They were both tragic works about the upper class, but why did they feel that 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was very different from 'The Great Gatsby?'
Dream of the Red Chamber and The Great Gatsby are two completely different novels. They not only have great differences in plot, theme and character creation, but also have different influences in different times and cultural backgrounds. " Dream of the Red Chamber " was a Qing Dynasty story that described the struggles and pursuits of Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, and the others in feudal society, as well as their relationships and emotional entanglements. The novel used the rise and fall of the four families of Jia, Shi, Wang and Xue as the main line to show a grand social and historical background, while also depicting the greed, vanity, betrayal and tragedy of human nature. In contrast, The Great Gatsby was one of the masterpieces of 20th-century American literature by F. Scott. The novel was set in the 1920s in America, which described the setbacks and tragedies that Gatsby faced in the process of pursuing his dreams and love, as well as his deep reflection on society and human nature. Therefore, although Dream of the Red Chamber and The Great Gatsby were both tragic works about high society, there were great differences in plot, theme and character creation. Dream of the Red Chamber depicted the decline of a feudal dynasty and the deep thinking of human nature, while The Great Gatsby explored the hypocrisy, vanity and tragedy of American society and culture through the story of Gatsby. The style and theme of the two novels are different, but they are both excellent literary works worthy of our in-depth reading and thinking.
Why did Dream of the Red Chamber have such a tragic ending?
Dream of the Red Chamber was a classic work in Chinese classical literature. The reason why its ending was so miserable was that the author Cao Xueqin had experienced many twists and turns and pain in the process of writing, as well as the influence of the era and social background. When Cao Xueqin wrote 'Dream of the Red Chamber', it was during the decline of the feudal society of the Qing Dynasty. In this context, social unrest, political corruption, people's living standards decline, traditional culture gradually lost its vitality. Cao Xueqin had experienced a lot of hardships and pain when he was writing 'Dream of the Red Chamber'. He had to sell his property and furniture because of poverty, and finally exhausted all his savings. Therefore,'Dream of the Red Chamber' depicted a poor, depressed, and competitive feudal society, which was one of the reasons for its miserable ending. The ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was also influenced by the era and social background. In the feudal society of the late Qing Dynasty, due to political corruption, social unrest, economic decline and other reasons, the value of people's lives gradually decreased. Family, love, friendship and other interpersonal relationships also became indifferent and hypocritical. In 'Dream of the Red Chamber', many characters experienced pain and suffering, but they all chose to leave this world in the end, which also reflected the mental state of the society at that time. To sum up, the reason why the ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was so miserable was because the author, Cao Xueqin, had experienced a lot of hardships and pain in the process of writing, as well as the influence of the era and social background. Although the ending was heartbreaking, it was also a classic in the history of Chinese literature, which had a profound impact on later literature and art.
Why is the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber so tragic?
'Dream of the Red Chamber' was a classical Chinese novel that told the story of Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, and the others. Although it was an excellent literary work, its ending was not perfect and was called "tragic". The reason why 'Dream of the Red Chamber' had such a tragic ending was mainly because it depicted a complicated social reality, and the author Cao Xueqin could not find a perfect solution in it. In addition, there were many problems in the novel itself, such as insufficient character creation and complicated plots. In the novel, the love line between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu was finally torn apart and Jia Baoyu's health was always poor. In addition, there were many characters in the novel who did not have satisfactory endings, such as Xue Baochai, Wang Xifeng, and others. In summary, the reason why the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was so tragic was mainly because it depicted a complex social reality, and the author Cao Xueqin could not find a perfect solution in it. In addition, there are many problems in the novel itself. These factors eventually lead to the ending of the novel.
Why was the ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' so tragic?
The reason why the ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was so sad was due to the complexity of the story's background and plot, as well as the various difficulties and setbacks that Cao Xueqin had experienced in the process of writing. The story of Dream of the Red Chamber took place in the Qing Dynasty and told the love story of Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu and others. In the story, the relationship between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu was very deep, but in the end, due to various factors, they died separately. This ending was very sad, especially for those who had a deep understanding of relationships. The ending of Dream of the Red Chamber also involved the fate of many people, including Jia Baoyu's family, Xue Baochai and others. Due to the author Cao Xueqin's experience and identity, he could not completely control the plot and development of the entire story, which led to the twists and turns of the fate of many characters, making the whole story even more tragic. The story of Dream of the Red Chamber also involved the creative process of the author, Cao Xueqin. He had experienced many difficulties and setbacks in the creative process, including economic and political pressures, as well as physical and mental health problems. These factors caused him to be unable to complete his work and the final outcome was regrettable. In summary, the reason why the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was so tragic was due to the complexity of the story background and plot, as well as the difficulties and setbacks experienced by the author Cao Xueqin in the process of writing.
The Tragic Meaning of Dream of the Red Chamber
'Dream of the Red Chamber' was a classic of Chinese classical literature and was hailed as the pinnacle of Chinese novels. It depicted an illusionary and complicated life of a feudal dynasty family with Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, Xue Baochai and other characters as the center, reflecting the various shortcomings of feudal society and the deep-seated problems of human nature. The tragic significance of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was mainly manifested in the following aspects: 1. The rise and fall of the family: In the novel, the Jia, Wang, Xue, and Shi families were the top families of the feudal dynasty, but their decline was inevitable. The prosperity and decline of a family were interconnected. The misfortune of any family member was inseparable from the rise and fall of the entire family. 2. Discussion of human nature: Through the description of Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, Xue Baochai and other characters in the novel, it reflects the distortion and defects of human nature in feudal society. Especially the love between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu, it showed the fragility and helplessness of human nature. 3. The fickleness of fate: Every character in the novel has their own fate, but fate is often unpredictable. Some people's fate is tragic. They gain a lot at a certain moment but lose everything at another moment. 4. Social criticism: The novel has a profound criticism of feudal society. The closed and cruel nature of feudal society made it impossible for many people to obtain freedom and equality in their own destiny. "Dream of the Red Chamber" became a classic in the history of Chinese literature with its profound thoughts, exquisite art, and profound discussion of human nature. It shows the various tragedies and helplessness of human beings in history and social reality, providing us with profound thinking and enlightenment.
Why did the Four Great Clans in 'Dream of the Red Chamber' decline?
In "Dream of the Red Chamber", the reasons for the decline of the four great families were many, including but not limited to the following: 1. The corruption and loopholes in the system of feudal society: In feudal society, the interests of the family and the interests of the country were interconnected. However, due to the corruption and loopholes of the feudal society, the family was often unable to effectively protect their own interests, resulting in the decline of the family. 2. Family members 'personal cultivation and moral issues: In "Dream of the Red Chamber", the members of the four major families generally lack personal cultivation and moral issues. Greed, selfishness, narrow-mindedness, cruelty and other shortcomings are prominent, which will also lead to the decline of the family. 3. Changes in the external environment: In Dream of the Red Chamber, the external environment of the four great clans also changed. With the development of social economy and the progress of civilization, the surrounding environment became more and more complicated and turbulent, which brought great pressure and challenges to the four families, leading to the decline of the families. 4. The management of the family itself: In "Dream of the Red Chamber", the four families also had some management problems. For example, unclear division of labor among family members, chaotic management, and lack of effective organization and coordination would also lead to the decline of the family. To sum up, the reasons for the decline of the four great families were multi-dimensional and required a comprehensive analysis from multiple angles.
Why was 'Dream of the Red Chamber' hailed as a great encyclopedia?
The reason why 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was hailed as a great encyclopedia was because it contained a large amount of knowledge about society, culture, history, philosophy, art, literature, and other aspects. Moreover, this knowledge had to be very comprehensive and in-depth. In 'Dream of the Red Chamber', the author Cao Xueqin described the rise and fall of a feudal dynasty and the distortion of human nature through exquisite descriptions and in-depth analysis. He not only described the various customs, systems, and cultures of the Qing Dynasty, but also the politics, economy, military, education, and technology of the time. In addition, he also showed the kindness, distortion and evil of human nature through the description of the characters and the construction of the plot, reflecting the various problems and contradictions of the society at that time. "Dream of the Red Chamber" also involved knowledge about philosophy, religion, literature, art, and other aspects. Cao Xueqin, the author, had a great understanding of both Chinese traditional culture and Western culture. He incorporated many philosophical and literary ideas into his novel, such as "men and women are different","true feelings and false feelings","human nature is good", etc., reflecting the values and aesthetics of the society at that time. At the same time, the various descriptions and characters in "Dream of the Red Chamber" also reflected the development of literature and art at that time and the trend of aesthetics. To sum up,"Dream of the Red Chamber" is a very comprehensive, in-depth, rich in thought and literary value of the novel. It is known as a great encyclopedia because it contains a large number of social, cultural, historical, philosophical, artistic, literary and other aspects of knowledge. Moreover, this knowledge must be very comprehensive and in-depth, which has an important impact on the literature, culture, and thought of the time and later generations.
Why is Dream of the Red Chamber a great literary work?
'Dream of the Red Chamber' was a monumental work in the history of Chinese literature, known as the pinnacle of Chinese classical novels. It depicted the rise and fall of the Jia, Shi, Wang, and Xue families as the main line, depicting the life of an illusory and huge feudal dynasty family. The novel not only has a profound character and emotional description, but also integrated with a wealth of history, philosophy, sociology and other knowledge, showing the author's deep thinking and understanding of Chinese traditional culture and society. Dream of the Red Chamber's narrative techniques were ingenious. Through the dialogue, actions, and psychological descriptions of the characters, it portrayed many characters with distinct personalities. The plot design of the novel is complicated, full of suspense and reversal. It is difficult for the readers to sort out their thoughts, so they can only explore the mysteries through continuous reading. The depth of thought in 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was also an important reason why it stood out. Through the criticism and revelation of the feudal society, the novel emphasized the theme of human nature, family, love and so on, which led to the development of Chinese literature. To sum up, as a great literary work, Dream of the Red Chamber not only had outstanding performance in narrative skills and depth of thought, but also became an indelible cultural treasure because of its contribution to the history of Chinese literature and its far-reaching influence.
What did 'Dream of the Red Chamber' in 'Dream of the Red Chamber'?
Dream of the Red Chamber was a classical Chinese novel, also known as The Story of the Stone. It was about the life and love story of Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu and others in the feudal society of the Qing Dynasty. The term "Red Mansion" referred to the Rong Mansion where Jia Baoyu lived, which was also the main plot of the story. This mansion was located in the western suburbs of Beijing. It had a beautiful environment and exquisite architecture. It was one of the residences of the Qing Dynasty nobles. The story of the Red Chamber, with the Rong Mansion as the background, showed the style of the Qing Dynasty nobles 'life, but also reflected the problems of social politics, interpersonal relationships, moral values and so on. This novel was hailed as the pinnacle of Chinese classical novels and a classic in the history of Chinese literature.
What was the ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber'? Why was it different from the one on television?
The ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' varied according to the different versions and different adapted versions. Here are some possible endings: 1 Cao Xueqin's death: In some versions of the Dream of the Red Chamber, Cao Xueqin wrote the novel before his death but did not complete it. Later on, Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, and the others had a different ending. 2. Jia Baoyu Becomes a Monk: In other versions of Dream of the Red Chamber, Jia Baoyu eventually chose to become a monk. 3. Jia Baoyu's Death: In the original work of Dream of the Red Chamber, Jia Baoyu died of illness. However, in some adapted TV dramas or movies, Jia Baoyu was chosen to live and continue to be with Lin Daiyu and others. The difference between the book and the television might be because the book was created by Cao Xueqin himself while the television was adapted by a screenwriter or director. Television might focus more on the plot and character development, while books focus more on the exploration of the novel's theme and structure. In addition, the audiences of television and books may also be different, so they may have different opinions on the ending of the novel.
Analysis of the Tragic Connotation of Dream of the Red Chamber
'Dream of the Red Chamber' was a classic work of Chinese classical novels and was hailed as a monumental work in the history of Chinese novels. This novel takes the story of Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, Xue Baochai and other main characters as the main line. Through the description of the rise and fall of the four families of Jia, Wang, Xue and Shi in the feudal society and the fate of the family, it shows the decline and collapse of a huge feudal dynasty family. At the same time, it also reflects the complexity of human nature and the various problems of social reality, which has a profound tragic meaning. The tragedy of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was mainly manifested in the following aspects: 1. The disillusionment of the family's prosperity: The decline of the Jia family in Dream of the Red Chamber was a gradual process. From the prosperity at the beginning to the final collapse, the fate of the entire family made people sigh. This sense of disillusionment made the readers wonder why a seemingly perfect family would eventually fall. 2. Distortion of human nature: "Dream of the Red Chamber" depicted the complex relationships and emotional entanglements between many characters. These people were restricted and bound by various restrictions in the feudal society. Their thoughts, behaviors, and values were greatly distorted, resulting in many tragedies. 3. The tragedy of love: The tragedy of love in Dream of the Red Chamber is also a highlight of the novel. The emotional entanglement between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu, as well as the family entanglement between them, makes the readers wonder what love is in feudal society. 4. Problems of social reality: Dream of the Red Chamber not only depicted the problems of feudal society, but also included the complexity of human nature and various problems of social reality, such as class contradictions, the gap between the rich and the poor, moral concepts, etc. These problems were deeply reflected and discussed in the novel. To sum up, the tragedy of Dream of the Red Chamber was mainly reflected in the disillusionment of the family's prosperity, the distortion of human nature, the tragedy of love and the problems of social reality. Through its unique narrative style and profound tragic content, this novel makes readers think deeply about the nature of feudal society and human nature. It has high literary value and historical significance.