webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of TeaTop in Reincarnated as Draco's Twin To Dominate Hogwarts

Review detail

TeaTop
TeaTopLv125mthTeaTop

The translation is full of garbage. Talk about ruining my immersion and this fic is up there. Clearly the author couldn't be bothered to check whether things lined up.

altalt

Reincarnated as Draco's Twin To Dominate Hogwarts

Scaramousse

Liked by 52 people

LIKE

Replies9

Salmon_El_Solomon
Salmon_El_SolomonLv3Salmon_El_Solomon

I can bet all my money that the name of the original is something like Xiao Malfoy or something Chinese, but he is the son of Narcisa and Lucius

Clay_Champion:say that after you see the mtl version.
Transhumanist
TranshumanistLv14Transhumanist

Sorry to say translation kinda sucks. The MC's personality leaves a lot to be desired too.

Woutt
WouttLv2Woutt

I think the translation is fine its not good but its okay, the only thing that annoys me is that MC wants to 'restore' the honor of his family name.

Propht
ProphtLv4Propht

I simply came to write this one thing but then I saw your review and I can’t help but wonder why you thought their would be any immersion with a name like Skylor malfoy? I mean it’s a small thing but I just can’t help but be a little upset every time I read a bad name in a fic. Sorry to the author but I mean cmon.

Clay_Champion
Clay_ChampionLv5Clay_Champion

say that after you see the mtl version.

Clay_Champion
Clay_ChampionLv5Clay_Champion

lmao.Yeah, his name is something evil in Chinese xD "Xie something?" The spells are Chinese as well in them. I dunno what they do in china (referring to movie dubs), i think they rename everything to their cultural counterparts etc.

Salmon_El_Solomon:I can bet all my money that the name of the original is something like Xiao Malfoy or something Chinese, but he is the son of Narcisa and Lucius
Salmon_El_Solomon
Salmon_El_SolomonLv3Salmon_El_Solomon

No no no, if you read right, all the others names are correct, only the mc is wrong, the mc is the only Xiao Lin in the Malfoy family

Clay_Champion:lmao.Yeah, his name is something evil in Chinese xD "Xie something?" The spells are Chinese as well in them. I dunno what they do in china (referring to movie dubs), i think they rename everything to their cultural counterparts etc.
Clay_Champion
Clay_ChampionLv5Clay_Champion

🤔 I don't remember much of it now, but sometimes, the mtl called Cho Chang some other Chinese name because of her mysterious Chinese grandfather xD. (If this fic is the one where mc awakens his "Malfoy bloodline related "spiritual heritage", then ya, in it some specific names become inconsistent sometimes. Somewhere around 100+ chapters had his names as evil spirit or Xie something)

Salmon_El_Solomon:No no no, if you read right, all the others names are correct, only the mc is wrong, the mc is the only Xiao Lin in the Malfoy family
midgetydeath
midgetydeathLv3midgetydeath

That's pretty arrogant and stupid. Though, it's on the head of whoever made that corporate decision. That might be why Chinese HP fanfics treat the shield charm as if it's some sort of form-fitting protective forcefield. I think the direct translation was given as "Iron Armor Charm". Such a mistake would, therefore, be understandable. For someone who never read what it does in the books, forgot, or otherwise didn't bother doing the slightest research on it.

Clay_Champion:lmao.Yeah, his name is something evil in Chinese xD "Xie something?" The spells are Chinese as well in them. I dunno what they do in china (referring to movie dubs), i think they rename everything to their cultural counterparts etc.