webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of GooseOverlord in The Guardians' Throne - The First Magic Swordsman

Review detail

GooseOverlord
GooseOverlordLv152yrGooseOverlord

The fact that the MC is 10 ruins the immersion, I could get behind these things happening to 14-15 year olds but 10 is just too young. What kind of bow could 10 years olds use to kill with or without training. Bows are not something someone can pick up and just use in that manner. Everything gets solved if there is a 4 year time skip before the first guarding mission. The other issues of using the wrong word here and there dont matter as much. Wheres the hook, we were promised someone to protect but this may as well be forgotten. The first chapter ends up as a mess, is this a scene that happens in the future or was this from a previous timeline. I liked the idea but my expectations were subverted and at this point I have little desire to continue reading.

altalt

The Guardians' Throne - The First Magic Swordsman

ExSoldierLv99

Liked by 29 people

LIKE

Replies9

boov
boovLv5boov

for how many chapters is he 10

GooseOverlord
GooseOverlordLv15GooseOverlord

I quit close to ch 150 and was still a kid

boov:for how many chapters is he 10
Aimdoo
AimdooLv14Aimdoo

When does he meet the one he's supposed to protect?

GooseOverlord:I quit close to ch 150 and was still a kid
Tyson_1102
Tyson_1102Lv14Tyson_1102

I haven’t read it but I saw a comment saying something in between 330 and 350

Aimdoo:When does he meet the one he's supposed to protect?
Capt_Eye_Collector
Capt_Eye_CollectorLv4Capt_Eye_Collector

350

Aimdoo:When does he meet the one he's supposed to protect?
Sraptor69
Sraptor69Lv2Sraptor69

didn't birth of the demonic sword have him do his first mission around 10?

GooseOverlord
GooseOverlordLv15GooseOverlord

I just reread some of the early chapters of that book, the main difference here is that the mc is still treated like a kid, a kid in a cultivation world, but a kid none the less. But even a cultivation novel wouldn’t send a group of children to defend a town

Sraptor69:didn't birth of the demonic sword have him do his first mission around 10?
Sraptor69
Sraptor69Lv2Sraptor69

spose so

GooseOverlord:I just reread some of the early chapters of that book, the main difference here is that the mc is still treated like a kid, a kid in a cultivation world, but a kid none the less. But even a cultivation novel wouldn’t send a group of children to defend a town
GooseOverlord
GooseOverlordLv15GooseOverlord

Keep in mind that I haven’t read this in over a year and Birth was likely 2-3 years ago. My tastes have add time to develop in that time.

Sraptor69:spose so