webnovel

If writing a novel is similar to others, can it violate the reputation of others?

2025-03-04 18:20
I'm a law graduate student, and I'm interested in novel torts. In 2005, the Wuchang District Court found Tu Huaizhang guilty. Both the private prosecutor and the defendant appealed, and the Southern Weekend and other media outlets published it, causing heated discussions. The results of the second trial have yet to be seen. Who knows? Please inform me that you have received it. What do you think about whether writing novels can violate the reputation of others? Please express your opinions. Case: In August 2003, the 390,000-word novel "Human Disaster" was published by Tu Huaizhang, the vice chairman of the Writers 'Association of Wuhan City City and a professor of the Chinese Department of Hubei University. The book described a "extreme left" incident that persecuted the intellectual during the period of bringing order out of chaos: the head of the Liangjiang Normal University, Zeng Wen, used the investigation of the "letter to Jiang Qing" incident to make the young lecturer Yu Weishan suffer political oppression and mental torture. In the end, Yu Weishan was finally able to escape from the bad luck. On October 10, 2004, 13 people filed a criminal supplementary civil lawsuit against Tu Huaizhang on the grounds that Tu Huaizhang had committed the crime of "insult, defamation and causing mental damage." The vast majority of these plaintiffs were faculty members of Hubei University and their spouse. They believed that the place where the story took place in "Human Disaster" was the original "Two Rivers Normal University"(the predecessor of Hubei University), and some of the "villains" in "Human Disaster" were insinuating themselves. On December 30, 2004, the Wuchang District Court dismissed the lawsuit due to insufficient evidence. On April 13, 2005, the Intermediate People's Court of Wuhan City decided to send him back for a new trial. On December 6, 2005, the Wuchang District Court found Tu Huaizhang guilty of defamation and sentenced him to six months of detention. At the same time, the private prosecutor's civil compensation lawsuit was rejected. Before the appeal period expired, both the private prosecutor and the defendant refused to accept the judgment of the first instance and filed an appeal. The "novel copyright" here actually refers to the author's violation of the reputation rights of others through the novel, and does not involve the issue of copyright violation. Do you think writing and publishing non-documentary novels (excluding biographies, historical novels, and other documentary novels) can violate the reputation of others? If not, what was the reason? If he could, what were the conditions?
2025-03-04 22:14

Writing a novel that was similar to others did not necessarily violate the reputation of others. It depended on the degree of similarity and the way of creation. If the similarity was high and the creative method was similar to others, it might violate the reputation of others. In this case, it is recommended to consult the copyright department and respect the rights of the copyright owner.

Latest Questions

Which chapter gives the clearest reveal tied to Great Xia instead of another vague hint?

Chapter 273, "Top 100 Revealed, Entering the Hall, Team Numbers as Team Names", is the clearest early answer because the hidden truth stops feeling like mere subtext. The chapter turns that into something concrete by moving from Over a hundred people in the hall saluted him simultaneously, and Xia... to Great Xia is about to establish a formal military force..

1 answer
2026-06-11 08:14

What chapter makes Yang Gan feel plot-relevant instead of background detail?

Chapter 282, "Humiliation and the Formation of a New Army (Part 2)", is the clearest early answer because it turns Yang Gan's situation into a concrete plot event. The setup is Old Third, you've recently improved your basic strength quite a bit., but the pressure keeps building through Be honest with big brother, how did you, Li Hu, manage to do it?"....

1 answer
2026-06-11 08:13

Which chapter would you cite if someone asks for the most direct payoff tied to Ice Abyss?

Chapter 218, "Departure, Sending a Letter, Killing", is the clearest early answer because the violence around Ice Abyss becomes final instead of hypothetical. It opens with Long Mountain is located more than fifty kilometers to the west of... and closes on For the vast majority of Ice Abyss humans, over fifty kilometers is a.... The key payoff is that the danger stops being abstract and the conflict around Ice Abyss becomes immediate, forcing the surrounding cast to react under pressure.

1 answer
2026-06-11 08:13

Where in the first 1000 chapters does Xia Hong get its most concrete on-page development?

Chapter 184, "Leap in Productivity, Territorial Expansion, Xia Chuan's Opportunity", is the clearest early answer because it turns Xia Hong's situation into a concrete plot event. The chapter turns that into something concrete by moving from The first time to hunt an Intermediate Snow Mane, if I remember... to Leader..." Mu Dong intended to dissuade him but saw Xia Hong's face....

1 answer
2026-06-11 08:13

If I need a concrete chapter number for Dong Zhong, is Chapter 222 the strongest early answer?

Chapter 222, "Indecisive, Blood Guard Army, Sudden Turn of Events (2)", is the clearest early answer because it turns Dong Zhong's situation into a concrete plot event. The chapter gives readers a real answer by opening on Dong Zhong thanks the Young Lord for sparing his life." The trio of... and ending on Cold Resistance Level experts themselves are not afraid of arrows....

1 answer
2026-06-11 08:13

If I only want one chapter that proves why Hou Hu matters, should I jump to Chapter 289?

Chapter 289, "Crushing, Stalling for Time, Ning Yuan Hill's Decisive Victory", is the clearest early answer because it turns Hou Hu's situation into a concrete plot event. The chapter turns that into something concrete by moving from She had an impression of Xia Hong's strength. to Unlike Chen Yingyuan and Chen Peng, Xia Chuan looked at Xia Hong with....

1 answer
2026-06-11 08:13

What chapter gives the clearest reader-friendly payoff for Peng Bo in this early arc?

Chapter 232, "Saving Lives, Acting, Xia City in Uproar [8,000-Word Chapter, More to Come]", is the clearest early answer because the rescue effort creates visible on-page results. It opens with Hahaha, Master Hou is truly considerate, Wu is very grateful!" Wu... and closes on The masked person was none other than Yuan Cheng, who had just saved....

1 answer
2026-06-11 08:12

If I only reread one chapter to remember Chen Yingba's situation here, should I pick Chapter 231?

Chapter 231, "Investigating Yang Lu by Day—Whose Side Are We On?", is the clearest early answer because it turns Chen Yingba's situation into a concrete plot event. The chapter turns that into something concrete by moving from Wushuang and Hanqiong each have three Cold Resistance Levels. to Wu Xiong, Wu Ying, Han Jiuli, Wu Lin, it's those four!" The....

1 answer
2026-06-11 08:12

If I only want one chapter that proves why Yue Feng matters, should I jump to Chapter 195?

Chapter 195, "Jade Bone, Conclusion, Cultivation Dilemma", is the clearest early answer because it turns Yue Feng's situation into a concrete plot event. The chapter turns that into something concrete by moving from Xia Hong's entire body was still bulging with veins. to Yuwen Dao, Hong Guang, Meng Yi, Yue Feng, and over two hundred others....

1 answer
2026-06-11 08:12

What chapter makes Cold Beast feel plot-relevant instead of background detail?

Chapter 271, "Eliminated, Breakthrough Surge, Green Lotus Grass (2)", is the clearest early answer because Cold Beast finally turns buildup into a real advancement. The setup is Xiang Ping felt dizzy as he stepped off the stage., but the pressure keeps building through Since arriving in Great Xia at the beginning of the year and joining.... Once the chapter lands on Crucially, this is only in Xia City;

1 answer
2026-06-11 08:12
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h
i
j
k
l
m
n
o
p
q
r
s
t
u
v
w
x
y
z