The main reasons could be that the OC lacks depth and development, or the fanfiction just doesn't capture the charm and tone of the original Harry Potter universe.
Often, the problem is that the OC's storylines are too far-fetched or don't mesh with the existing magic system and characters. Plus, the writing quality might not be up to par.
It might be because some OC characters don't fit well into the established Harry Potter world and seem out of place.
One reason could be that it deviated too much from the original tone and style of the Harry Potter series. The characters seemed to act out of character at times. For example, some of the relationships and character developments felt forced, not in line with how they were built up in the previous books.
Well, Harry Potter has a rich and detailed world. It has a huge number of fans who create various fan works. Its story has complex characters like Harry, Hermione and Ron. The magic system is well - defined. All these elements make it a great source for fanfiction, thus considered a model.
Some people think fanfiction is bad because it might not have the same quality or originality as the original work. Also, it could potentially violate copyright laws in some cases.
I don't think Harry Potter is godling fanfiction. Harry Potter is an original and highly creative work by J.K. Rowling. It has its own independent world - building, unique characters, and a complex and complete magic system. It's not a derivative work based on some pre - existing 'godling' concept in the sense of fanfiction.
Well, in fanfiction, Harry might be seen as the hottest because of his heroic deeds. He's the Boy Who Lived, and that makes him super appealing. His courage in facing Voldemort time and time again gives him an air of mystery and strength, which are very attractive qualities.
Well, Harry Potter is fiction because it's the creation of an author's imagination. The events, settings, and characters are all invented to take readers on an enchanting and fantastical journey that couldn't happen in reality.
Well, some people think RWBY is bad fanfiction because of its inconsistent writing. For example, the plot sometimes has holes and the character development can be really shaky. One moment a character acts one way, and then suddenly, without much build - up, they're completely different. It gives the feeling of being hastily put together like a not - so - great fanfic.
Some people think it's bad because it might not have the same quality or depth as officially published works.
It depends. If the cheats are overused and make the story too easy for the main character, it can be bad writing. But if they are part of a well - thought - out concept, like a cheat being a curse in disguise that has negative consequences later, then it can be great. In some fanfics, cheats are used to explore 'what - if' scenarios in the 'Harry Potter' universe, which can be really engaging.
Some so - called 'cancerous' Harry Potter fanfiction might exist where the author completely misinterprets the original characters or themes. For example, making Harry into a completely out - of - character villain. It could also be due to really bad writing, like having a plot that makes no sense in the context of the Harry Potter universe.