For me, good manga has a balance of action, emotion, and interesting themes. It also has consistent world-building and doesn't leave you confused. Plus, the dialogue has to feel natural and not forced.
A good manga typically has a unique concept or story that stands out. The pacing is just right, not too fast or too slow. And the author knows how to build suspense and create cliffhangers to keep you coming back for more.
Good manga usually has an engaging plot that keeps you hooked. The characters are well-developed and relatable, and the art style is visually appealing.
Emotional depth is a key characteristic. A good yaoi story can make you feel the characters' love, pain, and joy. In 'Super Lovers', the main character's journey of coming to terms with his feelings for his adopted brother is filled with a lot of emotions. And also, an interesting plot. It could be something unique like in 'No. 6' where the post - apocalyptic setting adds a whole new layer to the yaoi relationship story.
A key characteristic is the exploration of adult - level emotions. Mature manga like 'Your Lie in April' explores grief, love, and regret in a way that is relatable yet profound. The art in such manga also plays a role. It can be detailed and used to enhance the mood of the story, as seen in 'Attack on Titan' where the detailed drawings of the Titans add to the horror and intensity of the story. Moreover, mature manga with good stories often have a sense of realism. They don't rely on simple happy - endings but show the consequences of actions, similar to how 'Grave of the Fireflies' shows the harsh reality of war and its impact on civilians.
Good manga often have unique art styles. For example, in 'Tokyo Ghoul', the art beautifully depicts the grotesque yet fascinating world of ghouls. The characters in good manga are also well - defined. They have distinct personalities and backstories. In light novels, a strong plot is crucial. 'The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya' has a really interesting and convoluted plot that keeps readers hooked. Another characteristic is the ability to create an immersive world, like in the manga 'Naruto' where the ninja world feels real and full of possibilities.
Good manga stories often have engaging characters. The characters are well - developed, with their own personalities, goals, and flaws. For example, in 'One Piece', each member of the Straw Hat crew has a distinct backstory and motivation. Another characteristic is a unique and interesting plot. It could be a thrilling adventure like in 'Naruto' where the protagonist chases his dream of becoming Hokage. Also, good manga stories usually have high - quality art that can effectively convey the emotions and actions in the story.
Good Splatoon manga fanfic often has vivid descriptions of the battles. For example, it can clearly show how inklings use their ink - based weapons. Also, unique character designs are important. The fanfic might introduce new inklings with different personalities and looks.
Well, first of all, it should have well - developed characters. For example, in 'One Piece', each character has their own backstory, dreams, and personalities that make them feel real. Second, a good plot is crucial. It needs to have a clear beginning, middle, and end, like in 'Naruto' where Naruto's journey from an outcast to a hero is a well - structured story. Third, it often has themes that resonate with the readers, such as friendship, love, or justice. In 'Fruits Basket', the theme of acceptance and breaking the cycle of family curses is very touching.
Good manga often have great art styles. For example, in 'Tokyo Ghoul', the detailed and dark art really enhances the mood of the story. In light novels, a strong narrative voice is important. 'A Certain Magical Index' has a complex world - building through its narrative. Also, interesting characters are key in both. In 'Naruto', the characters like Naruto himself and Sasuke are very relatable and have complex personalities.
The plot itself should be engaging. It can't just be a series of sexual scenes. Take 'Nana' for instance. It has a story about two girls named Nana who are on different paths in life. There are some romantic and passionate relationships in it. The overall plot about their friendship, career aspirations, and love lives holds the story together, and the 'smutty' elements are just part of the bigger picture of the characters' lives.
Good harem manga and light novels often have a likable male protagonist. He might be an ordinary guy in an extraordinary situation or have some special abilities. For example, in 'High School DxD', Issei has the power of the Red Dragon Emperor. The female characters are diverse, with different personalities, looks, and abilities. This creates a lot of interesting interactions.
Manga novels usually have unique art styles. Some may feature highly stylized characters with big eyes and elaborate hairstyles, which are typical in the manga genre. In terms of story, they can cover a wide range of themes, from fantasy adventures to slice - of - life tales. They also often have a serialized nature, with the story evolving over multiple volumes.