Why was there such a huge contrast between Zhuge Liang in history and in novels? In history, he was simply a good-for-nothing, but in the novel, he was so godly?

2024-09-19 14:43

In the official history, Zhuge Liang's military ability was not even comparable to Cao Zhen's, and was even worse than Lu Xun and Zhou Yu's. Why did Luo Guanzhong risk universal condemnation and go against history? Not to mention that Meng De looked down on him, even Liu Bei did not really put him in an important position. The person Liu Bei put in an important position was Fa Xiaozhi.

1 answer

2024-09-19 17:47

The main reason why Zhuge Liang's image in history was so different from that in the novel was that there was a big difference between the historical and the novel. In history, Zhuge Liang was a very smart, intelligent, upright and loyal figure. He made great contributions to the country and was known as "Mr. Wolong". However, due to his overly cautious and conservative personality, he might be criticized for certain decisions. In addition, he also had some historical disputes, such as his governance in the late Shu Han Dynasty. In the novel, Zhuge Liang's image was portrayed as a very smart, witty, talented, brave and fearless character. He could call the wind and summon the rain, control the situation, and help the protagonist complete various tasks. In the novel, his image was even more lofty and heroic, making people feel a sense of worship. In addition, the creation of novels was often based on the author's imagination and creativity. They could freely shape the image and character of the characters. Therefore, Zhuge Liang in the novel might be more exaggerated, humorous or absurd, which was different from the image in history. To sum up, the main reason why Zhuge Liang's image in history was so different from that in the novel was that the way he wrote the novel was different from that in history.

Was Zhuge Liang really as godly as in Romance of the Three Kingdoms? Was there a big difference between the Zhuge Liang in official history and the novel?

1 answer

2024-09-23 19:53

Zhuge Liang was a famous politician, strategist and inventor in ancient China. His image in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms was very successful. However, there was a big difference between real historical figures and novels, plays, and other literary works. In the official history, Zhuge Liang was an important figure in the Shu Han Dynasty during the Three Kingdoms period. He once served as the prime minister of the Shu Han Dynasty and presided over the state affairs and military affairs. Zhuge Liang was a very intelligent and talented man. He had made outstanding contributions to politics, military affairs, culture and so on. During the Shu Han period, he had put forward many suggestions for governing the country, such as "dividing the world into three parts" and "governing the country safely", which were deeply praised by people at that time. Although novels, plays, and other literary works exaggerate and embellish Zhuge Liang's image, we should realize that there is a big gap between real historical figures and literary works. When evaluating historical figures, we should analyze and judge them based on objective facts and evidence, not just based on the evaluation of literary works.

What was the difference between the Zhuge Liang in history and the one described in novels?

1 answer

2024-09-23 06:29

There were many differences between the Zhuge Liang in history and the one described in the novel. The following are some of the main points: 1. There is a difference between historical records and novel creation: historical records are very different from novel creation. Historical records tend to be more objective, rigorous, and focus on facts and evidence. On the other hand, the creation of novels was more subjective and focused on the plot and character creation. Therefore, there might be some differences in details between the Zhuge Liang in history and the Zhuge Liang described in the novel. 2. Character images are different from literary images: novels are a fictional art form that express the author's views and thoughts through the creation of character images and plot construction. The Zhuge Liang in history was a historical figure. His character image and literary image might be influenced by the author and the times. 3. The historical background and plot setting are different. In historical records, Zhuge Liang was the prime minister of Shu Han during the Three Kingdoms period. His main story took place during the Three Kingdoms period. In the novel, Zhuge Liang was a fictional character, and the plot might vary according to different literary styles and creative purposes. Historical details and plot conflicts are different: in historical records, Zhuge Liang's main goal in Shu Han was to govern the country and support the people. In novels, some romantic plots and character creation may be added to highlight Zhuge Liang's resourcefulness and political talent. Therefore, the historical Zhuge Liang and the Zhuge Liang described in the novel might have different plot settings and details. There are many differences between the Zhuge Liang in history and the Zhuge Liang described in novels. These differences may be caused by the differences in historical records and novel creation, as well as the influence of authors and times.

Was Zhuge Liang a real figure in history?

1 answer

2024-09-26 00:02

Zhuge Liang was a real figure in history. He was a military strategist, politician, and inventor of the Shu Han Dynasty during the Three Kingdoms period. He was known as "Mr. Wolong" and "Zhuge Wuhou". He became one of the most respected figures in Chinese history because of his outstanding talent, wisdom, and leadership. Zhuge Liang's life story was recorded in his "Book of Commandments" and "Later Master's Table", which became classics of Chinese culture. He also put forward some important ideas and policies in politics, such as "dividing the world into three parts" and "admonishing Liu Bei not to appoint eunuchs", which had a far-reaching impact on Chinese history. Although there were some disputes and untruths in the historical records, Zhuge Liang's authenticity as a historical figure was widely recognized.

What was the real Zhuge Liang in history?

1 answer

2024-09-25 23:33

The real Zhuge Liang in history was an outstanding politician, strategist, and inventor, known as the "greatest sage of the Three Kingdoms". Zhuge Liang lived from 181 to 234 A. D. He was a statesman and military strategist in the Shu Han Dynasty during the Three Kingdoms period. With his outstanding talent, wisdom, and courage, he had made great achievements in the fields of politics, military affairs, and diplomacy. In politics, Zhuge Liang advocated for political stability and put forward the idea of "taking governance as the foundation" and served as an important official in Shu Han. He also put forward the idea of "cultivating one's moral character, managing one's family, governing the country, and pacifying the world", emphasizing the importance of personal cultivation. In terms of military affairs, Zhuge Liang held many positions in Shu Han, including military commander and diplomatic envoy. He had successfully resisted many attacks from Cao Wei and displayed extraordinary military talent in the Battle of Yiling. In terms of diplomacy, Zhuge Liang actively participated in the diplomatic activities of Shu Han and successfully established cooperative relations with Wu and Cao Wei. He also put forward the strategy of "making friends far away and attacking near", which laid the foundation for the development of Shu Han. Zhuge Liang was also an outstanding inventor. He invented many practical items such as Kongming Lantern and Kongming Lock. Zhuge Liang was a historical figure with widespread influence. His thoughts, talent, and courage had a profound impact on Chinese history and culture.

What was the real Zhuge Liang in history?

1 answer

2024-09-25 23:26

The real Zhuge Liang in history was an outstanding politician, strategist, and writer, known as the "greatest sage of the Three Kingdoms". He was born in 181 and died in 234. He was the prime minister of Shu Han. Zhuge Liang was very outstanding in politics. He put forward many important policies such as "dividing the world into three parts" and "persuading Liu Bei not to attack Dongwu", which laid a solid foundation for the development of Shu Han. He was also good at using talents to put Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun and other generals, as well as Liu Bei's brothers and relatives, into a powerful military force. Zhuge Liang was also very outstanding in military affairs. He proposed the "Empty City Strategy" and other military strategies to successfully resist the attack of Cao Wei and led the army to defeat Sima Yi, the general of Wei. Zhuge Liang also had high attainments in literature. He had written many excellent literary works such as the Book of Commandments, which had a profound impact on the development of Chinese culture. Zhuge Liang was a historical figure with great wisdom, talent, and leadership. His thoughts, actions, and contributions would always be remembered by people.

Is Luo Guanshui a down-and-out literati? Is he pinning his political ideals on himself by writing Zhuge Liang so godly? Is he treating himself as Zhuge Liang?

1 answer

2024-09-20 04:52

Luo Guanshui was a famous writer in Chinese history. His novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms was widely regarded as a classic in the history of Chinese literature. In the novel, Luo Guanshui described a fictional Three Kingdoms period and portrayed Zhuge Liang as the main character. Although Luo Guanshui's novels were not widely praised, his literary achievements could not be ignored. His novels were famous for their rich imagination, profound characters and excellent narrative skills. Romance of the Three Kingdoms was regarded as a classic of ancient Chinese novels. As for whether Luo Guan Shui was a down-and-out scholar, there was no conclusive evidence. However, it could be seen from his works that he had a certain literary talent and the ability to think independently. Although his novels did not gain a high reputation, he still expressed his thoughts and feelings about society and life through his works. There was no clear answer to the question of whether Zhuge Liang's godlike writing was a manifestation of his own political ideals. Because the Zhuge Liang created by Luo Guan Shui was a fictional character, his actions and decisions were based on the needs of the plot of the novel. Therefore, he could not compare Luo Guan Shui with Zhuge Liang or entrust his political ideals.

Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition was essentially a huge gamble. Why did he fail?

1 answer

2024-09-23 06:05

Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition was essentially a shocking gamble with a small amount of money. Why did it fail? As the Prime Minister of Shu Han, Zhuge Liang had always hoped that the Northern Expedition would succeed in restoring the Central Plains, but the process of the Northern Expedition was not smooth sailing. In a war, any attack required the preparation of funds, personnel, materials, and other support. However, Zhuge Liang's lack of preparation in these aspects caused his northern expedition to be thwarted many times. Secondly, Zhuge Liang encountered various difficulties during the Northern Expedition. For example, he needed to pass through dangerous areas such as mountain roads, and there were often ambushes in these areas. In addition, the difference in national strength between Shu Han and Cao Wei also led to the low success rate of the Northern Expedition. Finally, Zhuge Liang also made strategic mistakes in the Northern Expedition. He had tried many times to launch a surprise attack on Cao Wei's defense line, but these actions were seen through by Cao Wei's soldiers, causing his plans to fail many times. To sum up, Zhuge Liang's failure in the Northern Expedition was due to many factors, including insufficient preparation, strategic mistakes, national strength gap, terrain constraints and other factors.

What kind of person was Zhuge Liang in history?

1 answer

2024-09-25 23:47

The real Zhuge Liang in history was an outstanding politician, strategist, and writer, known as the "greatest sage of the Three Kingdoms". He was born in 181 and died in 234. He was the prime minister of Shu Han during the Three Kingdoms period. Zhuge Liang's life story had been passed down to this day, and his talent and contributions were widely used in Chinese history and culture. He made many important political and economic suggestions, such as developing agriculture, promoting electricity, building a railway, and implementing tax reform. He was also good at military command and won many victories in the war. After the fall of Shu Han, he continued to work hard for the revival of Shu Han and finally died at the age of 63. Zhuge Liang was a highly respected historical figure whose ideas and contributions had a profound impact on Chinese history and culture.

What kind of person was Zhuge Liang in history?

1 answer

2024-09-25 23:47

The real Zhuge Liang in history was an outstanding politician, military strategist, and inventor. He was also an important figure in Shu Han during the Three Kingdoms period. He was born in 181 and died in 234 at the age of 61. Zhuge Liang was one of the famous politicians in Chinese history. He advocated governing the country as the main means to promote social development and progress. He had served as the prime minister, the military advisor general, and many other positions in Shu Han, making great contributions to the development and stability of Shu Han. In terms of military affairs, Zhuge Liang was also an outstanding general. He had led the army on many expeditions and won a series of victories. He was one of the famous military strategists in Chinese history. Zhuge Liang also invented many practical objects such as Kongming Lantern, straw boat and borrowed arrows, which had a profound impact on the development of Chinese culture. His life story was widely praised by later generations as "Mr. Wolong".

What kind of person was Zhuge Liang in history?

1 answer

2024-09-25 23:41

The real Zhuge Liang in history (181 - 234 years), whose name was Kongming, and whose name was Wolong, was an important politician, strategist, and writer in the Shu Han Dynasty during the Three Kingdoms period. He was born in the Bashu area of the Sichuan Basin. He was intelligent and good at poetry, military affairs, and politics since childhood. Zhuge Liang had high political talent and prestige, and was known as "Mr. Wolong". He advocated using military means to govern the country and put forward the idea of "using troops only when they are not warlike", emphasizing the need to strengthen the construction and training of the army in times of peace. He also put forward a series of strategies and policies such as "benevolent government","emphasizing agriculture and suppressing commerce","lenient punishment and illegal", which had a positive impact on the politics, economy and society at that time. Zhuge Liang also performed well in military affairs. He had served as a general many times in the wars between Shu Han and Wei. He was brave and good at fighting, and was known as the "Marquis Wu". He also planned many important military operations during the Shu Han period, such as pacifying Nanzhong and the Northern Expedition to Cao Wei, and achieved remarkable victories. Zhuge Liang was one of the most respected figures in Chinese history. His ideas and contributions had a profound impact on Chinese culture and society. During the Three Kingdoms period, he was known as the "greatest advisor of the Three Kingdoms" and was honored as "Marquis Wu" and "Kong Ming". He was a famous politician, strategist, and writer in Chinese history.