This type of fanfic can have a significant impact on the fandom. It can create a stir and generate a lot of discussion. Some fans may be offended and think it's inappropriate to take the character in such a direction. But for those who are more open - minded, it can add depth to their perception of the Harry Potter universe. It shows that the world created by J.K. Rowling can be explored in many different ways, even if those ways are uncomfortable or controversial.
It can be quite shocking to some fans. For those who love the original positive and hopeful tone of the Harry Potter series, such a dark fanfiction can be disturbing. They might feel that it goes against the essence of the character they know and love.
It's quite a controversial thing in the Naruto fandom. On one hand, some might see it as a very dark exploration of 'what if' scenarios. But on the other hand, it can be really harmful. Naruto is a symbol of hope for a lot of people. A fanfic about his suicide can make fans feel betrayed. It can also create a lot of negative emotions within the community. Some fans might feel angry that someone would write such a thing about their beloved character.
No. It's not appropriate. The Harry Potter series is mainly aimed at a wide range of audiences, including young readers. Such a dark and depressing theme as suicide is not in line with the positive and magical world that J.K. Rowling created.
On the other hand, it could also start some interesting discussions within the fandom. It might make fans think about the darker aspects of the wizarding world that were not fully explored in the original books. For example, how much pressure can a young wizard like Harry actually bear? However, it also has the potential to make some fans feel uncomfortable or even depressed, especially those who are more attached to the positive and heroic image of Harry.
It enriches the fandom. New ideas from fanfic can inspire more discussions among fans.
It may also divide the fandom a bit. Some fans who are more attached to the original positive and heroic narrative of Harry may not like the idea of him dying in fanfic at all. While others, who enjoy exploring darker and more alternative storylines, might embrace these 'harry potter dies fanfic' and even contribute to creating more similar stories, which can cause some friction between different groups of fans.
A 'Harry Potter commits suicide fanfic' is not in line with the general positive and adventurous spirit of the Harry Potter universe. Fanfics should usually be creative expansions that respect the core values of the original work. This kind of concept might be too dark and could potentially be triggering for some fans. It also doesn't seem to have a positive or meaningful contribution to the vast world of Harry Potter fan - created content.
It can have a divisive impact. Some fans might be intrigued by the new ideas presented in the infamous fanfictions and it can spark their creativity. They might start to think about the story in different ways. However, it can also annoy many fans who are purists and want to keep the original vision of the series intact. For example, when a fanfiction changes the essence of a beloved character like Dumbledore into something unrecognizable, it can make traditional fans very unhappy.
It keeps the fandom alive. Fans who read and write this fanfiction are constantly engaged with the Harry Potter world, discussing their favorite stories and ideas. This creates a sense of community within the fandom.
The'suicidal Harry Potter fanfic' might make some fans feel uncomfortable or alienated from the fandom. However, it could also attract a different group of fans who are interested in exploring the deeper and darker aspects of the Potterverse. Overall, it has the potential to reshape the perception of the fandom, either by causing controversy or by sparking new discussions about the boundaries of fan - created content.