Korean Film Review" Silence " was a remake of the China film " Witnessed by the Nation ". It was different from the original in many aspects.
In terms of narration, it abandoned the original concise and logical expression. It was too slow in explaining the background of the characters, and it dealt with the death of the actress at the heart of the movie carelessly. In terms of character setting, the two characters with very different personalities in the original version were combined into one character played by Park Shin Hye. This unreasonable setting made the character seem ambiguous. Unlike the original version, where the three people were evenly matched, the Korean version of Cui Minsik's aura was too strong, making the characters of Park Shin Hye and the prosecutor seem like cameos.
However, this movie was also unique. For example, the scene where the lights were turned on after the "Truth" was played in the court in Thailand was quite impressive. It was named " Silence," which emphasized the state of the person involved after the tragedy. This state also reflected the attitude of most people after experiencing or watching the whole story, such as the president's evasive eyes when facing his daughter, the unreadable eyes of the driver uncle when he handed over the keys, and the silence of the daughter when she was protected by her father. The style of the entire film was more delicate, suitable for film critics who were used to slowly savoring it.
" The Silent Eyewitness " novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Eyewitness Korean Film ReviewYou only said the words " Korean Film Review of the Eyewitness ", but you didn't give me any specific review content. Please give me the complete review content of the Korean film " Eyewitness " so that I can consolidate and polish it.
" The Silent Eyewitness " novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Korean drama eyewitness reviewEyewitness was a controversial Korean film.
In terms of merit, Korean directors were more "standard" in directing crime topics and were good at grasping the effective points. For example, in the plot setting of the film to create a tense atmosphere, such as the hand that reached out when the elevator door was about to close, the shadow that rushed quickly when the door was about to close, and the scene where the murderer secretly opened his eyes on the balcony after turning off the lights, even if the audience had a premonition that this was a horror scene deliberately set up by the director, they would still be emotionally affected when watching it. It could be seen that the director had a strong ability to deal with such scenes.
However, the flaws of the film were also very obvious.
Firstly, there were many problems with logic. The logic of the second half of the movie collapsed severely. In The Pursuit, it was understandable for the audience to feel aggrieved by the incompetence of the police because the police did not have a god's perspective. However, in The Eyewitness, this grievance reached the level of insulting intelligence. For example, the surveillance camera could not be seen clearly when the murderer killed at night, and the surveillance camera still failed when he killed the female witness during the day. When the male protagonist was chased downstairs by the murderer, his wife and children were fooling around beside him, the guard left his post without permission, and he did not dare to tell the truth when he met the police. A group of policemen went to the house to catch people and were blown up. The murderer directly chiseled the window and left. The setting of these plots greatly reduced the logic of the film.
Secondly, there was a lack of character creation. The protagonist Han Sanghun's ability to deal with a crisis was hard to understand. As the pillar of the family, he should have called the police to provide clues when he witnessed a murder, but he chose to hide the truth to please the murderer to protect his family. This approach lacked logic. It was more like ignoring rationality to create a tense atmosphere. Moreover, the movie was unclear about the murderer's motive. From the beginning, the audience knew who the murderer was, but did not analyze his motive in depth. In the end, the detective only said that the murderer had no motive and liked to kill. This was difficult for the audience to accept. They felt that the film lacked in-depth exploration.
In addition, the film also revealed some social problems, shifting from the focus on murder to human emotions and sociality. However, it was still difficult to cover up the collapse of the second half of the plot. Originally, it had hoped to reach the height of The Pursuit, but in the end, it became a third-rate crime film.
" The Silent Eyewitness " novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
Eyewitness Korean Film Review DoubanThe Eyewitness received a rating of 6.2 on Douban. Some film critics pointed out that the film directly attacked the cold side of human nature. Although some of the audience did not like the cowardice of the male lead, felt that there were logical problems in the plot, that the motives of the characters were not valid, and that the movie was made up of hard coincidences, some people felt that it was a bad movie. However, there were also people who felt that it captured the true thoughts of most people and had a certain value.
" The Silent Eyewitness " novel is equally exciting. Everyone is welcome to click and read it!
The grammar was horrible but the story was great. Was this some chinese/korean novel that you stole from the site cuz many dialogues were plain stupid?