Daoist9177NN

Then why did it stop working against her in her second ascendance ?

Well that makes sense why it is good against humans but if it was the proof of Jesus of being human why does it have god slaying properties

Again why is her character having such strong opinions. I had pointed out the same thing with Iskander and I would point this out again. Why is there such a drastic change in her character ?? Is there some hidden lore that I missed. Is there an omake or something ?

Mash gives her master a perma defense just by existing Archer. She is doing her part very nicely. Btw Archer is chalked if any servant Archer better than him takes a shot some of them being Chiron, Hercules, arash etc. And pretty much anyone with presence concealment

Which brings me to another question how did she make the immortality fruit when she didn't have the authority over life like her counterpart.

The only 2 abilities we know it has are holy light and Its ability of ignoring defenses, but we don't really know its rank so there's that. And again kukuklan has the highest defense against reality bending shinnanegans, which these things count as

But ........... she doesn't have the heritage. That's the whole point of this discussion. She didn't inherit any divinity from her Proper history counterparts. The only thing they have in common is the name.

As far as we know it was a normal spear. Before Jesus was poked by it. So yeah it's a "normal" spear with a super mystery advantage from the blood and it's legends as far as we know. Not a god killer spear with extra spice added to it like u r imagining it. Definitely could be rebooted as everything is after a year or two in nasu verse but as of now it was a normal spear

It's an Au ability. But If it's like enkidu and it scales on divinity, then it works with divinity. That's it there's nothing more. Would it still work like a spear, yes. You can swing it, twirl it and stab with it so yeah it works like a spear. The same way enkidus chains work, they would still hold servants and still hit them. But they cannot "bind" someone without the scaling from divinity. They would just be some tough chains. And even those things are not absolute considering Hercules broke the chains even with A rank divinity

But why would it be same as the one in Naruto world. There are multiple iterations of Excalibur across hundreds of media most of them look somewhat different. So why would someone after seeing a weird orange sword just assume it to be one of the 3 blades??