Maybe it's the character of the Jingaly Man himself. If he has a menacing look or does really cruel things in the stories, that would be scary.
The fear factor in 'the jingaly man scary stories' might also come from the way the stories are told. If they are passed down orally with a lot of suspense and build - up, it can really make the listener feel scared. For example, if the storyteller slowly reveals the terrifying deeds of the Jingaly Man while creating a tense atmosphere, it would send shivers down the spine of the audience. And if the Jingaly Man preys on the innocent or targets people when they are most vulnerable, that would also contribute to the overall scariness of the stories.
It could be the setting of the stories. If they take place in a spooky location like an old abandoned house or a dark forest, that would add to the scariness. Also, if there are elements of the supernatural in the Jingaly Man's character, like being able to appear and disappear at will or having some sort of dark magic, that would make the stories very frightening.
The mystery around the jingly man. We don't know who he is or what his intentions are. Just the sound of the bells and the presence of an unknown figure is enough to send shivers down one's spine.
The fact that the jingle is the only sign of his approach. It's like a warning that you can't escape from. And also, we don't know what his intentions are. He could be out to harm or just to terrify, and that uncertainty is really scary.
In Jingling Man scary stories, it's often the setting that adds to the fear. For example, if he haunts an old, dilapidated place like an abandoned mansion or a spooky forest. The idea that he could be anywhere in that eerie place, and all you can hear is his jingling, makes it really scary. Also, the mystery behind his existence and his possible motives for haunting are very unnerving.
The unknown aspect of his life. We don't know his past, why he behaves the way he does. Maybe he has a dark secret or has been through some traumatic event that has made him this way. And not knowing this makes our imagination run wild, creating all kinds of terrifying scenarios in our minds about him.
The unknown elements in 21 scary stories often make them frightening. When we don't know what's lurking in the dark or what will happen next, it creates fear.
Often, it's the combination of elements. It could be the setting, like a dark and isolated place in the stories. And the characters' vulnerability. If the main character in one of the 7 stories is all alone in a spooky old mansion with no way to escape, that's pretty frightening. Also, the use of suspense, like when the story builds up to a big scare moment but keeps you in suspense for a while.
The element of the unknown. In these stories, things happen that can't be easily explained. It's like a strange noise in the middle of the night with no obvious source. That makes our minds race with all kinds of scary possibilities.
The element of the unknown. For example, when there are strange noises in a story but no clear explanation of what's causing them. It makes the reader's imagination run wild, which is a big part of what makes it scary.
The way they play on our fears. A lot of the stories in '50 scary stories' involve common fears such as the fear of the dark, being alone, or something evil lurking just out of sight. They build up the tension slowly, making you feel more and more on edge until the big scare comes. For instance, there are stories where a character is home alone at night and starts to notice small, unexplainable things happening around them, like doors opening slightly by themselves. This gradually makes the reader or listener feel very uneasy. Another aspect is the use of vivid descriptions. When the author describes a spooky location, like a decrepit old cemetery with broken tombstones and mist swirling around, it really sets the mood and makes it scarier.
The stories in '67 scary stories' are often frightening because they play on our deepest fears. Fears of the dark, of being alone, of the supernatural. For instance, a story where a person is alone in a big, empty building at night and starts to feel that there are other 'things' there with them. It builds up the tension and makes our hair stand on end. Also, the vivid descriptions in the stories make the scary scenes seem real. They describe the coldness of a haunted place, the creepy sounds, and the menacing atmosphere in such detail that it's easy to get scared just by reading it.