley should be the strong - willed and independent character she was in the books. When writing about the magic, use the spells and incantations that are already known. And don't forget to set the story in the familiar locations of the wizarding world, like Diagon Alley or Hogsmeade.
There are also some dedicated Harry Potter fanfic communities and forums. For example, some Reddit groups are focused on sharing and discussing Harry Potter fanfic. You can join these groups and get access to fan - written stories that might not be on the larger platforms. Additionally, some Tumblr blogs are known for curating and sharing interesting Harry Potter fanfic pieces.