Plastic or organic?

While her body is still recovering from her orgasm, I drop her to the floor and by dragging her by the hair I force her half atop the bed, her thighs against the side of the bed and her perky tits pushing on the mattress. I lay my already recovering cock between her ass cheeks and bend forward to cover her body with mine, then start whispering in her ear while my hands roam freely around her body, pinching a tit here, grabbing a butt cheek there, all the while my hips move slowly back and forth, sliding the length of my newly aroused cock in the valley of her ass.

"That was nice little girl, but dad wants more. I would love to stick my cock deep in you, but not yet. If I take your virginity, you won't be able to walk properly tomorrow and your stupid mother would nag at me. As for your asshole, let's see how it goes. As I say so, I use a hand to guide my cock gently to her asshole and start pushing it in slowly. Of course, I have no intention to take her like this, without prep and a good lubing, but my baby girl does not know that. Yet she does not shout the safe word to get the chance to clarify my intentions, instead she starts screaming again while sobbing,

"Nooo… dad, please!... no! It is to big! It huurts!... nooo… sob…".

Considering that not even half of my cockhead has penetrated her asshole, it is obvious that her words are part of her roleplay, still… hmmm…

I stop pushing forward and remain still, half my cockhead stretching her asshole and say the safe word.

"Strawberries. Honey, are you ok??

"…Y-yes daddy… you just surprised me, that's all. Daddy… are you… are you going to put it in?"

I can feel in her voice a mix of fear and anticipation, it seems that my little girl is a tad excited at the thought of her daddy raping her ass during roleplay… good to know, I might be able to use it in the future to make her accept trying something she is shying away from, but for now…

"Now, now, honey, as lovely as your little butt is and as tempting your butthole looks with my tip inside it, it would hurt you too much without preparation. Trust in daddy, honey, daddy knows what he is doing."

"Yes daddy! I trust you! Please go on."

Having received her okay, I return to roleplay mode.

"Hmm, your asshole feels great, little bitch. Too bad my cock is too big to just ram it inside. I mean, I could, but you would probably spend a couple of days in bed… sigh, very well, you got lucky today so no ass-raping with my cock for now."

I move my hips back, causing my cock to disengage from her asshole and bounce erect atop her ass… then I stick a finger deep in her puckering hole.

Ella tenses and her head whips up and turns to look at me,

"Hiiii… dad… you… you said…"

I grin at her expression,

"I said I would not ass-r.ape you with my cock, I never said I would not use something else to do the job…"

As I say so, I add a second finger inside her asshole and start thrusting in and out.

"Aaah… dad… ouch… stop… noo… sob… please…"

"Uh? Why should I stop? You belong to me, my lovely little bitch, so I will do whatever it pleases me…"

I start thrusting faster and deeper with my fingers, enjoying her screams and sobs of despair…

I stop to look at my little girl, bent as she is over the bed with her ass exposed and tears glistening her eyes. I chuckle and extend a hand to reach my discarded clothes, and after a bit of rummaging I manage to extract my "tools" from the pockets. Her asshole is already somewhat dilated by my fingers, so I skip to the second sized plug directly, one inch by five. I put it on the bed to her side so she can see it as I say,

"This little toy will act as my cock today, baby. I hope you will enjoy it; I am sure that I will."

Ella looks at the plug and an expression of horror fills her eyes.

"Dad! No! … It's too big. Nononono… sob… please….".

"Oh? It's either that or my cock, my lovely little bitch. Tell you what, since you gave me such a stellar blowjob, daddy will let you choose? Plastic or organic?"

Ella looks at me in confusion while the tears keep dropping non-stop.

"Dad? What do you mean… ?"

"It's easy, dear. You can choose whether you want dad to stick the buttplug in your ass or you prefer his big fat cock. I mean, your opinion matters to me…"

Ella is completely horrified now,

"Please dad, don't. I want neither. Please let me go. I promise I will not say a word. I will be a good daughter… I… I will suck you whenever you want…"

I laugh at her and slap her ass, causing her to yelp.

"Oh honey, of course you will suck me whenever I want. That was never in question. But this and that are two different things. Either you choose, or I choose for you. And I believe you know what my choice would be…"

As I say so, I move my hips causing my cock to rub the valley between her ass cheeks.

"Dady… sob… please stop… please…"

I grab my cock and guide the tip to her asshole, then I push it in gently until half the glans is once again inside her.

"Choose now, honey. Last chance before the cock express departs on its exciting journey!", I say, while I nudge my cock another couple of millimeters in.

"Dad… sob… I… I… I… sob… the plug…"

Her last words are barely audible, so I decide to tease her again.

"I can't hear you honey; did you say the cock? Are you sure? It will hurt a lot…", I push a little bit more in, now my cockhead is almost entirely inside her and she hisses, probably feeling some pain.

"N-no, dad… I said… the plug."

I keep teasing her, moving my hips back and forth, causing my cockhead to exit almost completely from her starfish and re-entering again.

"Honey, dad is tired of your games. Either you tell me right now in a clear voice what you want and beg me for it, or I am going to ram my cock completely inside your ass until my balls slap your buttcheeks. I will count to three… One…"

"No!... I w-want the plug…"

"Two…"

"Dad? I said… I want the plug?"

"Three…", I gather force in my hips and I am ready to nail my cock inside her before she finally realizes where the problem with her words lies.

"Dad… I want the plug. Please stick the plug in my ass, dad, I beg you".

I put a sad expression on my face, and ask her,

"Are you sure, honey? Dad would love to stick his cock in your asshole. I mean, I am sure that it will be tight and it will hurt, but I really, really, want to stick it in you. Should I…?"

My baby girl panics,

"No! Dad! I want the buttplug! Please, take the buttplug and stick it in my ass, please dad!"

Hehe, her words are almost making me cum. I sigh theatrically and plaster a look of disappointment on my face.

"Oh, very well, I did tell you that I would let you choose. I didn't expect you to beg so much for it though? I mean, did you fall in love with the plug as soon as you saw it? Is it the color perhaps? Never mind…"

Please support me

https://www.p@treon.com/PinkCulture