Regarding the Central TV version of Dragons and Demons?

Putting aside the original novel.
I didn't see the front, but I saw the back.
It was at the Shaolin Temple where Xiao Feng, Duan Yu, Xuzhu, Murong Fu, Xiao Yuanshan, Murong Bo, Jiu Mozhi, and the others gathered for the martial arts tournament.
Two questions.
Huang Rihua's version was that Xiao Yuanshan and Xiao Feng looked the same, so people mistook them for each other. Therefore, everyone thought that Xiao Feng was a villain who killed people everywhere for revenge. Xiao Feng's reputation was ruined, and he became a Khitan thief that everyone cursed.
The abbot of Shaolin Temple was exposed by Xiao Yuanshan, which made Shaolin Temple lose face. Later, after hearing Duan Yu's reminder, he attacked Murong Fu and forced Murong Bo to show up to confirm his suspicion.
However, it was different in the Central TV version. Xiao Yuanshan deliberately made himself look like Xiao Feng and went around killing people. It made people feel that Xiao Yuanshan was deliberately framing Xiao Feng so that Xiao Feng would be forced into a dead end.
After the Shaolin abbot's past was exposed, he didn't attack Murong Fu. Instead, he acted like a despicable person and exposed Murong Bo. It felt like his own embarrassing matter had been exposed. He didn't want Murong Bo to live in peace and pushed the responsibility to Murong Bo.
Comparing the two versions, it made people realize that the difference in standards was too great.
In Huang Rihua's version, everyone would sympathize with Xiao Yuanshan and Xiao Feng. Because Xiao Yuanshan looked exactly like Xiao Feng, people would mistake him for someone else. Even if Xiao Yuanshan wasn't a hero, he was still a good man.
However, the Central TV version made me feel that Xiao Yuanshan was a despicable person who hid his head and exposed his tail. He actually framed his own son. It made me despise him. If I were Xiao Feng, I really wouldn't think that such a person was qualified to be my father.
Huang Rihua's version. The abbot of Shaolin Temple was also quite a character. Even if his past was exposed and his reputation was damaged, he still took into account that Murong Bo was already dead and didn't want Murong Bo to be in peace after his death. It was Duan Yu who reminded him that Murong Bo might not be dead, so he just tested him. From this, it could be seen that although this abbot could not be called a hero, he was still a good abbot. After all, he carried the foundation of Shaolin Temple for thousands of years, so his actions were justified.
However, the Central TV version seemed to be about two people going to steal something. After many years, one of them was caught, but the other was exposed. There was probably something wrong with the character of such people.
Logically speaking, these famous directors wouldn't make such a low-level mistake.
In Huang Rihua's version, when Murong Bo and his son confronted Xiao Yuanshan and his son in the Sutra Depository, Murong Bo lured Xiao Feng, hoping that he would encourage Liao to send troops to attack Song Dynasty. Although Xiao Yuanshan was a little tempted, he looked at Xiao Feng with gratification when he saw Xiao Feng's words of loyalty and love for the country. He felt that his son was a hero.
From this, it could be seen that although Xiao Yuanshan was blinded by hatred, he did not want Xiao Feng to do anything for revenge, nor did he want his son to live in hatred for the rest of his life. Therefore, he was indeed admirable.
On the other hand, the actions of the Central TV version of Xiao Yuanshan were really not admirable. He did not have the boldness and spirit of Xiao Feng at all. He only cared about hatred and did not care about others. He even had the heart to push his own son into the fire pit.

Answer 1

The Central TV version of " The Eight Dragons " was a TV series adapted from Mr. Jin Yong's novel. It told the story of Duan Yu, Xu Zhu, Murong Fu, and others in the underworld. The following are some questions about the CCTV version of "Tian Long Ba Bu":

1. Is the CCTV version of " Tian Long Ba Bu " the same as the original?

It was basically the same as the original work, but there were some cuts and adjustments in terms of character creation, plot setting, and plot development.

2. Do the actors in the CCTV version of "Dragons and Demons" match the characters in the original work?

The actors 'performances were basically in line with the characters in the original novel, but some of the characters' appearances, personalities, and settings were slightly adjusted.

3. Has the CCTV version of "Demigods and Semi-Devils" been approved by Mr. Jin Yong?

Mr. Jin Yong had a high evaluation of the CCTV version of " Demigods and Semi-Devils ", praising the production level and the performance of the actors.

4. Was the CCTV version of "Demigods and Semi-Devils" generally accepted by the audience?

CCTV's version of " Dragons and Demons " had been recognized by the audience in terms of production level, actors 'performances, and plot setting, but there were also some aspects that could be controversial.