One 'Peter Pan tied up' fanfiction might involve a plot where he's tied up by the pirates as a way to stop him from interfering with their plans. They think that by restraining him, they can finally take over Neverland without his meddling.
In some fanfictions, Peter Pan could be tied up by a spell gone wrong. Maybe a new magic user in Neverland accidentally casts a binding spell on him. This could lead to a series of events where his friends have to figure out how to break the spell and free him. They might have to go on a quest to find a rare ingredient or consult an old, wise creature in the forest.
Another scenario could be that Peter Pan is tied up as part of a game or a challenge among the Lost Boys. They might be testing their skills against him in a more extreme way. However, things could quickly turn serious if an enemy, like Captain Hook, discovers Peter in this vulnerable state and tries to take advantage of it.
There are fanfictions where a female character is inserted into the original Peter Pan story as a sort of guide for Peter. For example, she could be from a different magical realm and helps Peter understand new forms of magic, which in turn changes the dynamics of his relationship with Captain Hook and the others in Neverland.
There are fanfictions where Peter Pan and Tinkerbell have a big argument and Tinkerbell decides to leave Neverland. But then she realizes she can't really be without Peter and the adventures they share. So she has to find a way to make things right with him. This often involves her going through a journey of self - discovery.
One interesting Peter Pan vampire fanfiction could be where Peter Pan himself is turned into a vampire. He might use his new vampire abilities like super speed and strength in Neverland, changing the power dynamics among the Lost Boys. Another could be a story where Tinker Bell has to deal with a vampire threat in Neverland while also being jealous of Peter's newfound vampiric allure.
One interesting story could be where Jane discovers a hidden part of Neverland that Peter Pan had forgotten. In this fanfiction, Jane uses her unique perspective, different from Wendy's, to navigate the new challenges there. It could involve new magical creatures and a different kind of adventure.
One interesting Peter Pan and Ariel fanfiction could be about them meeting in a magical realm between Neverland and Atlantica. Maybe Peter takes Ariel on an adventure above the water, showing her the joys of flying. Another could be a story where they team up to save both their worlds from a common threat, like an evil sea witch who also wants to take over Neverland.
There might be a fanfiction where Captain Hook has a change of heart and tries to make amends with Peter Pan. He could start to see the error of his ways after a particularly dangerous encounter with a sea monster. In this story, they could gradually become friends, much to the surprise of all the Lost Boys and the pirates.
There could be a fanfiction where Felix has a secret that he's been hiding from Peter Pan. It could be that he has a connection to a group outside of Neverland that could either help or harm their world. As the story unfolds, Peter Pan discovers this secret and has to decide whether to trust Felix or not. This would add a lot of drama and tension to their relationship.
One interesting fanfiction could be about Jack Frost and Peter Pan teaming up to save Neverland from a new, mysterious threat. Maybe a dark magic that is freezing parts of the island and they have to combine their powers to stop it.
There might be a fanfiction where Henry Mills and Peter Pan have to team up to save Neverland from a new, dark threat. They could start off as distrustful of each other, but as the story progresses, they learn to rely on one another's strengths. For example, Henry's knowledge from the real world and Peter's in - depth understanding of Neverland's magic.
One interesting story could be about Peter Pan facing a new kind of magic in Neverland that he's never encountered before. Maybe it's a magic that starts to change the landscape and he has to figure out how to stop it to save his home.