webnovel

I would like to ask the meaning of the title of Shi Shuo Xin Yu and the criticism of later historians.

2024-09-13 04:06
one The original name was Shi Shuo, and I would like to ask the classical Chinese translation and meaning of Shi Shuo. Later, it was changed to "Shi Shuo Xin Yu." I would like to ask the explanation and significance of the title of "Shi Shuo Xin Yu." . two Some of the articles in the story of the world were accurate or even false. Some historians criticized the authenticity of this novel. How should they view this problem? Liu Zhiji pointed out in Shi Tong Cai Zhuan Pian that: "The miscellaneous books of the Jin Dynasty are not a family. For example, Yu Lin, Shi Shuo, You Ming Lu, and Search for Gods recorded in them are humorous and small debates, or gods and ghosts. This kind of thing is not a saint, Yang Xiong does not understand; His words disturb the gods, and Xuan Ni does not speak. The new history of the Jin Dynasty was written by the emperor, and most of them were used as books. What is the difference between the Wei Dynasty's Huanglan and the Liang Dynasty's Bianlue? They strive to be more beautiful and accumulate extensive knowledge to make contributions. Although they are used by villains, they will eventually be laughed at by gentlemen." The Biography of Fang Xuanling in the Book of the Old Tang Dynasty also records that in the Book of Jin compiled by Tang Dynasty,"Most of the historians are scholars of literature and poetry. They like to collect strange and absurd trivial things to spread different news. Moreover, the comments they make are gorgeous and not sincere, so they are often ridiculed by scholars." Wang Yinglin's "Difficult Learning Ji Wen" Volume 13 also said: "Liu Zhiji's" Shi Tong ":" The History of Jin "collected many small books, such as" Yu Lin,"" Shi Shuo,"" Search for Gods,"" You Ming Lu." Cao Jiazhi and Gan Bao's Ji, Sun Sheng and Tan Daoluan's Yangqiu are not suitable. There are many good things recorded in the book, and many are left behind. He also said: "The Tang Dynasty revised the Book of Jin. The authors were all poets. They abandoned Shi and Ban, and were close to Xu and Yu. Chao Zizhi also said: "History of Jin" is the most complicated. There were also stories such as Zhou Chu's rehabilitation, which were fabricated by people for various reasons, even to glorify someone. Zhengfang, please put forward a strong argument and personal opinion on the article. Opponents, please provide the wrong place of the world. (PS: Actually, I don't have any enmity with Liu Yiqing. I just want to write my review, so you don't have to be too professional.) Please point out any mistakes in the explanation.
2024-09-13 06:06

Shi Shuo Xin Yu was a work from the Eastern Jin Dynasty of China. The author was a writer, politician, and ideologist from the Northern and Southern Dynasties. Shi Shuo Xin Yu was a literary work with speech, behavior, and thoughts as its main content. It was known as a classic of ancient Chinese novels. The meaning of the title of Shi Shuo Xin Yu was that it was a novel that described the words and deeds of various characters in human society. At the same time, it was also a pronoun that represented people of different classes and identities in human society. Therefore, the title of Shi Shuo Xin Yu could also be understood as " worldly language " or " social speech." Later historians 'criticism of Shi Shuo Xin Yu mainly focused on the following aspects: 1. The content of Shi Shuo Xin Yu is false and lacks authenticity. Some historians believed that many of the contents in Shi Shuo Xin Yu were fictional and lacked actual examples and historical background. 2. He thought that the language in Shi Shuo Xin Yu was too exaggerated and lacked practical significance. Some historians thought that the language in Shi Shuo Xin Yu was too gorgeous and lacked practical meaning and philosophy. 3. The content of Shi Shuo Xin Yu is not conducive to historical research. Some historians believed that many of the contents in Shi Shuo Xin Yu were manifestations of social customs and fashions at that time, which had certain value for studying the social culture and historical background of that time. Generally speaking, the criticism and recognition of Shi Shuo Xin Yu by later historians reflected the historical environment and characteristics of the times. However, we must also see that Shi Shuo Xin Yu, as a literary work, has its unique charm and value in terms of language, thought and plot.

Latest Questions

Where does the novel turn Qin Xiaoxiao into something readers would actually remember later?

Chapter 11, "She Smiled, He Panicked", is the clearest early answer because it turns Qin Xiaoxiao's situation into a concrete plot event. A useful checkpoint is the way the scene starts with After a meeting, Shang Shaojing pinched the bridge of his nose,...

1 answer
2026-06-10 10:18

Where does the story give Yin Yang Theory a scene that actually changes momentum instead of just adding flavor?

Chapter 94, "Finally, Someone Comes to Calculate Affection!", is the clearest early answer because it turns Yin Yang Theory's situation into a concrete plot event. Early on, Jiang Li really has some skills, being able to figure that out." "Can.... By the end, Brother is going to dress you up;

1 answer
2026-06-10 10:18

What chapter-level takeaway best explains why "Chen Ying's New Discovery, Xia Yuning, and a String of Good News (Part 3)" matters for Li Xuanling?

Chapter 332, "Chen Ying's New Discovery, Xia Yuning, and a String of Good News (Part 3)", is the clearest early answer because it turns Li Xuanling's situation into a concrete plot event. The setup is Oh, I see, no wonder the captain had us bring iron picks and shovels..., but the pressure keeps building through With Zhu Yinhua around, it most likely means there really is a silver....

1 answer
2026-06-10 10:18

If I only want one chapter that proves why Cloud Dragon Army matters, should I jump to Chapter 308?

Chapter 308, "Shocking Turn, Grave Injuries, and Restless Hearts", is the clearest early answer because it turns Cloud Dragon Army's situation into a concrete plot event. The chapter turns that into something concrete by moving from Five people emerged from the crowd. to But judging by the loud noise when they hit the ground, those who....

1 answer
2026-06-10 10:18

If readers keep asking about Great Xia, is Chapter 323 the chapter you would send them to first?

Chapter 323, "Approaching Labor, the Talented Xiao Family Assembles Urgently", is the clearest early answer because it turns Great Xia's situation into a concrete plot event. The chapter gives readers a real answer by opening on Lin Lan spoke more and more proudly, and the three women beside her... and ending on Today's Xiao Family, with its own strength alone, is enough to secure....

1 answer
2026-06-10 10:18

What chapter gives the clearest reader-friendly payoff for Merit Birth in this early arc?

Chapter 76, "Who knows if there is poison inside", is the clearest early answer because it turns Merit Birth's situation into a concrete plot event. It opens with Thinking of this, the aunt repeatedly praised, "Girl, hearing your...

1 answer
2026-06-10 10:17

Why do readers treat Chapter 319, "Military Merit and Bestowal of Titles, Hearts Stirred", as a real turning point for Xia Hong?

Chapter 319, "Military Merit and Bestowal of Titles, Hearts Stirred", is the clearest early answer because it turns Xia Hong's situation into a concrete plot event. It opens with After Mu Dong finished explaining, he seemed to remember something... and closes on The more they participated, the more military merits they naturally....

1 answer
2026-06-10 10:17

Where does the novel turn Lin Manru into something readers would actually remember later?

Chapter 14, "She Looks So Cool Dancing with a Gun", is the clearest early answer because it turns Lin Manru's situation into a concrete plot event. A useful checkpoint is the way the scene starts with Lin Manru had a rare good night's sleep.

1 answer
2026-06-10 10:17

What chapter makes Lili feel plot-relevant instead of background detail?

Chapter 28, "Beaten Up Again", is the clearest early answer because it turns Lili's situation into a concrete plot event.

1 answer
2026-06-10 10:17

If I want the chapter where Mr stops being setup and becomes an actual event, which one is it?

Chapter 132, "Looking at me with that kind of eyes, are you afraid I'll eat you?", is the clearest early answer because it turns Mr's situation into a concrete plot event. Early on, The new girl in the live-streaming room went crazy..

1 answer
2026-06-10 10:17
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h
i
j
k
l
m
n
o
p
q
r
s
t
u
v
w
x
y
z