webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of ApproachingStorm in Carnal Cultivation

Xem lại chi tiết

ApproachingStorm
ApproachingStormLv134mthApproachingStorm

It started off looking like a good romance novel then outta nowhere my boy got NTR'd not my kinda novel but if Ur into that go ahead 😐

altalt

Carnal Cultivation

ASKeeling

Được 40 người thích

giống

Trả lời41

ASKeeling
ASKeelingTác giảASKeeling

I really wish there was some kind of notification when people left comments. I miss so many of these. Sorry for the late reply, that is the reason. Thank you for the well thought out comment as well. I actually do understand your point of view on this matter. I just don't agree with it. Let's view it from the self-insert point of view even. If I envision myself as the ML of a story, why would I want to be shackled to a FL that doesn't want me? If I wrote that version of the story it would bother me, and I'm sure a few others that picked up on it. I could have also simply not made her care if she could get stronger with other people. That too is limiting because it takes away a part of who the FL is. She isn't the type of person to just do something without a reason, even if that reason is one that others won't always like. So, that is the majority of the reasoning behind the choice. What we are left with is a fully informed FL who truly loves the ML. She denied it and ran from it briefly but in the end, she accepted and embraced it. I would much rather be the guy with that girlfriend than the guy whose girlfriend is only with him out of obligation or need.

ApproachingStorm:Author, after reading the comments that have come up while I was gone, I can see that you still don't get what I'm trying to say. It's simple really, the action of the FML kissing a man that isn't the ML isn't bad in itself, instead it's the context and the implications behind that kiss that make it unforgiveable to me. Let me elaborate. The FML being completely willing to kiss a random guy she doesn't know, just to test whether her powers can work with other men is a little annoying, especially since readers love to self insert into these novels. But that isn't the crux of the problem. The real problem is what that kind of action says about the FML, her mindset, and what she might do in the future. It tells us that she is someone who is willing to kiss other men than the boy she has feelings for (whether she realises those feelings or not) just to get back at the ML for making her mad at him. Essentially a cheater's mindset. And you as the author being able to write something like this into a character in a self insert novel only says bad things for the future of their relationship and the novel. Like the FML actually cheating next time cuz my boy doesn't have the relationship plot armour every other self insert protagonist has. And I personally, regardless of the author saying it won't happen again, won't take my chances on the sinking ship that is this novel. Finally, I would like to add that being willing to write a character that can get cheated on (to any extent whether they are in a relationship or not) is a sign of a good author because they can write more complex characters. So I actually commend you for being able to write that. But I was looking for a self insert novel, like most other readers, and this isn't it. Next time you write a novel, rather put it mainstream instead of on webnovel, as I see a lot of potential in your writing, or write one with regards to your audience (self inserts like me). Good luck with your novel, it's a shame that I won't be here to see the promising story progress.
ApproachingStorm
ApproachingStormLv13ApproachingStorm

Just hate read some more and cooled off and bro doesn't get cheated on again, not changing review cuz I'm mad that he just goes straight back to her after getting cucked. Also I know that they aren't 'technically' in a relationship yet so she isn't technically cheating but is it too much to ask for a romance novel heroine to not go out with another dude and kiss him whilst also having at least a physical relationship with mc?

BroBrigade
BroBrigadeLv3BroBrigade

author please confirm this comment, is this gentlemen saying the truth? I'm a simple guy, my heart can't take NTR. so imma put it on hold for now.

Justin_Brooks
Justin_BrooksLv13Justin_Brooks

He is saying the truth the author has a cuck fetish

BroBrigade:author please confirm this comment, is this gentlemen saying the truth? I'm a simple guy, my heart can't take NTR. so imma put it on hold for now.
ASKeeling
ASKeelingTác giảASKeeling

omg no I don't! there is a moment when the female lead kisses a boy that isnt the male lead. However, they are not a couple yet! I cannot stress that point enough! she is not cheating or cucking him because they arent a couple. and she only goes out with the guy once and she hates it!

driveknight
driveknightLv4driveknight

Cope out. Keep you cuck fetish to yourself.

ASKeeling:omg no I don't! there is a moment when the female lead kisses a boy that isnt the male lead. However, they are not a couple yet! I cannot stress that point enough! she is not cheating or cucking him because they arent a couple. and she only goes out with the guy once and she hates it!
Frosty_Cupcakes
Frosty_CupcakesLv4Frosty_Cupcakes

I agree with them author, why did you have to do the protagonist dirty like that.😔😔😔

ASKeeling
ASKeelingTác giảASKeeling

lol, this is hilarious. in chap 3, i almost kill him off, and it's fine. but a few chaps later, he walks in on a meaningless kiss, and the world comes to a screeching halt! i honestly love the interaction from readers. Thanks for reading as much as you did

Frosty_Cupcakes:I agree with them author, why did you have to do the protagonist dirty like that.😔😔😔
Sabaroth_zarkiel
Sabaroth_zarkielLv4Sabaroth_zarkiel

No update?

Frosty_Cupcakes:I agree with them author, why did you have to do the protagonist dirty like that.😔😔😔
Frosty_Cupcakes
Frosty_CupcakesLv4Frosty_Cupcakes

I am busy stock piling on chapters, I have received a contract invitation so do not worry, I am going to start updating the novel very soon.

Sabaroth_zarkiel:No update?
Sabaroth_zarkiel
Sabaroth_zarkielLv4Sabaroth_zarkiel

Congratulations on the contract

Frosty_Cupcakes:I am busy stock piling on chapters, I have received a contract invitation so do not worry, I am going to start updating the novel very soon.
Frosty_Cupcakes
Frosty_CupcakesLv4Frosty_Cupcakes

Thank you

Sabaroth_zarkiel:Congratulations on the contract
image
BridgeToHeavens
BridgeToHeavensLv3BridgeToHeavens

You tell him my man 😭😭😭

ApproachingStorm:Just hate read some more and cooled off and bro doesn't get cheated on again, not changing review cuz I'm mad that he just goes straight back to her after getting cucked. Also I know that they aren't 'technically' in a relationship yet so she isn't technically cheating but is it too much to ask for a romance novel heroine to not go out with another dude and kiss him whilst also having at least a physical relationship with mc?
Uskalski_Yuchiha
Uskalski_YuchihaLv3Uskalski_Yuchiha

good luck living life with your cuck fetish, maybe you'll become a great cucker and cuck out all your protagonists, have a wonderful cuck life

Frosty_Cupcakes:Thank you
image
Frosty_Cupcakes
Frosty_CupcakesLv4Frosty_Cupcakes

Uhh ... What are you talking about ?🤨

Uskalski_Yuchiha:good luck living life with your cuck fetish, maybe you'll become a great cucker and cuck out all your protagonists, have a wonderful cuck life
Uskalski_Yuchiha
Uskalski_YuchihaLv3Uskalski_Yuchiha

have a cuckerful life blessed with cuck

Frosty_Cupcakes:Uhh ... What are you talking about ?🤨
Co_Ala
Co_AlaLv2Co_Ala

Wait, do you have Ntr?

That_Annoying_guy
That_Annoying_guyLv3That_Annoying_guy

If your axing if this have ntr then yes the fl kisses someone

Co_Ala:Wait, do you have Ntr?
Sabaroth_zarkiel
Sabaroth_zarkielLv4Sabaroth_zarkiel

No update ?

Frosty_Cupcakes:Uhh ... What are you talking about ?🤨
Frosty_Cupcakes
Frosty_CupcakesLv4Frosty_Cupcakes

Really soon.

Sabaroth_zarkiel:No update ?
Saggs
SaggsLv11Saggs

I haven't the book yet. I saw this comment and was curious. Is the Mc in a exclusive relationship with the Fl? How far has the ntr gone? is it just kissing?