Please recommend a western fantasy novel that I have read before but have forgotten the title?

The titles of the characters in Western fantasy novels depended on the genre, background, and storyline of the novel. The following are some common examples of Western fantasy characters 'titles: - Magician: Humans who use magic often have a unique title such as "Grand Magician","Forbidden Magician","Black Magician","White Magician", etc. - Elves: Some elves, half-elves, dwarves, and other races of humans often have a unique title such as "archer","warrior","hunter","merchant", etc. - Giants: Some giants, skeletons, goblins, and other races of humans often have a unique title such as "Warrior","Mage","Hunter","Thief", etc. - Vampires: Some vampires, werewolves, and other creatures of the night often have a unique title such as "vampire","werewolf","night demon king","paladin", etc. These were just some of the titles in Western fantasy novels. In fact, there were many other titles and titles that depended on the plot and character settings of the novel.

The book " The Second Immortal Lord " is a fantasy romance novel written by the author, Wu Yi Dongfeng. The general plot of this novel is as follows: In this chaotic and dark era," I " woke up from a dream. The Ghost Realm, the Fey Kingdom, and the human race were the three pillars of power. With the mysterious forces interfering, who could rule the world? Who could touch the truth? This was the legend of the " dead ", and also the story of " behind "… ---------------------------- " Spirit World " was a fantasy romance novel written by the author, Jimo Wushuang. The general plot of this novel was: This text is 11, do not enter the thunder ` After ten years of separation, they were full of joy and anticipation when they reunited, but all they got was a question," Who are you?" So what if he had forgotten everything in the past? Some things would still be remembered even if he had forgotten everything. Moreover, as time passed, he would slowly recall them… ` [World background: A new book in the magical world with an oriental classical charm and extremely advanced technology," Fairy's Chosen Girl." Book number 1341484. PK in September. Please support.] ---------------------------- I Can Become a God was a fantasy immortal cultivation novel written by an author who knew how to write. The general plot of this novel was: This was a fantasy novel about cultivation. It was also a novel about the invincible protagonist who had lost his memory and ran amok in the world of cultivation. ---------------------------- " Enter My Demon Path " was a fantasy immortal cultivation novel written by the author, Xiling Bushuishou. The general plot of this novel was: There were many storms in the human world, and the road had experienced many hardships. Who could truly be free and unfettered in this world, and whether cultivation could really lead to immortality? Until today, no one had seen a true immortal, only countless legends were left behind. We are all ordinary people, constantly working hard to survive. In the end, we have long forgotten what our original heart is. This is the legend of each of us... ---------------------------- " The Story of the Desolation " was a Xianxia, mythical, and cultivation novel written by a pen name that the author had missed. The general plot of this novel was: Chaos was just created, the world was just formed, all things were enlightened, and hundreds of races stood in the forest, each occupying a region. Later, it was rumored that the gods and devils of Kunlun established their capital and were called gods. They could live forever and reach the heavens. They could enslave hundreds of races and establish the capital of immortals to become the ruler of heaven and earth. This period of time was called the Pre-Desolate Era. ---------------------------- The Mystic World God was a fantasy novel written by the author, Deep Learning. The general plot of this novel was: The bloodline of the Mystic World had fallen into the human world. Fiendgods were spying, and alien races were lurking. This was the story of a young man who was determined to become a peerless expert. ---------------------------- " Traditional Fantasy " was a fantasy sword and magic novel written by the author, Martial Arts Is Killing Skill. The general plot of this novel was: This was a traditional fantasy. Therefore, in the process of looking, there might be a sense of familiarity in some places. ---------------------------- " The Past of the Gods " was a Xianxia-Mythological Cultivation novel written by the author, Wang Feihong. The general plot of this novel was: All the news was plagiarizing history, and everything that happened was in the past. Have you been to the mysterious northeast? Have you heard of the mystical legends of the northeast? Between the white mountains and black water, the legend continued. ---------------------------- " The Wind and Cloud of the Mystic Way " was a fantasy and oriental fantasy novel written by a Chinese kid. The general plot of this novel was: Death Transmigration, Reincarnation An extraordinary Black Tortoise World Unique Xuan Dao Cultivation System Martial Arts Divine Power is not a dream of countless Mystic Arts and innate martial arts. Innate Ability, Divine Ability Inheritance The lotus blooms and the sea of consciousness opens the sky. Comprehending Xuanhuang, Dominating the Wilderness ^^^^^^Ask to collect, ask to recommend. ---------------------------- " A Record of a Mortal's Journey to Immortality-Immortal World Arc " was a Xianxia-Mythological Cultivation novel written by the author, Wang Yu. The general plot of the novel was: When mortals cultivated, the wind and clouds would rise again, and they would travel through time and space. Reincarnation would reverse, and the Golden Immortal would become a Grand Unity. The 3,000 Great Daos of the Great All-Embracing Dao Ancestors, the Immortal World Chapter of the Supreme Law's Mortal Cultivation Biography, a story of Han Li's reign over the Immortal World, and an undying legend of a mortal's cultivation. For those who have not read the prequel, it will not affect the reading experience of this book. However, those who are interested can also read the Legend of Mortal Cultivation first before reading this book. Fellow Daoists, Wang Yu's new book," Immortal," has been uploaded on Qidian Chinese Network. Please continue to support me!

😋I recommend two Western fantasy novels to you: The Magic Apprentice's User's Manual and The Half-Dragon Maiden. "The Magician's Apprentice User's Manual" was a fantasy romance novel. It was full of fantasy and told the story of how an apprentice used magic to change his own fate. "Half-Dragon Girl" was a fantasy romance novel. The main character was a half-dragon girl. Her life was full of twists and turns, but through her own struggles, she continued to grow into a powerful woman. The two books had their own unique plots and were both good books worth reading. I hope you like this fairy's recommendation. Muah ~😗

To name a Western fantasy novel, you can refer to the following example: The Lord of the Rings is a classic western fantasy novel written by Tolkien. It tells the story of a group of warriors searching for and destroying the Lord of the Rings. 2. Harry Potter: The series of novels tells the story of a wizard, Harry Potter, growing up at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry and his battle with the evil Dark Wizard, Voldemort. 3. Dark Elves: This is a novel with dark elves as the main characters, describing their adventures in the Viking era. 4 " The Dance of the Magic Dragon ": This is a novel with a dragon as the protagonist. It tells the story of a group of adventurers fighting and adventures with dragons. Doctor Who: The protagonist of the series is a scientist with the ability to travel through time. He leads a group of volunteers to explore the universe and solve various scientific problems.

I recommend "Rebirth: Journey to the West" by the author, Mo Wen Chuxin. This was a superb Xianxia cultivation novel. The main character was originally a nobody, facing the gods, buddhas, demons, and devils in the world of gods and devils, not knowing where to go. This was a masterpiece of the Journey to the West written by a new author, not a prehistoric novel. Although the updates were slow, the story was extremely exciting. The protagonist's personality changed naturally. He valued friendship and had flesh and blood. The description in the early stages was poor, but the rhythm in the later stages was superb. The story began with the main character's arrival, and then he occupied the mountain and became king. The plot became more and more exciting. The author's writing style was not bad. He had a good setting for the power struggle between the four sides and even wrote about the protagonist's growing process. There were touching plots, hot blood, brotherhood, and love in the book. Many of the chapters were extremely touching, such as the one about causing a ruckus in Heaven. Although it was not a stallion novel, there might be more female leads, but it was not an exaggeration. Those who like Journey to the West novels shouldn't miss it. <a href="/?from=ask_words" style="color:red" target="_blank">Read more exciting novels for free</a>

"Memory Corridor" is a light novel written by Night Walker Z. It's a fantasy novel. The general plot of this novel is as follows: Memories were a person's past, a person's memories, a person's treasure. At the same time, they could also change a person. Painful memories made people struggle, happy memories made people jump for joy, and painful memories made people work hard. In the long river of memories, there were always endless stories. Have you ever thought about what you would look like after losing all your memories? You don't remember the happiness, sadness, and past; You also don't remember your friends, relatives, and lovers; You don't even remember your name, occupation, or what you've experienced. Searching for oneself and retrieving lost memories was the theme of the Memory Corridor. However, the process of searching was a little difficult, painful, and often accompanied by danger. People desperately wanted to reach the end of the corridor, but what would be waiting for them at the end of the corridor? ---------------------------- " Where are the Scattered Lands?" This book was a modern romance novel written by the author, Rainfall's Millet. The general plot of this novel was: Everyone more or less had similar experiences. There were regrets, and there were also disappointments. There were also times when they wanted to look back but found that they could no longer find the past. The past buried deep in their hearts pushed us forward all the way to maturity, learning to forget, and knowing how to hide. ---------------------------- " The Rise of the Literature World " was a novel about urban life written by the author, a romantic scholar. The general plot of this novel was: This book is a classic story of recollection! Let the protagonist bring you back to the most classic moments of our time! " The novels, movies, and songs that once made your soul throb can be found in this book! ---------------------------- " Sorry, I Forgot You " was a modern romance novel written by the author, Autumn Fog. The general plot of this novel was: The furthest distance in the world is not when I stand in front of you, but when you stand in front of me, I can clearly see me in your eyes, but you have already forgotten me. ---------------------------- " The Return of Youth " was a modern romance novel written by the author, Bai Shi Bei Li. The general plot of this novel was: Everything started from the first time they met eight years ago. Those were the beautiful memories of her childhood. How happy she was, how little parting she had. That was the three months he wanted to stay for the most, but after going through thousands of sails, he was no longer the youth he was back then. When the two of them met again, one of them did not know each other and the other was unwilling. If life is just like the first time, but why meet each other before? ---------------------------- Cheng Jian was a short story written by the author, Gu Ruoxi. The general plot of this novel was: Ten years later, she finally saw that person again, but that person didn't recognize her. ---------------------------- " A Survival Guide for Supporting Characters " was a light novel written by the author's name, Yao Yaoling. It was a fantasy novel. The general plot of this novel was: Dark history, don't look at dark history. ---------------------------- Life Severing Stage Expert was a fantasy novel written by Feng Yusheng. The general plot of the novel was: Time passed by in a hurry, and she forgot when it started. A blank space occupied her memory, as if she had woken up for a long time and was guarding something hazy. ---------------------------- The book," Perhaps My Heart Never Changed " was a short story written by the author, Ibieerkuan. The general plot of the novel was: I love him like crazy, but unfortunately, he has never stopped loving me. Later on, I stopped loving him. Only then did I know that he cared about it and kept it in his heart, always… ---------------------------- The book " Dying the Fleeting Years " was an ancient romance novel written by an old friend of the author. The general plot of this novel was: When I was young, I liked the beginning of stories. A long, long time ago, there was a person in a certain place. How was he…Everything was beautiful at the beginning. The story had yet to break out of its shell. There was no time for it to develop, and we had no time to grieve. When they first met, he whispered in her ear," My name is Wei Zhuang. Remember this name. We'll meet again in the future." After two years of affection, she said," I won't leave you." However, they parted in a hurry. After three years of reunion, she finally got rid of the life he had promised her. But now I know that the flowering period has been delayed. Is it too late for us? The human heart often couldn't withstand the heat of the world, and everything had variables. He could guess the beginning of the story, but he couldn't predict the ending. We can't hide from the hand that makes clouds and rain behind the world.

"Memory Corridor" is a light novel written by Night Walker Z. It's a fantasy novel. The general plot of this novel is as follows: Memories were a person's past, a person's memories, a person's treasure. At the same time, they could also change a person. Painful memories made people struggle, happy memories made people jump for joy, and painful memories made people work hard. In the long river of memories, there were always endless stories. Have you ever thought about what you would look like after losing all your memories? You don't remember the happiness, sadness, and past; You also don't remember your friends, relatives, and lovers; You don't even remember your name, occupation, or what you've experienced. Searching for oneself and retrieving lost memories was the theme of the Memory Corridor. However, the process of searching was a little difficult, painful, and often accompanied by danger. People desperately wanted to reach the end of the corridor, but what would be waiting for them at the end of the corridor? ---------------------------- " Sorry, I Forgot You " was a modern romance novel written by the author, Autumn Fog. The general plot of this novel was: The furthest distance in the world is not when I stand in front of you, but when you stand in front of me, I can clearly see me in your eyes, but you have already forgotten me. ---------------------------- " Memories " was a suspense-mystery detective novel written by the author, Yasuzawa. The general plot of the novel was: Is this world really as you remember it to be? Did the past that existed in his mind really exist? Or could it be that your memory was a clay puppet that someone else made when they were bored? A person who should have existed suddenly disappeared, and the traces of existence were erased. Who touched whose memory? ---------------------------- " Where are the Scattered Lands?" This book was a modern romance novel written by the author, Rainfall's Millet. The general plot of this novel was: Everyone more or less had similar experiences. There were regrets, and there were also disappointments. There were also times when they wanted to look back but found that they could no longer find the past. The past buried deep in their hearts pushed us forward all the way to maturity, learning to forget, and knowing how to hide. ---------------------------- When I Forgot You was a modern romance novel written by the author, Xun Bie Bie. The general plot of the novel was: The love between men and women in the world was caused by entanglement and could not be let go because of regret. Without entanglement, where would there be so much craziness? Without regret, where would there be so much concern? ---------------------------- " The Hunter's Lost Memories " was a light novel by the author, March Black Today. It was a derivative doujinshi novel. The general plot of the novel was as follows: This article is also known as " I just want to go home after being traumatized ". I traveled to the Hunter World more than 20 years ago in the main storyline to find the way home. It wasn't the trait system, it wasn't the trait system, it wasn't the trait system. Important things had to be repeated three times. ---------------------------- " A Survival Guide for Supporting Characters " was a light novel written by the author's name, Yao Yaoling. It was a fantasy novel. The general plot of this novel was: Dark history, don't look at dark history. ---------------------------- " Rebirth Entertainment: 1990 " was a novel written by the author, Jun Xucai, about an urban and entertainment star. The general plot of the novel was: Hello, is this the Space Administration? I've been reborn, but other than the improper way of enlightenment, I don't remember what happened in the future! Did you make a mistake? Can I do it again? Waiting online! It was quite urgent! ---------------------------- " The Rise of the Literature World " was a novel about urban life written by the author, a romantic scholar. The general plot of this novel was: This book is a classic story of recollection! Let the protagonist bring you back to the most classic moments of our time! " The novels, movies, and songs that once made your soul throb can be found in this book! ---------------------------- Oblivion Descends was a novel written by the author, Melody Under the Moon. The general plot of the novel was: In this ever-changing and unstable world, one second it was the era of cold weapons, the next second it could become StarCraft, one second it was planes, cannons, rocket launchers, the next second it could become fireballs, lightning, Holy Light. Along with this unexplainable phenomenon, people would naturally be brought into a new role in life and forget everything that happened a second ago. Forgetting meant not remembering. Who are you? Who am I? What was wrong with this world? How to unravel the truth of the world? Could it restore stability? Could he not forget?

" It might not meet your needs, but I'll try my best to recommend a novel that's most relevant to your description."" A Mixed World " is a fantasy romance novel written by the author, Red Cliff Soy Milk. The general plot of this novel is as follows: A foreign world full of unknowns, a city as strong as steel, splendid and wonderful magic, magical nature, and…I live in such a strange world, experiencing an interesting and thrilling life. What kind of love would there be, and what kind of ending would there be. Seeking collection, seeking recommendation... ---------------------------- Alice's Magical World was a fantasy romance novel written by the author. The general plot of the novel was: This was a secret legendary journey. City College, the legend of spirits, plane travel, magic exploration, all of them were there. ---------------------------- " Spirit World " was a fantasy romance novel written by the author, Jimo Wushuang. The general plot of this novel was: This text is 11, do not enter the thunder ` After ten years of separation, they were full of joy and anticipation when they reunited, but all they got was a question," Who are you?" So what if he had forgotten everything in the past? Some things would still be remembered even if he had forgotten everything. Moreover, as time passed, he would slowly recall them… ` [World background: A new book in the magical world with an oriental classical charm and extremely advanced technology," Fairy's Chosen Girl." Book number 1341484. PK in September. Please support.] ---------------------------- " Demon Temptation " was a fantasy romance novel written by the author, Guo Xiling. The general plot of this novel was: Eastern Fantasy. r The story of a twisted otaku traveling in another world. r RPG adventure + romance story. r Regarding the God Descendants and the Heaven, Earth, Human and Demon Realms… Destroying the world and saving the world…maybe there is? r Anyway…I'm trying to tell a complete story. It was a serious storyline, and it was generally a light-hearted story, with occasional spoof…That was it. r ===================\r Take it slow! Be careful! r Please recommend me, please collect me, please review me, please reward me…I'll ask for whatever I can. It's up to you whether I give it or not…I won't snatch it by force… ---------------------------- The book " Demon's Canon " was a fantasy-mystery fantasy novel written by the author, Gruncher. The general plot of this novel was: This was an epic fantasy novel. The world was grand, and there were many characters with complicated relationships. The main characters, supporting characters, villains, and passers-by had distinct images and different personalities. It was a pure plot with multiple main characters and group characters. It covered Norse mythology, Greek mythology, angels, demons, demon hunters, schemers, nobles, religions, royal families, heroes, spies, fantasy species, swordsmanship, magic, technology, history, and many other factors. Time: The historical background of the story took place after the Renaissance and before the Industrial Revolution. The social contradictions intensified, the class struggle was serious, and the racial conflicts intensified. The book was divided into three worlds: the God Realm where angels lived, the Demon Realm where demons lived, and the Mortal Realm where humans lived. Among them, the Mortal Realm where humans lived was the main continent, the Heaven of the God Realm, and the Hell of the Demon Realm. The main plot was a light plot and a dark plot. The light plot was the struggle and competition between the various factions of Middle-Earth for their own interests, while the dark plot was the process and outcome of the protagonist saving the end of the world. There were many side plots, waiting for the readers to discover the story themselves. The pace of the story was extremely fast, and there was no sloppiness. There were no cheat codes, and it was not a systematic text. It was completely different from the current routine text. The writing method was unique, and it formed its own style. ---------------------------- Myths of the Lost World was a fantasy and modern magic novel written by the author, October Night. The general plot of the novel was: [Pursue the blood of the Great Old Ones, revere the blood of the Great Old Ones.] Find yourself in the chaotic and dangerous unfamiliar world, recreate the truth of the past and the future in the fog of history, and touch the other side of the starry sky under the gaze of the ancient mystery. The salvation of the future and the fate of all things were waiting for the long road of the stranger. * Easy to understand introduction: This was a story of a transmigrator's adventure, life, and survival in a fantasy world that was close to the future. [Science Fantasy in the Virtual World, with Cthulhu and Cyber Elements.] ---------------------------- The Legend of the Phantom was a sci-fi novel written by author Zaion. The general plot of the novel was: Do you think this is a martial arts novel? No, it was science fiction! Do you think this is a fantasy novel? No, it was science fiction! Do you think this is science fiction? Yes, it was science fiction! This book was divided into five volumes: " Birth "," Entering the World "," Spirit General "," The World ", and " Spirit General The World "! It was probably a series of stories that revolved around " Phantom "! He would slowly tell everyone about the future world that the author had imagined in his mind-why was there only one supercontinent and the rest were oceans? Why would there be gods, devils, and all kinds of demons? Why did humans, animals, and plants all evolve and mutate? Who was the main character of " The Legend of the Phantom "? Him? Her? It? Or was it a TA? ---------------------------- " Trading with Ghosts in the Other World " was a fantasy novel written by the author, Xi Nandong. The general plot of this novel was: Fang Ze, the master of fortune telling on Earth, had his soul transmigrated to another world. An ancient book opened in his mind, and he saw a ghost! "That ghost, yes, that's right, it's you. You're already dead. What last wish do you have? Hurry up and tell me!" "Fairy Linglong, why are you looking at me so flirtatiously? I'm not a ghost. If you have any last wishes, hurry up and tell me!" " Ancient Dragon Demon Soul, you want to tell me the location of the treasure, and you want your son to be my mount?" Taking money from ghosts, helping ghosts, doing what one could, and not deceiving the old and the young! An ancient family book from the ancient times brought Fang Ze to the other world. From then on, Fang Ze walked the path of Yin and Yang in the other world and helped the dead rest in peace. ---------------------------- The Mysterious World: Battle of the Sequences was a fantasy-mystery fantasy novel written by the author, Floating Fear. The general plot of the novel was: In the age of steam and machinery, who was the one who sang the epic in the dark blood and tears? And who was it that spoke of secrets in the dusty ancient books? Humans, Elves, Beastmen, Undead, Dwarves, Dragons, Blood Race, Giants, Demons, Sirens... The bones of history gradually surfaced in the fog. The magnificent Western Continent was once again in turmoil. Extraordinaires, Sealed Artifacts, the pathway of god, mystical fruits…Mysteries had never disappeared, and the battle for the Sequences had never stopped. This was a legend of a " foreigner." ---------------------------- The Mystic World God was a fantasy novel written by the author, Deep Learning. The general plot of this novel was: The bloodline of the Mystic World had fallen into the human world. Fiendgods were spying, and alien races were lurking. This was the story of a young man who was determined to become a peerless expert.

Let me recommend a few romance novels to you: " Meng Po's Daily Sweeping,"" I Want to Hold Your Hand Until the End of Time,"" President, I Admonish You to Be Kind." I hope these novels can satisfy your reading needs. If you need any other recommendations, please feel free to let me know. I hope you like my recommendation, Mwah!

"Memory Corridor" is a light novel written by Night Walker Z. It's a fantasy novel. The general plot of this novel is as follows: Memories were a person's past, a person's memories, a person's treasure. At the same time, they could also change a person. Painful memories made people struggle, happy memories made people jump for joy, and painful memories made people work hard. In the long river of memories, there were always endless stories. Have you ever thought about what you would look like after losing all your memories? You don't remember the happiness, sadness, and past; You also don't remember your friends, relatives, and lovers; You don't even remember your name, occupation, or what you've experienced. Searching for oneself and retrieving lost memories was the theme of the Memory Corridor. However, the process of searching was a little difficult, painful, and often accompanied by danger. People desperately wanted to reach the end of the corridor, but what would be waiting for them at the end of the corridor? ---------------------------- " Sorry, I Forgot You " was a modern romance novel written by the author, Autumn Fog. The general plot of this novel was: The furthest distance in the world is not when I stand in front of you, but when you stand in front of me, I can clearly see me in your eyes, but you have already forgotten me. ---------------------------- The book," Perhaps My Heart Never Changed " was a short story written by the author, Ibieerkuan. The general plot of the novel was: I love him like crazy, but unfortunately, he has never stopped loving me. Later on, I stopped loving him. Only then did I know that he cared about it and kept it in his heart, always… ---------------------------- " Where are the Scattered Lands?" This book was a modern romance novel written by the author, Yu Luohe. The general plot of this novel was: Everyone more or less had similar experiences. There were regrets, and there were also disappointments. There were also times when they wanted to look back but found that they could no longer find the past. The past buried deep in their hearts pushed us forward all the way to maturity, learning to forget, and knowing how to hide. ---------------------------- " The Rise of the Literature World " was a novel about urban life written by the author, a romantic scholar. The general plot of this novel was: This book is a classic story of recollection! Let the protagonist bring you back to the most classic moments of our time! " The novels, movies, and songs that once made your soul throb can be found in this book! ---------------------------- For Whom the Sky Is Cold was a short story written by the author, For Whom the Sky Is Cold. The general plot of this novel was: Along the way, we seemed to have hurt many people. Those years that passed by us finally became a rare thought for the rest of our lives. After a few years, we realized that the things we thought we had lost never left. What we really wanted to keep was just our past selves. ---------------------------- If You Had Never Been Here was a short story written by the author. The general plot of the novel was: Every encounter in this world has its meaning, and it is precisely because of this that our lives are formed. Love yourself, love everything about yourself. You might be the light of another person, his motivation, and the meaning of his life. ---------------------------- " The Return of Youth " was a modern romance novel written by the author, Bai Shi Bei Li. The general plot of this novel was: Everything started from the first time they met eight years ago. Those were the beautiful memories of her childhood. How happy she was, how little parting she had. That was the three months he wanted to stay for the most, but after going through thousands of sails, he was no longer the youth he was back then. When the two of them met again, one of them did not know each other and the other was unwilling. If life is just like the first time, but why meet each other before? ---------------------------- " I Was Once a Small Star " was a novel written by the author, Mu Lixi, about an urban and entertainment star. The general plot of the novel was: Jin Wenyi before transmigration: I'm a superstar! Best Actor! Heavenly King! The man who was called God! After transmigrating, Jin Wenyi thought, I used to be a small star, but what about the future? Guess! ---------------------------- " Time Walks Before Her " was a modern romance novel written by the author, Tan Lisheng. The general plot of the novel was: The older you grew, the more you understood that time would remember some people, but it would also abandon some people. Therefore, in your life, you must always find something to look up to. This way, even if time abandoned you, the night sky would still not be dark and dull…