Sima Qian's Records of the Historian or Sima Guang's Zi Zhi Tong Jian, which book was more credible?

2024-09-17 05:05

1 answer

2024-09-17 09:15

Records of the Historian and Zi Zhi Tong Jian were two important historical documents in ancient China, both of which had high historical value. However, due to their large age span, their credibility is subject to some controversy. From a historical point of view, Sima Qian's Records of the Historian was the most famous book in ancient Chinese history books and the first step in the history of Chinese history. It recorded the history from the Xia Dynasty to the Han Dynasty, including many historical events and people. Many of the stories and legends in the Records of the Historian were also widely spread and became an important part of Chinese culture. In contrast, Sima Guang's Zi Zhi Tong Jian was the most important chronicle of ancient Chinese history. It recorded the history of China from 403 B.C. to 959 A.D., covering the Xia, Shang, Zhou, Qin, Han, Three Kingdoms, Jin, Northern and Southern Dynasties, Sui, Tang, Five Dynasties, Song, Yuan, Ming and other periods. Zi Zhi Tong Jian included many historical events and figures in politics, economy, culture, military, etc. It had important reference value for the study of ancient Chinese history. Due to the large historical span between Records of the Historian and Zi Zhi Tong Jian, their credibility was different. However, no matter which history book it was, it was an important part of ancient Chinese history. It was of great significance to the study of ancient Chinese history.

How to evaluate Sima Qian's Records of the Historian

1 answer

2024-09-24 01:01

Sima Qian's " Records of the Historian " was a historical biography written by Sima Qian, a historian of the Western Han Dynasty. It was hailed as the pinnacle of ancient Chinese history books and one of the most important documents in ancient China. "Records of the Historian" used historical events as clues to describe the characters, culture, geography, politics and other aspects of Chinese history in a comprehensive and detailed manner. At the same time, it combined a large number of myths and legends and Taoist thoughts to form a unique narrative style. From a literary point of view, Sima Qian's " Records of the Historian " was regarded as a classic work of ancient Chinese history books with extremely high literary and artistic value. Its narrative is smooth, the writing is beautiful, the characters are vivid, the plot is ups and downs, especially its rich and colorful myths and legends and Taoist ideas make it more literary and influential. At the same time, Records of the Historian was also an important part of ancient Chinese historical documents. It had important reference value for studying ancient Chinese history and culture. Generally speaking, Sima Qian's Records of the Historian is a classic work in ancient Chinese history books. It not only has extremely high literary value and historical value, but also an important part of ancient Chinese culture. It has important reference value for us to understand and study ancient Chinese history and culture.

Which dynasty was Sima Qian from? Records of Sima Qian's life

1 answer

2024-09-16 04:57

Sima Qian was a historian and writer during the Han Dynasty in China. He was born in 141 B.C. and died in 94 B.C. He was the author of the Records of the Historian, the most famous book in Chinese history. Sima Qian was born in a noble family. His father, Sima Qian, had once served as the Grand Scribe of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, so he had received a very good education and training. Sima Qian began to study history when he was young. Later, he became an official and served in the court of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty. In his work, he created many literary works about Chinese history and culture, including the Records of the Historian. Records of the Historian is a classic work of ancient Chinese history books. It records historical events and figures from the Xia Dynasty to the Western Han Dynasty, which has a profound impact on the study of ancient Chinese history and culture. Sima Qian described historical events in an objective and fair manner in the Records of the Historian and added his own analysis and opinions, making this history book a highly valuable document. Although Sima Qian's life was full of ups and downs, his contribution to Chinese history and culture could not be ignored. His works and thoughts had a profound impact on Chinese history and culture, and he was also one of the important figures in the history of ancient Chinese culture.

Who had Sima Qian's full version of the Records of the Historian?

1 answer

2024-09-20 05:22

Sima Qian's Records of the Historian could not be found because the Records of the Historian was a historical book written by Sima Qian of the Western Han Dynasty. It was written between 1046 B.C. and 879 B.C. It was divided into 130 volumes and contained 3859 words. Because the book was not yet to be continued, no complete version had been passed down to this day. However, Sima Qian's " Records of the Historian " enjoyed a high reputation in the field of literature and history. It was translated into many languages and was widely used in literature, history, philosophy, and other fields.

What did Lu Xun call Sima Qian's Records of the Historian?

1 answer

2024-09-20 14:10

Sima Qian's Records of the Historian was called " The First Book in the History of Chinese Fictions " by Lu Xun.

Wu Xia Amon was selected from Sima Guang's Zi Zhi Tong Jian. What story did he mainly tell?

1 answer

2024-09-14 10:31

" Wu Xia Meng " was selected from Sima Guang's Zi Zhi Tong Jian. It was an ancient novel that told the story of Wu Kingdom's general Meng during the Spring and Autumn Period. According to records, Amon had displayed extraordinary military talent when he was young and had led the army to defeat the enemy many times. During the war between the Wu Kingdom and the Yue Kingdom, Amon once again served as the general of the Wu Kingdom and led the army to fight the Yue army. In the battle, Amon used his intelligence and courage to finally win. At the end of the story, Amon was hailed as a hero because he was brave and good at fighting, and was written into historical documents.

When did Sima Qian officially start writing Records of the Historian?

1 answer

2024-09-11 14:17

According to the preface to the first volume of the Records of the Historian, Sima Qian began writing the Records of the Historian in 121 B.C.

Why was it said that Sima Qian had falsified and tampered with history in the Records of the Historian?

1 answer

2024-09-17 13:43

Sima Qian was a famous historian in Chinese history and one of the authors of the Chronicle of the Historian. When he compiled the Chronicle of the Historian, he had high requirements for the authenticity and accuracy of historical events. However, due to the political environment and various reasons at that time, Sima Qian had some problems with the historical records in the Records of the Historian. One of the problems was that Sima Qian might have fabricated or exaggerated some historical events when he recorded them. For example, in the Records of the Historian, he recorded the "curse of witchcraft" during the reign of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, but there were certain exaggerations and intruths. In addition, Sima Qian's recording of some historical events might also be affected by political factors. For example, there might be some prejudice and misunderstanding in the description of the change of ancient dynasties and political struggles. The existence of these problems caused Sima Qian's historical records to have certain disputes and doubts. Some people believed that Sima Qian had distorted and misled the true face of ancient history by falsified and falsified history in the Records of the Historian. These errors and distortions in historical records had a profound impact on the development and research of ancient Chinese history. However, it should be pointed out that Sima Qian's work as a historian was based on a large amount of reliable historical information. Although there were some problems in the Records of the Historian, it was still an important part of ancient Chinese historical documents, which had an important impact on the historical research and development of later generations.

The following statements about the Records of the Historian are wrong: [ ] A. The author is Sima Qian. B. It records from...

1 answer

2024-09-16 04:54

The following statements about the Records of the Historian are wrong. A. The author is Sima Qian. The Records of the Historian was a general history of the Western Han Dynasty written by Sima Qian. It was written in 1046 B.C. and was the most important historical book in ancient China.

The situation of the peasant uprising at the end of the Qin Dynasty, Sima Qian's life, and the knowledge of the Records of the Historian?

1 answer

2024-09-13 22:59

The situation of the peasant uprising at the end of the Qin Dynasty, Sima Qian's life and the knowledge of the Records of the Historian: 1. The situation of the peasant uprising at the end of Qin Dynasty: After the fall of the Qin Dynasty, the peasant uprising at the end of the Qin Dynasty was a large-scale war that led to the end of the short-term rule of the Qin Dynasty. The uprising started in 206 B.C., and a peasant army led by Chen Sheng and Wu Guang gradually developed into a nationwide war. The main force of the uprising army was the peasants. They demanded the abolition of the harsh taxes and laws of the Qin Dynasty to achieve equality and freedom. Although the rebel army was small at first, it soon defeated the Qin army and occupied a large area of land. Finally, the last emperor of the Qin Dynasty, Qin Shihuang, committed suicide. The peasant uprising at the end of the Qin Dynasty also ended the rule of the Qin Dynasty. 2. Sima Qian's Life: Sima Qian (about 141 B.C. -about 90 B.C.) was born in Jingzhao Prefecture of the Western Han Dynasty (now Xi'an City, Shaanxi Province). He was a famous historian in Chinese history and the author of the historical chronicle, Records of the Historian. Sima Qian used to serve under Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty in his early years. However, he was alienated because he opposed Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty's autocratic rule and eventually fled to Korea. During his time in Korea, he served as the prime minister of Korea before returning to China to continue writing Records of the Historian. Records of the Historian is an important historical work, which records various historical events and figures from ancient times to the Western Han Dynasty. It has important reference value for the study of ancient Chinese history. 3. Knowledge of Records of the Historian: "Records of the Historian" was the most famous historical book in ancient China. The author was Sima Qian. The book recorded various historical events and characters from ancient times to the Western Han Dynasty, including myths and legends, the history of the Xia Dynasty, the Shang Dynasty, the Zhou Dynasty, the Qin Dynasty, the Western Han Dynasty, and so on. "Records of the Historian" was divided into two volumes, with a total of 130 chapters. It was known as the classic work of ancient Chinese history books. This book has an important reference value for the study of ancient Chinese history and is also an important part of Chinese culture.

Many of the contents in the epic work, Records of the Historian, were actually fabricated by Sima Qian?

1 answer

2024-09-17 05:05

" Records of the Historian " was a very important historical work in ancient China and was known as the top of the Chinese history books. However, some people pointed out that many of the contents of this epic work were fabricated by Sima Qian. Sima Qian was a famous historian during the Han Dynasty. His Records of the Historian was considered a classic work of Chinese history. However, some historians believed that Sima Qian's writing of this historical work contained many elements of fiction and exaggeration. One of the most famous was the description of dinosaurs in the Records of the Historian. Although Sima Qian described the existence of dinosaurs in the Records of the Historian, these descriptions were not supported by real fossil evidence. Therefore, many historians believed that Sima Qian had fabricated and exaggerated elements when he wrote the Records of the Historian. In addition, Sima Qian also described many mythical and legendary figures in the Records of the Historian, such as the heroes of Greek mythology. However, these descriptions were not supported by real historical evidence, so there were also disputes. Although the Records of the Historian was a classic work of Chinese history, there were many elements of fiction and exaggeration in its content. We need to look at historical works with an open mind, and at the same time, we need to rationally analyze and evaluate the content of these works.