The movie Celestial Bane was based on Xiao Ding's novel Celestial Bane. It was a fantasy martial arts movie directed by Hong Kong director Lin Chaoxian and starred by Andy Liu, Zhao Liying, Zhou Yong, and others. The film narrated the love story between Xiao Yan and Lu Xueqi as well as the dispute between the Xiao clan and the Immortal World. The visual effects and special effects of the movie were good, especially the battle scenes and Xianxia style special effects. In addition, the storyline and character creation of the movie were also outstanding. In particular, the relationship between Xiao Yan and Lu Xueqi was deeply loved by the audience. However, there were some problems with the plot, such as improper adaptation of some plots and unclear relationship between characters. These problems might affect the audience's experience. In general, Jade Dynasty was good in terms of visual effects and special effects. The story and character creation were also relatively complete, but there might be some shortcomings.