Another plot could be that Natsu's transformation is not complete at first. He has to go on a journey to fully become a dragon. Along the way, he meets different characters who either help or hinder his transformation. Some might be afraid of him, while others see the potential in his new form and want to use it for their own purposes.
Perhaps in the fanfiction, when Natsu turns into a dragon, he can communicate with other dragons in a way he couldn't before. This could lead to him uncovering secrets about his past and the origin of dragons in that fictional world. He might find out he has a special destiny related to the dragons.
One interesting plot twist could be that when Natsu turns into a dragon, he loses his memory of his human friends. This would create a lot of drama as his friends try to bring back the Natsu they know. Another could be that he turns into a different kind of dragon than expected, perhaps one with a very rare and powerful ability that attracts the wrong kind of attention from dark forces in the fanfiction world. And also, he might transform into a dragon at a crucial moment during a battle, not only surprising his enemies but also his allies, changing the whole dynamic of the fight.
One idea could be that Hiccup turns into a dragon during a battle and uses his new form to surprise the enemy. He could fly faster and breathe a more powerful fire than any other dragon, leading his team to victory.
One idea could be that Natsu discovers unique magical abilities passed down from the Dragon God that set him apart from other mages. For example, he might be able to communicate with all types of dragons, not just the ones he's related to in the original story.
One idea could be Natsu exploring a new magic ability related to his dual dragon slayer powers. For example, he discovers a way to combine the fire of his Igneel - taught magic with the other dragon's element in a more powerful and unique way.
Well, a cool plot might involve Natsu being transported to a parallel world where he is the only water dragon slayer. He has to adapt quickly to this new role and use his skills to fight against an evil force that is draining the water from that world. Also, he could meet alternate versions of his friends and have to convince them to trust him, since his powers are so different from what they know.
Another plot could involve Natsu turning into a dragon in a completely different world. He has to adapt to this new world as a dragon and find a way to turn back. Along the way, he meets other dragons who teach him about his new form and its capabilities. This could lead to him having a greater understanding of his own powers when he finally returns to his normal self.
Maybe in the fanfiction, Natsu's emotional state causes him to turn into a dragon. After a great loss or a fit of extreme rage, his magic reacts and he transforms. This new form is both a blessing and a curse. It gives him the power to protect his loved ones better but also isolates him as he struggles to understand and control his new dragon instincts.
One plot idea could be that Natsu discovers a new, hidden power within his Alph Dragon Slayer abilities. Maybe he can communicate with ancient dragons that were previously unknown. Another idea is that he has to compete in a tournament against other dragon slayers with unique powers. This would lead to intense battles and character development.
In this 'natsu turns into a dragon fanfic', a great plotline could be that Natsu's dragon form is different from the typical dragons. His friends, like Lucy, Gray, and Erza, try to find a way to reverse the transformation at first. But as they see the potential in his new form to fight a greater evil, they change their minds and instead help him master his dragon powers. This could involve a series of adventures where Natsu has to learn to fly, breathe different types of dragon fire, and communicate with other dragon - like creatures.
One idea could be exploring Natsu's struggle to control his half - dragon powers. Maybe he accidentally causes destruction in the town and has to deal with the guilt and the fear of others. Another could be a story where Natsu discovers a hidden dragon clan related to his half - dragon heritage and has to prove himself to them.