The unknown nature of the cat's actions. For example, the cat's strange behavior like staring at the meat with a strange glint or leading the butcher on a chase through dark alleys. It creates an air of mystery and unease.
The transformation of the cat from an ordinary pet - like presence to something more menacing. When it shows human - like intelligence in its eyes or when it hisses in a way that makes the tough butcher shiver. Also, the cat's association with blood and dead animals in a somewhat abnormal way adds to the scariness.
Once upon a time, there was a butcher. He had a cat in his shop. The cat always seemed to stare at the meat with a strange glint in its eyes. One night, the butcher heard strange noises from the shop. When he went to check, he saw the cat standing over a pool of blood, with a freshly killed rat in its mouth. But the cat's eyes looked almost human, filled with a dark and menacing intelligence. It hissed at the butcher, making him shiver with fear.
The unknown. When you don't know what the cat is going to do or what it represents. For example, if the cat is just staring at you but you don't know why, it creates a sense of unease.
Perhaps it's the cat's appearance. If it has long, sharp claws and a wild look in its eyes, that can be really frightening.
In 'The Black Cat', the way the narrator's actions become more and more cruel and irrational is what makes it scary. He starts off normal but then begins to mistreat the cat and commits heinous acts. The cat's unwavering stare, which seems to be a sign of judgment, is also a factor that sends chills down the reader's spine.
There are several things that make cat stories scary. Firstly, cats are often associated with superstition. In many cultures, black cats are seen as a sign of bad luck. So when a story involves a black cat doing something strange like walking in a circle around a person at midnight, it creates fear. Secondly, cats' behavior at night. They are nocturnal animals and their glowing eyes in the dark can be quite intimidating. Also, if a cat behaves in an abnormal way, like constantly hissing at nothing or making strange noises, it adds to the scariness of the story.
The fact that the cat keeps coming back is just the start. Each time it returns, something more disturbing happens in the story. It could be strange noises or objects moving on their own. It creates an atmosphere of unease and mystery. And the cat seems to have some sort of power or connection to the place that is not normal. For example, it may come back after being left far away in a place it couldn't possibly find its way back from, which makes it seem otherworldly.
Well, cat's eyes are often seen as portals to another world in some horror tales. Their shape, with the slitted pupils, can look very alien - like. And when they stare without blinking, it gives the impression that they are sizing you up, maybe for something not so good. For example, in a story where a character is lost in a haunted forest and sees cat's eyes peering at them from the bushes, the unblinking stare and the mystery behind what the cat might be thinking or planning makes it really scary.
The unknown nature of the cat makes it scary. We don't know what it's really up to.
The unknown. In a cat scratch horror game story, not knowing what the cat represents or where the scratches are coming from is terrifying. For example, if you hear scratching but can't see the cat, it plays on your fear of the unseen.
In many such stories, the cat could be a symbol of something dark or cursed. Maybe it has some unnatural abilities like disappearing and reappearing suddenly, or making strange noises that send shivers down your spine. It could also be associated with a malevolent spirit, which makes it truly terrifying.