webnovel
xNoReadNoLifex
xNoReadNoLifexLv51yr
2022-11-27 16:37

So far it is a nice concept. But chapters are too short. Additionally, MC is dumber than a rock. I hope this helps. Suggestions: Make mc think through his actions or explain why he is as dumb as he is. Develop the chapter by putting more detail when describing. Hope this helps

Liked by 2 people

LIKE
Replies4
dogassnetorare
dogassnetorareAuthor

dumb? the protagonist literally hasn't done anything yet, why is he dumb?

xNoReadNoLifex
xNoReadNoLifexLv5

Whoa you don’t see it. Just Whoa. Okay. The setting is game of thrones. Strength should not be the dominant factor when everyone already knows Walter is old and weak. He could have easily used that to make people underestimate him while he increases his other stats. Furthermore, he should have summoned the hero first, looked at their stats and then picked a stats to increase. Additionally, spending every bit of store point before even finding out how to obtain more on a consistent basic is not smart. That is why I called him dumb. Unless of course you want to use his actions as some sort of character development. There is more but I think I would bore you with them. PS: I don’t know how to write. Especially not write a fanfic like your that have an interesting plot. Please don’t take this as an insult. I just wanted to give a detail review for once.

dogassnetorare:dumb? the protagonist literally hasn't done anything yet, why is he dumb?
bored_6
bored_6Lv4

dumb is not a word I would use. it looks slightly like he is rushing due to panic.

xNoReadNoLifex:Whoa you don’t see it. Just Whoa. Okay. The setting is game of thrones. Strength should not be the dominant factor when everyone already knows Walter is old and weak. He could have easily used that to make people underestimate him while he increases his other stats. Furthermore, he should have summoned the hero first, looked at their stats and then picked a stats to increase. Additionally, spending every bit of store point before even finding out how to obtain more on a consistent basic is not smart. That is why I called him dumb. Unless of course you want to use his actions as some sort of character development. There is more but I think I would bore you with them. PS: I don’t know how to write. Especially not write a fanfic like your that have an interesting plot. Please don’t take this as an insult. I just wanted to give a detail review for once.
xNoReadNoLifex
xNoReadNoLifexLv5

Humm. What panic?

bored_6:dumb is not a word I would use. it looks slightly like he is rushing due to panic.
Related Stories

Game of Thrones: The Odd-Fish

Our protagonist was in the real world a teenager whose not-so-shitty future was crushed when he was diagnosed with a disease from which he had almost no chance to come out alive. As expected, he didn’t beat the odds and died. But that wasn’t the end. As you have probably guessed (if you have read the tags), death offered him a second chance. A chance to live again… in a world of swords, kings, and dragons. Reborn as William Tully in the year 263 AC, one year after Robert Baratheon's birth and thirty-five years before the beginning of the events of Game of Thrones, William is no ordinary nobleman. He is the son of Brynden Tully, the man who, in this altered timeline, never became the 'Blackfish'. Giving in to the pressures of his older brother Hoster, Brynden married, and through this union, William was born. One thing that didn't change in this version however; The Riverlands remain as fragmented and overlooked as ever, a land known for the pragmatism and the resilience of its people, the richness of its soil, nourished by the numerous rivers that weave through the land, but never its power. But William has plans. Armed with memories of his past life, the knowledge of what's to come and (not too OP) wishes, he isn’t content with the Riverlands being a mere footnote in Westerosi politics. His ambitions soar far higher. His goal? To turn the Riverlands into a mighty kingdom, one that commands respect, fear, and prestige far beyond its reputation as the forgotten 'sage child' of Westeros. In this story, you will follow William as he maneuvers his way through the dangerous political landscape of Westeros. He will forge alliances, make enemies and challenge the very balance of power in a world where the game of thrones spares no one. Alongside him, familiar and new faces, some canon, others invented, will shape his journey into an uncertain future, where the Riverlands could rise to greatness, fall into flames, or both. --- Schedule: Three chapters a week for now, one on monday, one on wednesday and one on friday. Feel free to share your honest review on this fanfiction and shower me with those delectable power stones! I haven’t launched my Patreon yet, but get your free membership now to stay in the loop (even through I will defenitely mention it between chapters when something's going on there): https://www.patreon.com/Barbare. As for Discord, I don’t have a dedicated server for this fanfic yet, but it’s definitely coming soon!

Barbare · TV
4.9
17 Chs