One reason could be a lack of understanding of the essence of the Harry Potter series. They might not fully appreciate the positive values and relationships that are central to the story. Also, in some cases, it could be an attempt to create a 'forbidden' or 'taboo' story just for the sake of it, without considering the negative impact it can have on readers, especially younger ones who are fans of the original series.
It could be that they misinterpreted the characters or the world of Harry Potter. Maybe they wanted to explore a very different and 'edgy' take on the story, but they went too far. Another possibility is that they have some personal issues or experiences that they are inappropriately projecting onto the fanfic, but this doesn't make it okay.
Some people might create it just for shock value. They want to create something so out - of - the - ordinary and gross that it grabs attention, even if it's in a negative way.
There are many fanfics out there, but the idea of 'Harry Potter abused sister' is a very dark and untrue to the original spirit of the series. Most official and well - regarded fanfic communities would not support such a disturbing concept. It's also important to note that any form of abuse is unacceptable in literature, especially when it involves characters from a family - friendly franchise like Harry Potter.
It could also be very distressing for younger fans who look up to the Harry Potter series. They might be exposed to this inappropriate content and be confused or traumatized by it. Additionally, it could lead to a split in the fan community, with some fans being outraged by the existence of such a fanfic and others perhaps trying to defend the idea of 'creativity' even when it crosses ethical boundaries.
Well, it might be because some fans feel that Slytherin has been somewhat demonized in the original books. So, they create fanfiction where Slytherin is the victim of abuse, perhaps as a way to give the house more depth and sympathy. Also, the idea of abuse can create a lot of drama and conflict, which are elements that make a story interesting. Fanfiction writers might be using this concept to attract readers who are interested in more complex and edgy storylines. Additionally, it could be a form of exploring the morality and ethics within the Harry Potter universe in a very extreme way.
Some 'abused Harry Potter oc fanfic' might feature an OC who is a Muggle - born in a time when there is a strong anti - Muggle - born sentiment. They could be physically or verbally abused by pure - blood supremacists. The story could show how this OC tries to hide their identity at first, but then gradually finds the courage to stand up against the abuse with the help of some kind - hearted characters like Harry, Hermione, or Ron. It could also delve into how the abuse affects their magical development and their view of the wizarding world as a whole.
One reason could be the strict control by the official copyright holders. They might be worried about fanfic diluting the official brand or misinterpreting the original story. Another factor could be some fans' purist view. They only want to stick to the original works by J.K. Rowling and consider fanfic as something not in line with the 'true' Harry Potter universe.
In fanfiction, while creativity is encouraged, there are boundaries. The idea of abuse in the context of Harry Potter is not only unethical but also not in line with the overall tone and world - building of the series. The series promotes things like loyalty, bravery, and kindness. A theme of abuse would be a dark stain on this otherwise positive and magical world. It could also lead to discomfort and negative reactions from the majority of the fan community who cherish the positive aspects of the Harry Potter universe.
It could also be that the fanfic might interfere with the way he wants his story to be remembered. His adventures at Hogwarts were real and important to him, and when fanfic changes the narrative, it's like his story is being disrespected. For example, if a fanfic portrays him as cowardly when he was actually brave, that would surely make him dislike it.
One possible reason could be a miscommunication. Maybe Hermione accidentally reveals a secret of Harry's that he didn't want known, and this causes him to feel betrayed and start to hate her. Another reason could be jealousy. If Hermione gets more attention or praise for her magical abilities than Harry in the fanfic, he might develop feelings of envy and hatred. Or perhaps there's a love triangle situation where Hermione is involved with someone Harry doesn't like, and that causes his hatred.
One possible reason could be extreme despair. Maybe in that fanfic's alternate universe, Harry has lost all his friends and loved ones in a very tragic way, like a second wizarding war that was far more brutal and unforgiving. He might see no way out of the emotional pain and thus choose to end his own life.