Well, that's a bit subjective. If the story has elements like creepy settings, mysterious characters, and sudden twists, it might be scary. But it also depends on how it's told and your own imagination.
It could be in the dark forest she described. Maybe when she was alone and heard strange noises.
It's her magic. She can cast dark spells that can change the lives of those she targets for the worse. For example, she can take away someone's most precious abilities like their voice or their freedom to move. Also, she is very cunning. She often tricks her victims by disguising her true intentions at first, making them trust her before she strikes.
The girl with the green scarf was waiting at the bus stop late at night. A strange man approached her and stared at her scarf. He told her that the green scarf was a sign of doom. She laughed it off at first. But then, the bus she was waiting for never came. Instead, a horse - drawn carriage arrived. The driver, a faceless figure, beckoned her to get in. The girl's scarf seemed to be pulled towards the carriage. She resisted, but the scarf got caught on the carriage wheel. As the carriage started to move, she had to run to keep up or be strangled by her own scarf. Finally, she managed to free herself and ran home, shaken by the experience.
Once upon a time, in an old, abandoned asylum, there was a rumor of a corpse that roamed the halls at night looking for her toe. Legend had it that she was a patient who had lost her toe in a cruel experiment. Every night, a cold chill would sweep through the corridors as she dragged her mangled body, moaning and searching. People said if you heard her dragging footsteps, you should run, or she might mistake you for the one who took her toe.
There was an old woman with her dog. The dog was a large, shaggy beast that seemed to have a menacing air about it. The old woman lived alone in an old cottage. One day, a young girl went missing near the cottage. People started to suspect the old woman and her dog. Whenever anyone got close to the cottage, the dog would bark ferociously. The old woman would just stand there, staring blankly. Eventually, a group of villagers went to investigate. When they got close, they heard strange noises coming from inside. The dog suddenly burst out, scaring them all. They later found out that the old woman was a witch and the dog was her familiar, and they had something to do with the missing girl.
Once upon a time, there was a girl who always wore many rings on her fingers. One night, she heard strange noises. As she looked at her rings, they seemed to glow with an eerie light. Then, she felt a cold hand grabbing her fingers. The rings suddenly tightened, cutting into her skin. She screamed but no one could hear her. In the end, she disappeared, and only her rings were left, still glowing in the empty room.
By using a low, hushed voice. When an old woman speaks in a very quiet, almost whisper - like voice while telling a story, it immediately creates an eerie atmosphere.
Once upon a time, there was a girl who always wore a ribbon around her neck. One night, a strange wind blew through her house. She woke up feeling a cold touch on her ribbon. As she opened her eyes, she saw a shadowy figure tugging at it. Terrified, she tried to scream but no sound came out. The figure just kept pulling until the ribbon tightened around her neck, choking her.
There was this girl. She had a beautiful silk ribbon around her neck. Nobody knew why she never took it off. One day, she went to an old mansion. As she explored, she heard faint whispers. The ribbon seemed to shiver. It slowly began to constrict her. She was terrified. She ran, but the ribbon cut off her air supply. In the end, she was found lifeless on the floor of the mansion, the ribbon still tightly wound around her neck, and her face frozen in horror.
Once upon a time, there was a girl named Lily. She went for a walk in the old, spooky forest near her town. As she was walking, she heard strange noises. Suddenly, a hidden trap snapped shut on her foot, cutting off her toe. She screamed in pain, but then she saw a shadowy figure approaching. It was an old witch who lived in the forest. The witch cackled and said she would use Lily's toe for a dark spell. Lily was terrified and tried to run, but she could barely move with her injured foot. That night, she thought she would never escape the forest alive.