webnovel
YaGa
YaGaLv143yr
2021-07-12 16:24

I don't understand the logic of this fanfic. the author made a random orphan(I have no problem with them mind you) a no THE RIVAL to our mc who apparently has cheat similar to a system and is showing the mc as moron and wats more infuriating is that the mc is following the other kid like a lost puppy. This fanfic had sooo much potential but it was wasted it went down the drain just because author did not want the mc to be number 1 and give him a unrealistic rival and makes the protagonist dumb and stupid.

Liked by 119 people

LIKE
Replies28
RK9
RK9Author

I am sure I mentioned this somewhere, but I plan for Joseph to have a bigger role in the story. And he has what could be considered a cheat too, but it's different. I will explain it in the story when that topic comes up. As for the MC following the side character around, I admit I made a mistake. I got sidetracked Also, I have now tagged the novel as Slowpaced and World Building. And I mentioned the MC was an adult, but I did not portray that correctly as I am not an adult. But since I don't want to change it, it's going to be an adult that sometimes acts childish.

YaGa
YaGaLv14

dude honestly I think you should really consider rewriting the fic it has potential but the early mistakes make it dull. you even have the chance to rewriting it due to having less than 40 chapters. it might seem harsh but this fic has potential and if you rewrite it without mistakes it could become a masterpiece. just take this as a advice no pressure .

RK9:I am sure I mentioned this somewhere, but I plan for Joseph to have a bigger role in the story. And he has what could be considered a cheat too, but it's different. I will explain it in the story when that topic comes up. As for the MC following the side character around, I admit I made a mistake. I got sidetracked Also, I have now tagged the novel as Slowpaced and World Building. And I mentioned the MC was an adult, but I did not portray that correctly as I am not an adult. But since I don't want to change it, it's going to be an adult that sometimes acts childish.
RK9
RK9Author

Thank you for your advice. I don't think I am going to rewrite this though, because despite the mistakes I made earlier, I like where the story is at and is going. Hence I would like to continue. Also, the story is and always was going to be slow-paced, and it will continue. I am sorry to hear your thoughts.

YaGa:dude honestly I think you should really consider rewriting the fic it has potential but the early mistakes make it dull. you even have the chance to rewriting it due to having less than 40 chapters. it might seem harsh but this fic has potential and if you rewrite it without mistakes it could become a masterpiece. just take this as a advice no pressure .
YaGa
YaGaLv14

na as you said you aren't an adult do for a kid or teen this is a good start and as for my thoughts well honestly you are writing so do whatever you want people can give suggestions but ultimately its up to you to decide what to write and what not to write. I may dislike the fic but regardless of my personal opinion best of luck buddy and make mc a little more serious it would be honestly better.

RK9:Thank you for your advice. I don't think I am going to rewrite this though, because despite the mistakes I made earlier, I like where the story is at and is going. Hence I would like to continue. Also, the story is and always was going to be slow-paced, and it will continue. I am sorry to hear your thoughts.
YaGa
YaGaLv14

man gotta admit that as much as I don't like the way you write the plot and people but you are dedicated to this. I mean you post 4 to 5 chapters a day. as much as I don't like the fanfic personally your dedication is something else. Mad respect to you

RK9:Thank you for your advice. I don't think I am going to rewrite this though, because despite the mistakes I made earlier, I like where the story is at and is going. Hence I would like to continue. Also, the story is and always was going to be slow-paced, and it will continue. I am sorry to hear your thoughts.
_ShiningMoonLight_
_ShiningMoonLight_Lv15

Why don't you write a story then? Seems kinda stuck up your own a*s telling the author to rewrite the story just cause you don't like it even though he explicitly stated it's going to be a slow story and he has other thinks planed. Also he said he writing this just for fun so he can write how he want.

_ShiningMoonLight_
_ShiningMoonLight_Lv15

Wow 1 to a 10 in a instant must have got on your nerves seems like you can't take what you dish out lol.

YaGa
YaGaLv14

wait I didn't snap did I?? nope I didn't .

_ShiningMoonLight_:Wow 1 to a 10 in a instant must have got on your nerves seems like you can't take what you dish out lol.
YaGa
YaGaLv14

well someone here has a inferiority complex that they themselves admit that they are loser.

_ShiningMoonLight_:Wow 1 to a 10 in a instant must have got on your nerves seems like you can't take what you dish out lol.
YaGa
YaGaLv14

and did you expect someone to not reply when you first provoke them dude get serious. and yes I do get a kick of of this.

_ShiningMoonLight_:Wow 1 to a 10 in a instant must have got on your nerves seems like you can't take what you dish out lol.
_ShiningMoonLight_
_ShiningMoonLight_Lv15

Ok "petty tough" guy. First off you spazzed out from me calling you a a*s must have bruised that fragile of yours. Next you called me a uneducated idiot acting superior and your telling me you don't have a ego? Also I have a hard time seeing how I didn't hurt your feelings you replying. So let's sort out how you present yourself. Your a self appointed petty person you get joy out of making fun of others and you have the overcompencated ego to back up all your insecurities. Anyway I'm out now can't be bothered to respond anymore today I'll let this comment brew rent free in your head knowing your going to read this because petty people can't stand not getting the last say lol.

AaronchifV2
AaronchifV2Lv14

You seen genuinely hurt

_ShiningMoonLight_:Ok "petty tough" guy. First off you spazzed out from me calling you a a*s must have bruised that fragile of yours. Next you called me a uneducated idiot acting superior and your telling me you don't have a ego? Also I have a hard time seeing how I didn't hurt your feelings you replying. So let's sort out how you present yourself. Your a self appointed petty person you get joy out of making fun of others and you have the overcompencated ego to back up all your insecurities. Anyway I'm out now can't be bothered to respond anymore today I'll let this comment brew rent free in your head knowing your going to read this because petty people can't stand not getting the last say lol.
ExReality
ExRealityLv2

Ah, It's another one of those "Write your own story" r*tards. The guy was clearly stating advice in good faith. He never forced him to rewrite. Did you even read the author's reply? He clearly stated he has NOW added the Slow pace and World Building Tags Which meant it wasn't there in the first place. A review section is to critique, give opinions and suggestions. What your saying is that someone who hasn't made a novel shouldn't critique another novel. That's how stupid your statement is.

_ShiningMoonLight_:Why don't you write a story then? Seems kinda stuck up your own a*s telling the author to rewrite the story just cause you don't like it even though he explicitly stated it's going to be a slow story and he has other thinks planed. Also he said he writing this just for fun so he can write how he want.
Virtuosso
VirtuossoLv14

I do't mind Josph being a rival, but if he has also cheats like him, whats the difference between him and mc! its like watching a watered down version

YaGa
YaGaLv14

yes exactly someone finally understood. rivals are there so the protagonist could overcome them and leave them in dust but here it felt that Joseph is the protagonist. because author himself said that he has some cheats as well. that's the problem.

Virtuosso:I do't mind Josph being a rival, but if he has also cheats like him, whats the difference between him and mc! its like watching a watered down version
Kailour
KailourLv6

How is that a problem? Have you never read a multi reincarnation story, or a multi transmigration story where the MC has to deal with OTHER reincarnaters / transmigraters? And you explained it just now in THIS reply. Rivals are there for the protagonist to overcome. If it was easy, wouldn't it be pointless?

YaGa:yes exactly someone finally understood. rivals are there so the protagonist could overcome them and leave them in dust but here it felt that Joseph is the protagonist. because author himself said that he has some cheats as well. that's the problem.
Mortifer
MortiferLv14

Oh good thing I didn't read this one without checking. Would probably end up regretting reading and rage ranting on reviews.

RK9:I am sure I mentioned this somewhere, but I plan for Joseph to have a bigger role in the story. And he has what could be considered a cheat too, but it's different. I will explain it in the story when that topic comes up. As for the MC following the side character around, I admit I made a mistake. I got sidetracked Also, I have now tagged the novel as Slowpaced and World Building. And I mentioned the MC was an adult, but I did not portray that correctly as I am not an adult. But since I don't want to change it, it's going to be an adult that sometimes acts childish.
IronM
IronMLv4

What you said is just the first event of the story. And if you don't know what this fanfic is about? Well it's about the world of Pokemon, not about ash and well, the *main* story but about burns the MC the author is writing. The kid (MC) acting dumb, like a kid I don't see what's wrong with that. for all you know the mc with the adult soul could be trying to blend into what he is, which is a kid, and he's could be just acting like one. Even if the author may have had made a mistake, he could just add some word like *man it's easy to act like a kid again* and the whole event will look normal and maybe make the MC look like a good actor.

YaGa
YaGaLv14

dude have you rreadthis fanfic to chapter 40 at least cause after that I have given up on it and once you read it till there you will understand what I mean to say. So first read the fanfic and then reply the comment.

IronM:What you said is just the first event of the story. And if you don't know what this fanfic is about? Well it's about the world of Pokemon, not about ash and well, the *main* story but about burns the MC the author is writing. The kid (MC) acting dumb, like a kid I don't see what's wrong with that. for all you know the mc with the adult soul could be trying to blend into what he is, which is a kid, and he's could be just acting like one. Even if the author may have had made a mistake, he could just add some word like *man it's easy to act like a kid again* and the whole event will look normal and maybe make the MC look like a good actor.
YaGa
YaGaLv14

yep someone finally understood what I ment to say bro. and I have to say that OPM fanfic you are translating is very funny dude and with zero grammatical mistakes. gotta say keep it up dude.

ExReality:Ah, It's another one of those "Write your own story" r*tards. The guy was clearly stating advice in good faith. He never forced him to rewrite. Did you even read the author's reply? He clearly stated he has NOW added the Slow pace and World Building Tags Which meant it wasn't there in the first place. A review section is to critique, give opinions and suggestions. What your saying is that someone who hasn't made a novel shouldn't critique another novel. That's how stupid your statement is.
Other Reviews
Related Stories