The 'the cat came back' is a scary story because it plays on our fear of the unknown. We don't know why the cat is so determined to return. Is it a spirit? Is it cursed? Also, the reactions of the people in the story add to the scariness. They are terrified of the cat, and as readers or listeners, we feel their fear. The cat's presence seems to bring bad luck or supernatural events, like cold spots in the house or things disappearing and reappearing in strange places, all of which combine to make it a truly spooky tale.
The fact that the cat keeps coming back is just the start. Each time it returns, something more disturbing happens in the story. It could be strange noises or objects moving on their own. It creates an atmosphere of unease and mystery. And the cat seems to have some sort of power or connection to the place that is not normal. For example, it may come back after being left far away in a place it couldn't possibly find its way back from, which makes it seem otherworldly.
The sudden return of the cat is quite scary. Just when you thought it was gone forever, it shows up out of nowhere.
The 'cat came back' scary story often involves a cat that returns in an unexpected and spooky way. Maybe it was thought to be dead or lost far away, but then it shows up at the doorstep, looking different, with its eyes glowing in the dark, giving a sense of unease.
In the 'the cat came back' scary story, this cat showed up at a person's house. The owner didn't want it at first but eventually let it stay. However, the cat started acting really strange. It would disappear for days and then come back with a different look in its eyes. One day, the owner decided to take it to the woods and leave it there. But not long after, the cat was back, and this time it brought an eerie feeling with it. The house got colder, and there were unexplained noises. It seemed that the cat was not an ordinary cat but something from the other side that had attached itself to the house and the owner.
Well, in the 'the cat came back story', it could be that the cat got lost or was chased away for some reason. But cats have a strong sense of home. So, it managed to find its way back. It might involve the cat's adventures during its time away, like meeting other animals or facing difficulties, and finally making its way back to the familiar environment.
The unknown. When you don't know what the cat is going to do or what it represents. For example, if the cat is just staring at you but you don't know why, it creates a sense of unease.
Perhaps it's the cat's appearance. If it has long, sharp claws and a wild look in its eyes, that can be really frightening.
The main character is surely the cat. There might also be the cat's owner or the people in the household where the cat belongs.
The unknown nature of the cat's actions. For example, the cat's strange behavior like staring at the meat with a strange glint or leading the butcher on a chase through dark alleys. It creates an air of mystery and unease.
In 'The Black Cat', the way the narrator's actions become more and more cruel and irrational is what makes it scary. He starts off normal but then begins to mistreat the cat and commits heinous acts. The cat's unwavering stare, which seems to be a sign of judgment, is also a factor that sends chills down the reader's spine.
The sense of being followed or watched. For example, in stories where people feel a presence behind them all the time, it gives a creepy feeling. Also, the use of spooky settings such as abandoned buildings or dark forests in 'back to back scary stories' adds to the fright. These places are often associated with danger and the supernatural in our minds. The stories build tension by having things happen in quick succession, like one strange event after another, leaving the characters (and the readers/listeners) with no time to fully recover from the previous scare.