Some of the worst Fullmetal Alchemist fanfictions are those that lack proper research. They might get the alchemy rules completely wrong, which is a big deal since alchemy is such a central part of the story. For example, if they have characters performing alchemical transmutations without any proper equivalent exchange. There are also fanfictions that are just too self - indulgent, focusing only on the author's own ideas and not considering what makes Fullmetal Alchemist so great, like its themes of sacrifice, redemption, and the search for truth. These fanfictions often end up feeling disjointed from the original work.
Well, some of the worst ones are those that completely distort the original characters' personalities. For example, making Edward overly whiny and weak when he's supposed to be a strong - willed alchemist. Another type could be the fanfictions with really bad grammar and spelling that make it hard to even understand the plot. And then there are those that introduce out - of - place concepts that don't fit the world of Fullmetal Alchemist at all, like suddenly having magic when it's an alchemy - based world.
The worst stories in Fullmetal Alchemist fanfiction might be the ones that have a really convoluted plot for no good reason. They try to be overly complex but end up just confusing the reader. Also, the fanfictions where the author seems to be more interested in shipping characters in a forced way rather than developing a good story. For instance, pairing characters who have no real connection or chemistry in the original work just because it's a popular ship in other fandoms. This takes away from the essence of Fullmetal Alchemist.
One way is to look at the reviews. If there are a lot of negative reviews complaining about things like bad characterization or a confusing plot, it's probably a bad story. Also, if the story seems to go against the basic principles of Fullmetal Alchemist, like the concept of equivalent exchange in alchemy. Another sign is if the writing style is really hard to follow, with long, rambling sentences and no clear structure.
Some characters might be quite shocked or amused if they could read fanfiction about their own story. For example, Edward Elric would probably be very indignant at some of the out - of - character portrayals of himself. He's a proud alchemist and seeing himself depicted in a way that doesn't match his self - image would surely make him fume.
There are many fanfictions where Ed is portrayed as a girl. Fanfiction writers like to play with the existing characters in new ways. By making Ed a girl, they can introduce new themes and perspectives. For example, it could change how the story deals with gender roles in the world of Fullmetal Alchemist. Also, it can create new emotional arcs for the character, as a female Ed might face different challenges and experiences compared to the male version in the original story.
One great fanfiction could be about Izumi's backstory before she became an alchemist. It might explore her early training days and the challenges she faced. For example, a story could focus on how she overcame the difficulties of learning complex alchemical theories without proper guidance at first.
Yes, it does. Brotherhood is considered a more faithful adaptation that follows the manga's storyline closely.
Some characters might feel flattered. If the fanfiction portrays them in a heroic and positive light, especially if it emphasizes their good qualities like Edward's determination or Alphonse's kindness, they might secretly feel a bit of pride and be flattered by the author's view of them.
One interesting fanfiction could be about Harry Potter somehow ending up in the Fullmetal Alchemist world and learning alchemy. He might use his magic in combination with alchemy in unique ways to solve problems.
There probably are. Fanfiction writers often love to mash up different universes. In such a fanfic, Naruto could bring his chakra - based powers and blend them with the principles of alchemy from Fullmetal Alchemist. Maybe he'd use his Rasengan in a new way by incorporating alchemical transmutation circles. It would be a wild and creative concept.
A good Fullmetal Alchemist and Naruto fanfiction often has a well - thought - out plot that combines the elements of both universes in a seamless way. For example, it could be about how the laws of alchemy work in the world of ninjas. Also, good character development is key. If it shows the characters from both series growing and changing as a result of their interactions, it's great. Like if Naruto learns about the concept of equivalent exchange from Fullmetal Alchemist and it changes his view on his ninja training.
Another idea might be alternative endings. Fanfiction often plays with the concept of 'what if' things had gone differently. Maybe if Edward had not been able to regain his brother's body, how would he have coped and what new path would his life take?