It could also be a way to create high - stakes drama. Torturing Percy in Tartarus is a very intense situation. It can draw in readers who are interested in seeing how Percy will get out of such a horrible predicament, and how his friends will react when they find out. It adds a lot of tension and emotional weight to the story.
Maybe it's part of a plot to have Percy gain some sort of power or knowledge. In many fictional stories, a character has to go through great pain and suffering before emerging stronger or wiser. The torture in Tartarus could be a way to set up this transformation for Percy.
Another scenario could be that Percy is forced to endure extreme environmental conditions in Tartarus. The place is known for its intense heat, toxic fumes, and jagged terrain. He might be made to traverse through burning lava fields or climb sheer cliffs while being constantly weakened by the poisonous air, all of which would be a form of torture.
In some fanfictions, Percy's torture in Tartarus could be part of a grander scheme. For example, an enemy on the surface world has made a deal with the forces of Tartarus to weaken Percy. As he endures the torture, he gradually uncovers the conspiracy and tries to find a way to not only escape but also stop those who sent him there. His friends, unaware of his situation at first, start to suspect something is wrong and embark on a quest to find out what happened to him and rescue him.
There are several possible reasons. Firstly, for the sake of drama. It makes for a very intense and emotional story when a beloved character like Percy dies. Secondly, it could be to explore the after - effects on the other characters. How would Annabeth cope? How would the Camp Half - Blood react? Also, it might be a way to show the unforgiving nature of Tartarus.
Perhaps a prophecy misinterpretation. If a prophecy was misread and it seemed like Percy was the cause of great evil to come, the gods might take drastic action. For instance, if the prophecy spoke of a 'child of the sea' causing destruction, and they wrongly assumed it was Percy without fully understanding the context.
Some writers might create 'percy tortured fanfic' to shock the readers. It's a way to get a strong reaction and stand out in the vast sea of fanfiction. They might think that by presenting such a disturbing scenario, they can engage readers who are looking for something different from the typical happy - go - lucky fanfic.
A plotline could be Percy having to face his own fears and insecurities while being tortured. Maybe he starts to doubt his abilities and heroism. But as the story progresses, he overcomes these doubts through his willpower. Also, the fanfic could explore how the torture affects his relationship with the gods. He might feel betrayed by them for allowing him to end up in Tartarus and this could lead to a change in his loyalty or attitude towards them.
One possible reason could be jealousy among his so - called friends. Maybe someone was envious of Percy's powers or popularity and decided to frame him, leading to his betrayal and subsequent sending to Tartarus. Another reason might be a misunderstanding. For example, if there was some false evidence planted against Percy, his comrades could have been misled into believing he had done something unforgivable and sent him to that horrible place.
Percy might endure it through his own stubborn will. He's a demigod used to facing tough situations. In this fanfiction, he could be using his past experiences of fighting monsters and surviving hardships. He might tell himself that he's been through worse and this is just another trial he has to pass. So he grits his teeth and bears it as best he can, even when the torture in Tartarus is beyond what he's ever faced before.
He might use his powers in creative ways to lessen the impact of the torture. For instance, if the torture involves some form of mental attack, he could try to use his connection to water to calm his mind. Also, his demigod abilities, like his superhuman strength and agility, could help him physically resist some of the more brutal forms of torture to a certain extent. And he may also draw strength from the memories of his past victories and the people he has saved.
Well, perhaps in the fanfic, there's a prophecy that gets misinterpreted. The gods think Percy is going to cause great harm based on this wrong interpretation, so they send him to Tartarus. It could also be that there's some sort of power struggle among the gods. Percy might be caught in the middle of it, and one side decides to get rid of him by banishing him to Tartarus to tip the balance in their favor.