Imagine the two men are on a mostly empty subway car. There's a girl with sunglasses sitting at the end. As the train moves, the men notice that the girl's sunglasses are constantly changing color. They become curious and move closer. As they do, the girl suddenly looks up. The men can't see her eyes through the sunglasses, but they can feel a menacing aura. Then, the lights in the subway start to flicker. The girl stands up and starts walking towards them. The men back away until they're against the wall. The girl stops right in front of them and just stands there silently, the mystery of what's behind her sunglasses and her strange behavior making the situation extremely scary.
There were two men on the subway. They were sitting across from a girl who was wearing sunglasses. The men noticed that the girl never took off her sunglasses, not even when she entered the dimly - lit subway car. As the train rattled along, one of the men caught a glimpse of something strange behind the girl's sunglasses. It looked like there were no eyes, just a black void. They both started to feel a sense of dread. Suddenly, the girl turned towards them and smiled a sinister smile, and they realized she wasn't human at all.
A group of triangles could be chasing a square. The triangles' sharp points could be like weapons, and the square, with its four equal sides, has no way to escape easily. It's like a prey being hunted by predators.
A scenario could be a person walking in a foggy forest. They find a ribbon on the ground, thinking it's a lost item. When they put it around their neck, they suddenly can't see anything but the ribbon growing and tightening. They hear strange howls and feel as if they are being dragged deeper into the forest by an unseen force through the tightening of the ribbon around their neck.
The two men are a key element. Their appearance, like if they are dressed strangely or have a menacing look. Another could be their actions, such as acting in an odd or threatening way towards other passengers.
I'm not sure exactly which 'two men subway scary story' you mean. There could be many such stories. Maybe it's about two strange men seen in a subway late at night, with one having a menacing look and the other acting really oddly, making the passengers feel scared.
A family had a beautiful Christmas tree with lots of shiny decorations. One night, they noticed that the snowflake - shaped ornaments were melting, but not because of heat. They were melting into a strange, gooey substance that started to drip down the tree. Then, the miniature presents under the tree opened on their own, revealing tiny, clawed hands reaching out. The Christmas tree decorations had become a source of pure horror as the family watched helplessly.
Here's a scary scenario. A little girl goes missing in the Louvre near the Mona Lisa display. When the guards search, they find her standing in front of the painting, but she's in a trance. She starts to speak in an old language that no one understands. The Mona Lisa's eyes seem to be the source of a strange power that has taken over the girl. It sends shivers down everyone's spine.
An opossum that can speak in a raspy, evil voice. It could lure people into the woods by promising them treasures, but actually leading them to their doom.
A scenario could be that a person is tied to a chair in a dark basement. There are strange noises all around. Suddenly, they see a figure emerging from the shadows. The figure slowly approaches the chair and starts to whisper things that the person can't quite understand, but it sends shivers down their spine. The chair starts to shake on its own, and the person realizes they are completely at the mercy of whatever this entity is.
A group of hikers were smoking weed on a mountain trail. They decided to set off some firecrackers to celebrate reaching a peak. But the moment the firecrackers exploded, a rockslide started. The weed had made them slow to react. As they tried to run, they found themselves in a cave. Inside the cave, there were strange markings and an eerie silence. Then, they heard a growling sound, and something started chasing them in the dark, and they couldn't see clearly because of the after - effects of the weed.