Why is it said that a useless scholar? Where did this sentence come from?

2024-09-11 21:23

1 answer

2024-09-11 23:53

This sentence originated from Lin Chong's complaint in the ancient Chinese novel Water Margins: "Since ancient times, scholars are useless and only know how to talk on paper." However, not all scholars were suitable because scholars referred to people with knowledge, and the meaning of this sentence was that those who only knew how to read and lacked practical skills and experience could not play a role in practical application. The meaning of this sentence in the novel gradually evolved into a belittling and criticism of scholars, and later it was gradually quoted and spread by other literary works. Although the original origin of this sentence was uncertain, its image and influence in the novel had already become a common impression of scholars.

Where did the saying "a useless scholar" come from? What did he mean?

1 answer

2024-09-08 17:11

"A scholar is useless." This sentence came from the Qing Dynasty writer Nalan Xingde's "Mulan Flower Slow." The whole sentence is: "If life is only like the first sight, what is the autumn wind sad painting fan?" When I become an old friend, my heart says that the weather is cold and autumn is good. The words of Mount Li are gone. In the middle of the night, tears fall and bells ring. I don't complain. How can it be as I wish for the brocade-clothed man to be married?" If life can only be as beautiful as the first time we met, then why do you want the autumn wind to be sad, why do you want the fan to dance in the moon? Life is short. If everyone becomes as hypocritical as the people they love, why can't everyone have a happy ending? This sentence was used to describe a person's knowledge that could not bring practical help to him or to describe a person's life that was too idealistic and lacked practical action.

Everyone said that a useless scholar was right?

1 answer

2024-09-15 20:27

This sentence was not correct. Scholars were those who had studied in school for many years and had mastered a wealth of knowledge. Although scholars were usually considered to have rich cultural knowledge and thinking ability, they were not necessarily useless. In modern society, scholars could engage in various occupations such as writing, education, scientific research, etc. to contribute to society. Therefore, he couldn't simply regard the scholar as a useless person.

Everyone said that a useless scholar was right?

1 answer

2024-09-13 08:18

This sentence was not correct. Although scholars usually referred to people who were talented in literature or academia, it did not mean that they had no practical value. Scholars might discuss profound philosophical issues and historical events, but they did not necessarily lack practical ability. In fact, many scholars had high status and influence in politics and business. Therefore, the saying," A useless scholar " was not correct.

Where did this sentence come from?

1 answer

2024-09-10 10:37

This sentence came from 'Dream of the Red Chamber' written by Cao Xueqin, a novelist during the Qianlong period of the Qing Dynasty. In the novel, Cao Xueqin used this sentence to describe the relationship between the novel and the official history, indicating that the novel could be used as a supplement and extension of history but could not replace the official history.

Why did the ancient Chinese say,"A scholar is useless"?

1 answer

2024-09-15 20:40

This sentence originated from an ancient Chinese story. In the story, a scholar was rejected by the employer because he only knew how to read and lacked practical skills and practical experience. In the end, he could not find a job. The story reflected the criticism of scholars in ancient China, who believed that they only focused on theoretical knowledge and lacked practical skills, unable to play a role in their work. Therefore, the phrase " a useless scholar " became a way of belittling scholars. However, it should be noted that the meaning of this sentence did not mean that scholars were useless, but that they lacked practical application ability. In ancient society, scholars were a group of highly educated professionals. Their duty was to study classical literature and Confucian ideas and use them to guide people's lives and behavior. Although the theoretical knowledge of scholars is very important, they need to apply this knowledge to practical life in order to better serve the society. Therefore, the meaning of this sentence was to criticize those who only paid attention to theoretical research and lacked practical experience instead of belittling all scholars.

" Can a scholar's business be considered stealing?" Which story did this sentence come from?

1 answer

2024-09-12 13:45

This sentence came from the Peony Pavilion in Strange Tales from a Chinese Studio. The story tells the love story between the scholar Cui Zhiyuan and the beautiful woman Mei Xian. There is a sentence in it,"Can a scholar's business be considered stealing?" It expressed Cui Zhiyuan's pursuit of Meixian's true love and his persistence in traditional moral values. This sentence had also become one of the classics in Chinese literature.

"Can a scholar's business be considered stealing?" Which story did this sentence come from?

1 answer

2024-09-12 13:23

This sentence came from a storyline in Water Margins: Lu Zhishen was drinking in a hotel and heard a woman crying in the hotel, so he went to comfort her. The shopkeeper suspected that Lu Zhishen had stolen his woman and reported it to the government. Lu Zhishen explained to the shopkeeper that he was not a thief, but the shopkeeper still did not believe him. In the end, Lu Zhishen made a bet with the shopkeeper that if the shopkeeper could give the woman to him, he would not pursue the shopkeeper's theft. If the shop owner could give the woman to him, the shop owner would admit that he had stolen and Lu Zhishen would not pursue the matter. In the end, the shop owner was able to give the woman to Lu Zhishen. Lu Zhishen also proved that he was not a thief. The shop owner also admitted his theft and the two parties reconciled.

Where did this sentence come from? What is the full text?

1 answer

2024-09-26 04:17

You didn't provide the exact sentence you wanted to answer. Please provide more specific questions or information, and I will try my best to answer them.

What an amazing masterpiece! Where did this sentence come from?

1 answer

2024-09-15 02:12

This sentence was said by the protagonist Xiao Yan in the novel 'Battle Through the Skies' when he was sighing about the strength and greatness of mankind.

Marriage is the grave of love. Who said it? Where did it come from?

1 answer

2024-09-08 16:29

This sentence came from a famous line in the "Base" series of novels by the American author, Asimoff.