webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of YesTer in Invincible Colorless Butler

Review detail

YesTer
YesTerLv22yrYesTer

Sorry about this, mate. Volume 1 (which I call the introductory volume) was just horrible; the pacing was way too fast, barely any world-building, character design was 2D and "character development" didn't make any sense whatsoever, and the romance (or romance development) was simply garbage. I get that you want to do a character arc for them but that's not how you go for it. I, for one, barely care for any of the characters, much less the MC. So if I don't care for the characters, why should I care if they develop? It's about making us care that they will develop. You barely touch upon the relationship between him and his master and the other princesses too then you added that random one-sided romance, then everything (if there was any) was gone thanks to that war and he left everyone, while others were in fear and in awe of his abilities, he suddenly gained a random obsessive love interest thanks to a DESTINY which we had no idea about since we didnt KNOW about it. I read volume two but I just didnt care anymore about the previous characters in volume one, aside from the obsessive princess. Much less when you added more characters that still has no personality; in fact, now you're simply using cliches in your characters like the arrogant prince. Hope they-- and I mean everyone from volume 1 and 2--will actually have character arcs, because they are what makes up a story. The same goes for the MC. My overall point is: I couldnt care less for your novel or how the story will turn out because you, as the author, couldnt write a proper reason for me to stay, specifically in terms of characters.

altalt

Invincible Colorless Butler

Nzr150cc

Liked by 10 people

LIKE

Replies2

Nzr150cc
Nzr150ccAuthorNzr150cc

Thanks for your opinion, this is the first novel I made. I admit there are a lot of flaws here. Your opinion is invaluable for improving my novel in the futurešŸ™

YesTer
YesTerLv2YesTer

I realized this just now but I'm sorry that my review came out as rude or cold, especially at the last part. I really didn't intend to. Your story idea is actually pretty interesting but the execution of it just wasn't resonating. That's what I wanted to say at the last part. Sincerely hope this improves and keep doing your best!

Nzr150cc:Thanks for your opinion, this is the first novel I made. I admit there are a lot of flaws here. Your opinion is invaluable for improving my novel in the futurešŸ™