Review Detail of Weyri in A swordsman in TBATE
Review detail
One of the worst TBATE fanfic I have ever read, it's empty most of the time, the author just do whatever he wants without caring about the story. If you write for your pleasure ok but don't post it then, you just made me waste my time.
A swordsman in TBATE
Embra
Liked by 6 people
LIKEReplies7
Igris_69:... are you serious man ? who do you think you are? A prince or a president? I remind you that it is you who decided to read this fan fiction, it is your fault, not that of an author. go down a bit.
You mean, I'm supposed to know whether I will like a fan fiction before reading it? Wow, such a genius you are. I can admit I was a bit harsh after reading the author's comment, I'm too used to author that just don't want bad reviews and says if you don't like don't read, for him, it seems he really tries and for that I apologize to him. But you, you just shout nonsense, my mistake doesn't change my opinion on the story, and just how can I know if I will like when the synopsis is just one line long and explain nothing?
Igris_69:... are you serious man ? who do you think you are? A prince or a president? I remind you that it is you who decided to read this fan fiction, it is your fault, not that of an author. go down a bit.
I have nothing against the fact that you do not like this fan fiction, it is your mean character that I do not like. And tell me? what nonsense I wrote? but if you realize the harsh words you used, I apologize for the written words as well.
Weyri:You mean, I'm supposed to know whether I will like a fan fiction before reading it? Wow, such a genius you are. I can admit I was a bit harsh after reading the author's comment, I'm too used to author that just don't want bad reviews and says if you don't like don't read, for him, it seems he really tries and for that I apologize to him. But you, you just shout nonsense, my mistake doesn't change my opinion on the story, and just how can I know if I will like when the synopsis is just one line long and explain nothing?
Okay let's not go too far and talk calmly then, I mean by nonsense is that you said it should be the fault of the reader for reading, if you read a story where the title and synopsis tell you something, and you get nothing of it in the story is that your fault? I DON'T say that it's the case here I took an extreme for example, but still only one line of synopsis, I don't find it to be right, I just start reading think it's good, get attached to the story but end up falling from high which is the reason for why I had so much salt.
Igris_69:I have nothing against the fact that you do not like this fan fiction, it is your mean character that I do not like. And tell me? what nonsense I wrote? but if you realize the harsh words you used, I apologize for the written words as well.
I agree that the whole "its your fault not the author's" bit was stupid on the other guys part, but you were also being a bit of an *sshole for saying that the author "wasted your time" by posting the novel. If you didn't like the novel you could've done any number of things rather than slam the author for POSTING the novel. You could have 1) gave constructive criticism on what you didn't like about the novel 2) simply left a rating and said it "wasn't something you enjoyed" or something to similar affect 3) Left a bad rating with a bunch of spam words and looked like a bot 4) Left without saying anything or leaving a rating but instead you chose to bash the author for daring to "waste your time" (which, it really couldn't have taken very long to read a couple chapters and decide you didn't like it, could it?) for posting a novel that they wrote(in hindsight you did leave SOME criticism, even though it was a bit more negative than necessary, kudos for that) So yes, both of you were kinda wrong, but you were MORE wrong. Also, I apologize if any of this sounds weirdly aggressive or condescending, I am terrible at writing replies that don't come off like for some reason
Weyri:Okay let's not go too far and talk calmly then, I mean by nonsense is that you said it should be the fault of the reader for reading, if you read a story where the title and synopsis tell you something, and you get nothing of it in the story is that your fault? I DON'T say that it's the case here I took an extreme for example, but still only one line of synopsis, I don't find it to be right, I just start reading think it's good, get attached to the story but end up falling from high which is the reason for why I had so much salt.
Kamikage_1774:I agree that the whole "its your fault not the author's" bit was stupid on the other guys part, but you were also being a bit of an *sshole for saying that the author "wasted your time" by posting the novel. If you didn't like the novel you could've done any number of things rather than slam the author for POSTING the novel. You could have 1) gave constructive criticism on what you didn't like about the novel 2) simply left a rating and said it "wasn't something you enjoyed" or something to similar affect 3) Left a bad rating with a bunch of spam words and looked like a bot 4) Left without saying anything or leaving a rating but instead you chose to bash the author for daring to "waste your time" (which, it really couldn't have taken very long to read a couple chapters and decide you didn't like it, could it?) for posting a novel that they wrote(in hindsight you did leave SOME criticism, even though it was a bit more negative than necessary, kudos for that) So yes, both of you were kinda wrong, but you were MORE wrong. Also, I apologize if any of this sounds weirdly aggressive or condescending, I am terrible at writing replies that don't come off like for some reason