webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Lemman_D in When Doomsday Comes, I Can Upgrade My Refuge Infinitely

Review detail

Lemman_D
Lemman_DLv142yrLemman_D

it's a good novel but you're being forced to pay for chapter's which is illegal sense it's using copyrighted characters in it from both marvel and DC which is highly illegal so don't expect this novel to be worked on much longer especially now when Disney has started to double down on their copyrighted work. it doesn't matter if you're just using the names like Iron man, hulk,spiderman, batman, frozen man and Venom. i mean come on someone with basic copyright knowledge knows this.

altalt

When Doomsday Comes, I Can Upgrade My Refuge Infinitely

Xuanting_Official

Liked by 38 people

LIKE

Replies19

Helios_Sol
Helios_SolLv5Helios_Sol

so true

Shadow_Mongrel
Shadow_MongrelLv13Shadow_Mongrel

In this books he is making unrelated machines and such and simply giving them a name in relation. that's not copyrighted. Now if he actually made a suit, gave it an AI name Jarvis, and then made a reactor to power it? then yes you would be may correct. There's no such thing as a copyright of a name only. it has to be in representation as well.

Shadow_Mongrel
Shadow_MongrelLv13Shadow_Mongrel

as an example I could make a gas station and name it walmart and there wouldn't be any issues for copyright or business. This is because the gas station doesn't represent or copy anything of the grocery store of the same name. I hope this clears that up for you.

Shadow_Mongrel:In this books he is making unrelated machines and such and simply giving them a name in relation. that's not copyrighted. Now if he actually made a suit, gave it an AI name Jarvis, and then made a reactor to power it? then yes you would be may correct. There's no such thing as a copyright of a name only. it has to be in representation as well.
HitThat007
HitThat007Lv14HitThat007

this doesn't work since walmart has gas stations. people would think this gas station is connected to those gas stations actually linked to walmart

Shadow_Mongrel:as an example I could make a gas station and name it walmart and there wouldn't be any issues for copyright or business. This is because the gas station doesn't represent or copy anything of the grocery store of the same name. I hope this clears that up for you.
Shadow_Mongrel
Shadow_MongrelLv13Shadow_Mongrel

Anyone who has ever been to Walmart knows that the gas station is called Murphy. So a gas station called Walmart is still a viable name so long as the design doesn't imitate the commercial store's letter font and yellow star.

HitThat007:this doesn't work since walmart has gas stations. people would think this gas station is connected to those gas stations actually linked to walmart
Deyego
DeyegoLv13Deyego

loophole

Shadow_Mongrel:Anyone who has ever been to Walmart knows that the gas station is called Murphy. So a gas station called Walmart is still a viable name so long as the design doesn't imitate the commercial store's letter font and yellow star.
Moe_Cyan_Pile
Moe_Cyan_PileLv3Moe_Cyan_Pile

an actually good loophole. has the same energy as naming an agricultural company as Samsung.

Deyego:loophole
humanGaMuR
humanGaMuRLv12humanGaMuR

Thats not true, the name itself is copyrighted, do you really think they will leave such loophole. Also even if you could claim it good luck in defending the claim against Disney, hope you have couple of years and lawyers to spare

Lemman_D
Lemman_DLv14Lemman_D

it's nice to see that people knows about the loopholes in copyright law but you're forgetting the most obvious thing in the novel that no form of loopholeing :p can protect you from the author describes the robots to there comic book,game,cartoon and movie counterparts like a robot that looks like batman one like spiderman and so on as soon he used the descriptions and then chose to give the same names to the robots so when the author decided to put a payment wall on the chapters he's selling copyrighted material :)

DarkestCalling
DarkestCallingLv14DarkestCalling

no the names are trademarked to u can use the names for fanfiction but you can't use them to make a profit it's why you dont see toys comics movies or other things that have iron man as the name on anything that has even passing similarities besides he had a drone turn into an iron man armour named it iron man only difference is weapons and it doesn't have Jarvis still looks the same and named the same

Shadow_Mongrel:In this books he is making unrelated machines and such and simply giving them a name in relation. that's not copyrighted. Now if he actually made a suit, gave it an AI name Jarvis, and then made a reactor to power it? then yes you would be may correct. There's no such thing as a copyright of a name only. it has to be in representation as well.
Mathdebate
MathdebateLv1Mathdebate

selling chapters on webnovel with copyright names would count as copyright infringement. this is illegal

DarkestCalling:no the names are trademarked to u can use the names for fanfiction but you can't use them to make a profit it's why you dont see toys comics movies or other things that have iron man as the name on anything that has even passing similarities besides he had a drone turn into an iron man armour named it iron man only difference is weapons and it doesn't have Jarvis still looks the same and named the same
Mathdebate
MathdebateLv1Mathdebate

dude. name copywriting is a big thing. its just clled trademark. Business names, product names, logos and labels can all be trademarks. You acquire a trademark by using your mark in commerce—in other words, using it when you conduct your business. This applies to movies and related franchises.

Shadow_Mongrel:In this books he is making unrelated machines and such and simply giving them a name in relation. that's not copyrighted. Now if he actually made a suit, gave it an AI name Jarvis, and then made a reactor to power it? then yes you would be may correct. There's no such thing as a copyright of a name only. it has to be in representation as well.
Shadow_Mongrel
Shadow_MongrelLv13Shadow_Mongrel

I posted the exact link to copyright laws in these comments which specifically say that copyright laws do not apply to a name of any kind. and yes trademark does apply. BUT only applies to a business' logo, design, or wordmark, in a likeness to the original business. ex; "Walmart" with a very distinctive yellow star next to it. read and learn something before arguing for Christ sake.

Shadow_Mongrel
Shadow_MongrelLv13Shadow_Mongrel

a trademarks only purpose is to keep another business entity from using licensed trademarks or designs as a name for another product not produced by the original company. for example. a "book" called IronMan is not ok. but a "character" named Ironman is completely fine. because the author isn't making money off of a fictional character. he is doing so by the book named 'whatever'. I hope this makes sense to you all.

Shadow_Mongrel
Shadow_MongrelLv13Shadow_Mongrel

as another example you can Google yourself. There is an Ironman brand by the World Triathlon Corp. again, copyright of a name does not exist.

TheDemonNazI
TheDemonNazILv4TheDemonNazI

nah you would still be sued for all your worth

Moe_Cyan_Pile:an actually good loophole. has the same energy as naming an agricultural company as Samsung.
Visayan
VisayanLv14Visayan

This example is actually a violation and a cause for infringement because it violates the law for trademarks and trade-names. Copying another business' registered name, even though you have different type of business, causes confusion, which is the basis for infringement.

Shadow_Mongrel:as an example I could make a gas station and name it walmart and there wouldn't be any issues for copyright or business. This is because the gas station doesn't represent or copy anything of the grocery store of the same name. I hope this clears that up for you.
Ouroberos_Mark
Ouroberos_MarkLv4Ouroberos_Mark

I feel disappointed about how MC change his behavior suddenly. I drop this such a pity it's all good at first.

Wobyanga
WobyangaLv13Wobyanga

Started out a bit well with a different take on doomsday shelter. Overall, there are many issues with this book that it's not worth someone's coins Dropping it.