Perhaps an older, retired Auror could be a good butler character. He has the skills and knowledge from his years of fighting dark wizards. He could use his combat experience to safeguard Harry, and his connections in the wizarding world to get information. He would be like a wise old mentor but in the role of a butler, teaching Harry things that even Dumbledore might not have thought of.
Argus Filch could be an interesting choice for a butler in fanfiction, if he had a change of heart. He already knows every nook and cranny of Hogwarts. If he became Harry's butler, he could use his knowledge of the castle's secrets to keep Harry safe. He could also use his cat, Mrs. Norris, to patrol the area around Harry's dormitory.
Dobby could be a great character as a butler in fanfiction. He already has a strong loyalty to Harry and his self - sacrificing nature would make him an excellent butler. He could use his house - elf magic to keep Harry's living quarters clean and protected.
Dobby could be a great butler. He was always eager to serve Harry and was very loyal. His knowledge of the Malfoy manor and other wizarding households could be useful. And his unique brand of magic, like his ability to apparate in and out of places where other wizards couldn't, would add an interesting dynamic to the story.
A character like Severus Snape could be an interesting choice. He already has that mysterious and somewhat dark aura about him. Transforming him into a demon butler would add an extra layer of complexity to his character, and his relationship with Harry could be re - imagined in a whole new way.
I think Sir Ian McKellen would be a great choice. He has that air of elegance and mystery about him. His acting skills are top - notch and he could bring a lot of depth to the role of the butler.
Luna Lovegood could also be a very interesting Head Boy (even if it breaks the traditional gender role a bit). Her unique perspective on magic and the world around her would bring a fresh air to Hogwarts leadership. She could start some really out - of - the - box initiatives like star - gazing classes for all students or encourage the study of magical creatures that are often overlooked.
Well, the plot could involve the cat - Harry Potter - stumbling into the Black Butler world. Maybe he's lost his human form due to some dark magic. He could then encounter Sebastian and Ciel. The cat - Harry - might use his magic in cat form to help or hinder the duo in their investigations. For example, he could use his invisibility ability (in cat form) to spy on enemies.
Yes, there might be some fanfiction that has such an interesting and rather unique concept. Some fanfic writers like to create crossovers and put unexpected twists in them. They might imagine Harry Potter as a cat within the world of Black Butler for various reasons, like exploring different character dynamics or just for the fun of it.
In Harry Potter fanfiction, a cat could be a magical familiar. For example, it might be a cat that can transform into a wizard's assistant when needed. In Black Butler fanfiction, a cat could be part of the Victorian - era setting, perhaps a stray that Ciel and Sebastian encounter on the streets of London.
How about Neville Longbottom? He could be the main character in a fanfiction set in the Chamber. Neville, who has always been underestimated, could show his true courage and strength. He might discover a hidden ability that helps him face the challenges in the Chamber, perhaps something related to his connection with plants, which could play a crucial role in defeating the Basilisk or whatever new threat is in the Chamber.
A character like Seraphina. She could be an old witch who has traveled the world studying different forms of divination. Her character could have a very mysterious aura, with a pet raven that she claims can also see glimpses of the future. She might wear long, flowing robes with strange symbols embroidered on them, representing different divination methods she has mastered.
Ron Weasley and Grell Sutcliff. Ron's clumsy but good - hearted nature would be a sharp contrast to Grell's flamboyant and somewhat bloodthirsty personality. Grell could be constantly frustrated by Ron's lack of finesse, while Ron would be completely bewildered by Grell's behavior. Their interactions would add a touch of humor to the crossover fanfiction.