Some fanfictions might try to justify it by re - interpreting Dumbledore's motives. For example, they could claim that his desire to use Harry as a weapon against Voldemort was a form of abuse, as it put Harry in constant danger without fully explaining the situation to him. But this is a very different take from the original series.
In certain fanfictions, the justification for Dumbledore abusing Harry could be related to power dynamics. They may depict Dumbledore as being corrupted by his own power and using Harry for his own ends. However, this is a departure from the more benevolent view of Dumbledore in the official story. These fanfictions often take creative liberties to explore darker themes and alternative character arcs.
In some dark or alternate-interpretation fanfictions, there might be such portrayals. However, this goes against the general view in the original 'Harry Potter' series. In the official story, Dumbledore is more of a mentor figure, guiding and protecting Harry. But in the realm of fanfiction, some authors may explore extreme or different angles for creative or shock value.
Well, some people write these fanfictions because they feel that Dumbledore in the original books had some morally grey areas. His actions, like withholding information from Harry, can be seen as manipulative. So, fans create stories where Harry gets fed up with this and decides to part ways.
Authors often justify it through magical means. Maybe Harry discovers a long - lost spell that gives him a degree of control over Hermione's actions, but he uses it for what he believes is a noble cause like protecting her from a hidden danger. For example, if there's a dark wizard targeting Hermione specifically, Harry might use this control to keep her safe without her full knowledge.
One reason is that fans like to explore different perspectives. In the original books, Dumbledore is presented as a wise and mostly benevolent figure. But some fans want to see what would happen if he had a darker side. It adds a new layer of complexity to the story.
One popular 'Harry done with Dumbledore' fanfiction could be 'The Parting Ways'. In it, Harry realizes that Dumbledore has been keeping too many secrets and decides to take his own path. It shows Harry growing independent and making his own decisions.
One could be a story where Dumbledore is magically thrust into Harry's mind during a crucial battle. In this fanfiction, Dumbledore's wisdom and magical power help Harry make strategic decisions that he might not have made otherwise. It could be an exciting read as it combines the two powerful characters in a very unique way.
Fanfictions should generally uphold the positive values of the original work. Since Harry is a hero figure in the Harry Potter series, a fanfiction about him abusing Muggles goes against his established character. There might be some very rare and inappropriate interpretations out there, but they are not in line with the spirit of the story.
These fanfictions often make Dumbledore seem less of a benevolent figure. Instead of being the wise and all - knowing mentor, he becomes a character with his own self - interests. They show that his actions towards Harry, like putting him in dangerous situations, might not be just for the greater good but for his own plans.
Some fanfictions focus on Dumbledore's mistakes in raising Harry. They might show that his distance and secrecy were not just for protection but rather a sign of his lack of true care. For example, in a particular fanfic, Dumbledore is blamed for not being more forthcoming with information about Harry's parents and the prophecy, which leads to Harry making many mistakes and facing more danger than necessary.
There's 'Dumbledore's Special Training for Harry' which focuses on combat training. Harry learns advanced dueling techniques from Dumbledore, which comes in handy when facing powerful dark wizards. It also shows how Dumbledore prepares Harry for the greater challenges that lie ahead in the wizarding world.